Overly Offensive Mafia

by Casilu

Back to The Real World.

Jack2011-08-11 16:58:37
QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Aug 11 2011, 04:57 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Probably because I pointed my finger that way first, and Akeley and Phoebus jumped on the bandwagon.

That doesn't convince me of Xikue's scumminess, then, I'm afraid. I'm still most suspicious of Phoebus atm. I'm pretty sure she didn't claim resurrection until I mentioned my own skill, which has "opportunistic" painted on it. I'm torn on voting for her, though, in case she isn't bluffing and we're completely screwed over by her death. We hafta be cautious in LyLo.
Unknown2011-08-11 19:28:10
Frelling Unofficial Check
Xikue (0):
Ilyssa (3): Akeley, Ssaliss, Phoebus
Ssaliss (1): Xikue
Jack (1): Llesvelt

Yotz. There's frelling cautiousness and then there's frelling inactivity. Why so quick to protect Phoebus when there aren't any votes on her, Jack?
Jack2011-08-11 19:31:59
Uh, why bother voting at all if I'm not convinced it's the right thing to do? If I voted for her and a bunch of people bandwagon'd (which wouldn't happen anyway, everyone's being a pussy atm), I'd only have to remove my vote again to stand by my conviction.
Ssaliss2011-08-11 19:35:44
I removed my vote earlier, actually.
Unknown2011-08-11 20:18:54
Oh Yotz.

What in Hezmana. Too Much Frelling Unvoting Check
Xikue (0):
Ilyssa (2): Phoebus, Akeley
Ssaliss (1): Xikue
Jack (1): Llesvelt

To Ssaliss, what's this push for activity when you haven't voted?

QUOTE (Jack @ Aug 11 2011, 03:31 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Uh, why bother voting at all if I'm not convinced it's the right thing to do? If I voted for her and a bunch of people bandwagon'd (which wouldn't happen anyway, everyone's being a pussy atm), I'd only have to remove my vote again to stand by my conviction.


Sorry. What's it that's the right thing to do? I assumed it meant lynching Phoebus, but then frelling removing your vote wouldn't make sense to stand by your conviction to lynch her.
Ssaliss2011-08-11 20:21:00
Activity and voting has little to do with eachother. I'd rather see how situations unfurl before committing my vote.
Unknown2011-08-11 20:31:35
QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Aug 11 2011, 04:21 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Activity and voting has little to do with eachother. I'd rather see how situations unfurl before committing my vote.

That's not how you were using your vote earlier this frelling long day phase. What made you decide you had to be more committed with your vote now?

(Yotz. What in Hezmana. Frell.)
Unknown2011-08-11 21:39:42
I've been making annoyingly vague comments about not being able to die all game, Jack. suspicious.gif
Ilyssa2011-08-11 21:43:31
Xikue, Jack, I'm being cautious because it's LyLo. 0_0
Ssaliss2011-08-11 21:55:04
The votecount only strengthens my suspicions that Phoebus, Akeley and Jack are in this together. Otherwise, the scum would have won already; all they would need to do is to pile on three votes on either one, and they'd get a lynch. With that in mind,

Vote: Jack
Jack2011-08-11 22:01:41
QUOTE (Phoebus @ Aug 11 2011, 10:39 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I've been making annoyingly vague comments about not being able to die all game, Jack. suspicious.gif

Vague enough that I haven't picked up on it. All I got was "lynching me's a bad idea, don't do it", which could be for any number of reasons - I assumed you were an outsider role, prob'ly a bomb, initially.

QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Aug 11 2011, 10:55 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
The votecount only strengthens my suspicions that Phoebus, Akeley and Jack are in this together. Otherwise, the scum would have won already; all they would need to do is to pile on three votes on either one, and they'd get a lynch. With that in mind,

Vote: Jack

I can understand suspecting me (though I stand by my assertion that there's something wrong with Llesvelt's investigative ability), and I agree that Phoebus is pinging on my scumdar... but I don't see how you can, in good faith, incriminate Akeley. He's been pretty much the most useful townie since he joined up. What makes him scummier than you? For that matter, what makes him scummier than Xikue and Ilyssa?
Ssaliss2011-08-11 22:03:35
I've already explained my reasonings a while back.
Unknown2011-08-11 22:06:28
What in Hezmana? To Ilyssa, I don't think I accused you of anything directly. Although you could be more vocal.

To Ssaliss, Jack may be a scummy thoddo, but voting for someone who has been proven to be unlynchable when we're in frelling LYLO is not helpful. I'm not convinced you've the town's interests in mind.
Ssaliss2011-08-11 22:09:05
I very much doubt that anyone is actually immune to lynching. One-time protection? Perhaps. Although if any scum have such a power, they have won already.
Jack2011-08-11 22:15:19
It's a stupid power for a scum to have, which is why I allowed myself to be lynched yesterday, and even participated in the voting. I assumed everyone would lay off me today as a result, and I'd be put amongst the ranks of proven townies (which, with Bali gone, comprises me and Akeley) - apparently not.
Unknown2011-08-11 23:14:35
But for censor.gif's sake, I'm not scum. If you lynch me and we lose because of it, I can't wait to see the looks on your faces when you see my role being exactly what I've been saying it is this whole game.

I'm still 100% certain that there was no kind of trickery in Casilu's answers as they were presented to us. Why? Because it's freakin' Casilu. She's going to do whatever will cause the most confusion regardless of how OP it is, and knows that mafia players are paranoid as censor.gif. She's probably sitting there all "JUST AS PLANNED" while everyone is assuming that the answers meant the opposite of what they said, or even, in the case of Ssaliss, assuming that the person who asked the questions, despite being our greatest asset, is scum because it JUST CANNOT BE TRUE!!!

PROTIP: Yes-it-can-and-probably-is can be true. And now Ssaliss is going to be like YES I KNEW IT PHOEBUS JUST PROTECTED AKELEY, YOU SSSSSCUM. No I just think you are stupid stupid dumb idiot stupid bluh bluhhh and don't want you to be trying to get our most useful confirmed town person lynched

Just censor.gif lynch Ilyssa already. If Ilyssa isn't scum I grant you permission to make fun of me endlessly.
Ssaliss2011-08-11 23:20:50
Of course, if you are scum and Ilyssa is town, lynching her is exactly what you want us to do.
Jack2011-08-11 23:53:23
QUOTE (Phoebus @ Aug 12 2011, 12:14 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
But for censor.gif's sake, I'm not scum. If you lynch me and we lose because of it, I can't wait to see the looks on your faces when you see my role being exactly what I've been saying it is this whole game.

Agreed. If we assume you're not bluffing and you have a rez power, that's a stupid ability for a scum to have, so you're probably town. And if you ARE scum and STILL have a rez power (which would still be stupid, but possible in a game these weird)... lynching you would STILL be of no use to the town, since you'd come back tomorrow anyway and lose us the game - necessitating, at least, the lynch of a different member of the scum today. So I'm definitely crossing you off the list of people to vote for, alongside Akeley, who's the most useful member of town atm due to his day-proccing Star Power.

QUOTE
I'm still 100% certain that there was no kind of trickery in Casilu's answers as they were presented to us. Why? Because it's freakin' Casilu. She's going to do whatever will cause the most confusion regardless of how OP it is, and knows that mafia players are paranoid as censor.gif. She's probably sitting there all "JUST AS PLANNED" while everyone is assuming that the answers meant the opposite of what they said, or even, in the case of Ssaliss, assuming that the person who asked the questions, despite being our greatest asset, is scum because it JUST CANNOT BE TRUE!!!

I disagree with this, though, and not just because her answers incriminated me. I think it would be stupid for the mod to hand the town such an easy victory, particularly so late in the game and after such a poor showing from us - it'd be too cruel to the scum (who, credit to them, have kept their heads down). So I'm not taking the answers at face value.

I'm honestly getting kinda suspicious of Ssaliss, atm. Why are you so intent on calling out Akeley as scum? I think he's the one person here who's really cleared his name. I can see you being suspicious of me and Phoebus, for our duplicated powers alone, but I'm 100% sure that Ake's on the up-and-up.
Ssaliss2011-08-11 23:57:28
I find it interesting that you listed two possibilities with Phoebus, Jack, and both were that she was telling the truth about her resurrection power. I find it far more likely that she does not, in fact, have a resurrection power, and the only real reason to lie about that is if she is scum. Why I'm so suspicious of Akeley? I've already said why several times now. Feel free to look back on the last few days to see my reasoning.
Jack2011-08-12 00:34:40
QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Aug 8 2011, 02:00 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Hmm. This makes no sense at all. According to Akeley's questions, Phoebus should be town. However, her mannerisms indicate that she is on the other side. Likewise, by the process of elimination, Xikue would have to be an opponent, but hardly seems to be. And it could not be that we simply assumed that the wrong statements were true, or it would be even more backwards. According to someone (it slips my mind), whatever remains when everything else is eliminated must be the truth. As such, the only conclusion I can reach is that Akeley is scum, even though it certainly sounds strange.

huh.gif

QUOTE (Phoebus @ Aug 8 2011, 02:25 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm going to pull a Bali here and say that you're censor.gif stupid.

The mod just told us who was scum and what you've garnered from it is "the question-asker's allegiances are a lie! The answers are nothing!"

ohyeah.gif