Imperian was the first MUD I had ever played and I chose the Idras. They were the biggest to me.

They were pretty bad from a newbie perspective - that's elitist Imperian 'RP' for ya But the skills were great.

Actually... after a bit of reconsidering (and realizing that there were guilds that I hadn't considered...) here we go.

LIEK MY REAL LIST KTHX:

1) Sentaari (Achaea)
2) Idras (Imperian)
3) Wardancers (Imperian)


Wow. I'm a combo whore!

I loved all the snake guilds on Achaea.

And what I saw of the Idras.

I never did get to see any of the Saboteurs because they were so darn elitist. Psh.

Bards in Imperian rock! Especially with all their skill changes. It is hard to beat them at role play too, in my humble opinion.

1) Serenguard
2) Runewardens
3) Any Achaean Snake Guild


Runewarden's would have been first, but I was ultra annoyed with their GM (for personal reasons) until their new one, but I havent really been back since.

They are also, from what I am told, are one of he all time hardest guilds to advance in. Take Terenas for example. He would be one of, I think five (probably less) that have been knighted in my characters 30+ years in the Runewardens.

So I'm a few days late, nyah What's a few days?

1) Serpentlords (Achaea). I still miss them lots. Were really going downhill when I quit, though I hear they're better now.
2) Arcanists (Achaea). Miss them almost as much. Just less people to miss cos I spent less time with them even though they treated me much better. Bad Lusternia... bad me for coming to Lusternia
3) Serenguard. Can't be absolutely sure, but hey, I like what I saw so far.

Hmm.. Well, I really have to go with my parent guild on this one. We had so many things going on the Gods just kinda quit on us and took a few years off I think. We didn't have uber skills, large numbers, or a large amount of history to go back on like here in Lusternia, but I have to say the Infernals of Aetolia did pretty good for a Guild that's whole existance seemed to be for the whiners of the old Infernal Guild who didn't want to be Mhaldorians. I mean, face it, Aetolia was a poor mans Achaea with little support and a gimmick. So, my list.

From Aetolia-
1. Infernals
2. Luminaries
3. Sentinels

From Achaea-
1. Arcanists
2. Monks
3. Snakes

From Imperian
1. Idras
2. Wardens
3. Bards

From Lusternia
1. Ur' Guard
2. Paladins
3. Geomancers- Grr, we have a great history. Roleplay on it!

My favorites are:

Imperian Bards
Arcanists
Jesters could be fun, but I have zero time for their probation so I have quickly lost interest. I really hate jumping through probation hoops, very annoying for someone with limited gaming time.

So far I'm trying out different guilds in Lusternia and trying to find the best fit

Ha! What did I tell you? Imperian Bards reign supreme.

Heh. Anyone else who has played all the games willing to give their opinion of the Guilds from each game?

Dude easily best guild have to be:

Serenguard (Lusternia)
Sylvans (Achaea)
Monks (Achaea)

Draeld

Serenguard = teh s00k.

IDRAS! = teh r0xx0r.