Guild Security

by Shiri

Back to Ideas.

Shiri2007-07-23 02:10:46
Please make GAs either have security privs like GMs/GCs or make them able to be appointed as security.
Krellan2007-07-23 02:21:40
agreed
Gwylifar2007-07-23 19:17:15
What's worse, if you were Security when you got made GA you still carry security privs, but if you're GA first, there's no way to become appointed Security other than stepping down and then recontesting for your own position. This makes no sense at all. Malicia and I wrestled with this long ago and even Lisaera couldn't cut through the Gordian knot.
Isluna2007-07-23 19:56:18
QUOTE(Shiri @ Jul 22 2007, 08:10 PM) 427799
Please make GAs either have security privs like GMs/GCs or make them able to be appointed as security.


Please? pray.gif

Yeah Isluna isn't in leadership anymore, but it would really help all those who are now and in the future.
Aison2007-07-23 22:49:00
QUOTE(Gwylifar @ Jul 23 2007, 12:17 PM) 427926
What's worse, if you were Security when you got made GA you still carry security privs, but if you're GA first, there's no way to become appointed Security other than stepping down and then recontesting for your own position.


No. Aison was Security before she was GA and she lost all her Security privs. She can't get them back, either.
Forren2007-07-23 23:06:20
Agree. Please give Admins security privileges.
Jasato2007-07-24 00:43:03
I'd have to agree. I'm not entirely sure what GA's have access too (besides doing Admin stuffs for the guild) but it'd be helpful for those to have guard and "ripple/flux" abilities
Unknown2007-07-24 11:23:36
Agreed. Please either give them security privs or enable them to be appointed security. pray.gif
Unknown2007-07-24 12:54:05
I think giving them security privs would be a confusion of their role. It makes sense for Champions to have security privs (defenders of the land and all that) and for GMs (they are the commune leaders, and make defense decisions on behalf of the commune). Security issues don't really fall under the role of the Administrator.

That said, I do think it should be possible for the GA to be appointed to Security. I think they're two different roles, but there is no reason the same person can't do both.
Gwylifar2007-07-24 14:03:17
QUOTE(Aison @ Jul 23 2007, 06:49 PM) 427968
No. Aison was Security before she was GA and she lost all her Security privs. She can't get them back, either.

Hmm, either I was misinformed then, or things have changed (for the worse).