I voted Moondancer, though I think Serenguard would be tied with them. I am biased of course, we all are... but it also means we know our individual strengths and weaknesses. I just think Moondancer weaknesses far overpower their strengths. You may disagree. *shrug*

Geomancers would run a close third, I think... though from my experience if they are in their demesne they aren't too bad.

Edit: Um, what the hell? Why on earth are Nihilists or Ur'guard still there? Evil Objectivity - Die!

Funnily enough, that is how the poll was shaping up. Moondancer, Serenguard and Geomancer all leading.

So if a Nihilist chooses tarot, he shouldn't have any decent offense at all? I fail to see the logic.

Why not just give it two choices, Geomancer and Nihilist? That'd be a completely unbias poll.

His thread, his poll.

Stupid moderators and their bias.

But it would be fair to list all guilds, if the voter argues their reason.

So far - despite the fact that I even voted Nihilist - Nihilist has 0 votes.

Your vote doesn't count then! Damn overpowered Nihilist!

...erk. Sorry, Jack, that must've been when I reshuffled, I lost count. (You've got to cut and paste the options, and the numbers don't come with them. Let me adjust that for you.)

And what, biased moderators? What biased moderators? >_< I'm doing what the poll was originally meant to be, in theory, even though that's not an accurate picture. I've done a better poll over there.

Damn my wretched, overpowered capabilities!

Damn my cosmicfire, and the absurd ease it allows me when bashing!

Damn my sacrifice, and the ease with which I can pull it off!

And most of all, damn my Wrack! Unlike toadcurse, it is an instant kill, as long as I'm fighting someone without a mana vial and legs!

(To Terenas. Damn bot and it's damn posting. )

Sh, Jack, I put your vote back.

Frghgle.

I still think we should do what Jelaludin suggested, and let him be a Moondancer while Tuek + Narsrim relocate to the Nihilists.

Hmm, is the Celestine count right? Before I posted, they were on zero, and now they're on five?

Meh, doesn't really matter I suppose, this isn't a sensible thread anymore. Someone want to move it to Idiots?

I don't think Nihilists are the weakest class, anywhere close, they are far better then Paladins, Serenguard and Geomancers.

Quite frankly I agree, Silvanus, but they're the weakest Guardian archetype. And I'm not having more votes for Celestines than Nihilists.

D'oh, how did I put Celestines on 5? *mutters reshuffling* Daganev, don't do these things again, it messes with my head. *changes Celestines votes back to 0* And no, it's not a sensible thread, but TECHNICALLY it's not a rant either, so Idiots isn't really appropriate.

Damn bot!

Stop making me paranoid!

Anyone that votes for a Guardian class, is just stupid.

Shiri... put aquamancers on 20, and nihilists on 746.

I resent that, however true it may be.

..

Don't think so, Elryn, the poll's messed up enough as it is. Just go vote in the other one.

I don't know much about Serenguard, but I do really feel that Geomancers are at least the weakest Mage class. We have phantom and stalker, and runes with fuse, but Harstone has runes, Aquamancers have illusions, so that doesn't set us apart. It's really the fact that in terms of effects from the demesne, we don't compare.