So, I've made a website for the local church, and I am, unfortunately, extremely unskilled with graphical design. I was told they'd try to get some local talents for it, but so far (about two years later), no such luck. Thus, I'm hoping you guys can help me a bit.

In essence, I'm looking for a button and a frame. The image of the button I've got in my head is a simple slanted button, possibly with a feather on the right side. It should be fairly clean, without any color fading or an overly fancy frame; a bit of shadow along the edge should mostly do the trick, I think. The frame should also be clean; just a basic line with shadows added. The website can be found here, where you can get a general idea of what I'm looking for. I'm always up for other ideas though (and comments on the general design. I can code with one arm tied behind my back, but don't ask me to actually design anything!)