good job, a post

tis a miracle

1. ATM I'm leaning Ssaliss/Jack/Xikue. The Jack/Xikue alignment comes from several things. One early post on the part of Xikue. My accusation. Their defense.

2. Why I think we should base our vote on scumhunting and playstyle, not any possible scumgambit.

3. You dont know. But common sense dictates it. I'm working on it. You cant always hit scum 100% of the time. When there is only ONE PLAYER scumhunting in the entire game, rest assured he's probably town. I'm the only person trying. The rest are just useless speculators for the most part, awaiting death at the hands of mafia.



claim: buttman

lol. one and a half people

ayisdra got vigged by vendetta

rika should have never claimed doc and she should have posted more.

hardly a record of lynching thousands of townies

:censor:

claim: buttman

Well, first, I didn't say "lynching". I said "pointing your finger". Also, earlier you said I was most likely town. What made you change your mind?

Your recent posts.

:censor:

claim: buttman

Speculating isn't useless, that's how you get things done in a mafia game, especially one that's sparsely moderated like this. In a game like the last one I ran, when I was pushing up deadlines left and right (the topic only got to like... 11, 12 pages), your playstyle would be a godsend - jumping on people, pressuring them, forming swift bandwagons to force claims, like you did on day one. But in a game where we have all the time in the world to moderately and intelligently come up with targets, all you succeed in doing is muddying the waters and creating a sense of claustrophobia.

Look at the facts:
You've failed to catch a single scum so far, not a single person you've voted for has ended up being mafia.
Your erratic posting style is alienating people, meaning any good points you come up with are skimmed or ignored. (Like you yourself said, a wall post of this calibre from you would be ignored entirely on the assumption that it would consist of nothing but attacks.)
When people agree with you, you seem to think that's coo', you're totes town bro, but when people agree with others you start seeing this web of suspicion and collaboration, like you are with me/Ssaliss/Xikue/Phoebus/whoever the hell else happens to be scum today.

Enlighten us, oh master of this thread, as to what those things are. It'd also be nice to know how Ssaliss is scum, because I really haven't seen anything proving him too much either way, though I'm getting a town vibe from him and that's basically what you've been working off too, right? Instincts and vibes?

There's also a difference between hitting scum 100% of the time and not hitting scum at all.

I wouldn't say you're the only person participating, I'd say you're posting every second you get.

Hey so am I

italics

incorrect



whats intelligent about anyone's posting here. nobody has even tried. misrep/fallacy



what have you done



i didnt vote for razenth bro



imma scary alien



you seem to be implying that everything i say i actually believe. intentional miscomprehension of scumhunting to frankenstein me more

jack is scum

:censor:

claim: buttman

So what, you're like the BFG now? "What I means and what I says is two different things"? If you're deliberately saying wacky :censor: in order to force scum from the woodwork you can't really blame people for being confused by it.

@Ilyssa

I'm going to re-read the thread later tonight, I'll give you something nice and answer your post then.

:censor:

claim: buttman

Unfortunately, throwing names around as "scummy" without any kind of substantial backing isn't, apparently, very effective. You voting for me or blaming me certainly won't flush me out.

ssaliss you are so massively noobish and scummy at the same time

my brain is so confoosed

:censor:

claim: buttman

I'm going to a barbecue tonight, so on the off-chance a train forms on me all choo choo, gimme a chance to come back & defend myself beforehand.

What in Hezmana. I take one nap and there's two pages of frelling fluff. Looks more like trolling than scumhunting.

The only obvious townies are Akeley and Llesvelt. Either Jack or Bali (turning on Llesvelt when he cleared you?) is scum. Ssaliss is inching up along the scale. Not lifting my finger of suspicion from Phoebus (although she's not returning until tomorrow evening.) Ilyssa gets squinty looks from me, but I think Llesvelt's results will figure which of the two trolling thoddos are scum.

Pretty much everyone but Akeley gets squinty looks from me at this point.

Speaking of which, he hasn't been posting now that he's been put in.

OK, i'll join the hunt.
Both Jack and Bali seem off to me, but it might just be their post counts and tiffs. I am generally agreeing with Xikue, and Ilyssa seems more town than Ssaliss to me. Phoebus is lurking too much for me to form an opinion, really, except for her yelling at people. I'll have to reread so i can back up my feelings, though. Post later.

Back from the barbecue
So druuuuunk

itliacs

Okay, I am back.

Anyways, I investigated Jack, and it says he flipped the :censor: out. Just that, nothing else. Approx "Jack FLIPPED THE :censor: OUT"




Jews smell funny.

It doesn't sound like his frelling flipping out was done in a funny manner. Sounds like a fair indicator that he's one of the scummmy thoddo we've been looking for. About frelling time.

VOTE: JACK