My vote for Shoshana was not out of the blue.. look at a few posts before that, and you'll see why I voted for Shoshana.

As of now, I have no idea who I think is a Soulless. I don't see anyone really trying to twist anything around (except for Daganev, who was just in self-denial about the 5 Soulless voting for him).

Therefore, I'm placing my vote on Erion. Even if he isn't a Soulless, he's bothered to only post once and doesn't care for t he game.

If I were a soulless, I'd try to stay out of the big picture.

Edit: Plus, Erion wants the Seer to PM those who he thinks is an Elder God. If he PMs those who he thinks is an Elder God, someone could just be posing as an Elder God, and the whole plan will fall apart easily.

Actually, I think what Erion meant was for the Seer to PM those _verified_ to be Elder gods. Which isn't too bad a plan, if only the Seer had some way to convince those getting PMed that the Seer is a real Seer.

Good point.

Or maybe some of us know for sure that whatever reason Nyla is voting for me, it isn't because he's seen that I'm a Soulless. He may or may not be a Seer, but if he is one, he certainly hasn't PMed Shamarah about me.

I'd bet on his being a Soulless. Let's see if he survives the night eh?

The log thus far if anyone's interested.


N1
Kaervas dead
D1
BobStar by Soll
Silvanus by Eldanien
BobStar by Erion
Daganev by Silvanus
Summer by Nyla
Daganev by Etanru
Daganev by Veonira
Daganev by Gaetele
Nyla by Nayl
Silvanus by Jalain
Eldanien by Shoshana
Daganev by Jack
Shoshana by Silvanus from Daganev
Shoshana by Eldanien from Silvanus
Eldanien by Etanru from Daganev
Shoshana by Erion from BobStar
Etanru by Bobstar
Silvanus by Soll from BobStar
BobStar by Summer
Eldanien by Jalain from Silvanus
Shoshana by Daganev
Shoshana dead
N2
Nayl dead
D2
Silvanus by Daganev
Silvanus and Eldanien by Jalain (whichever more)
Erion by Summer
Summer by Erion
Silvanus by Gaetele
Summer by Jack
Summer by Nyla
Daganev by Soll
Soll by Eldanien
Silvanus and Daganev by Summer (whichever more) from Erion
Jack by Etanru
Yrael or anyone by Daganev (whichever more) from Silvanus
Nyla by Eldanien
Erion by Silvanus

I'll vote for Nyla. I'm also iffy on Jack.

Can people explain their reasoning? I mean, Nyla voted for Nayl (or some other way) because their name was similar.

Actually, _Nayl_ voted for Nyla.

Nyla voted for me. Both times. With no explanation.

Unless of course, you're a Soulless and that was a slip of the tongue, where Nyla voted for Nayl in the night *grin*

I'm iffy on you, bub.

And you still haven't mentioned why you didn't include Erion in your list. He voted for Summer too, if I'm not mistaken..

Actually, all things considered, switching my vote over to Nyla instead.

Shamarah, if there's a tie, do both live, or do both die?

I don't see any reasoning that Nyla is a Soulless.

I have just read the whole thread.

This game is based mainly on the Seers. There are two Seers, or one, or none. If there are none, there is no real chance of the Elder Gods winning. So, assuming that Erion is not a Seer, and that I am not a Seer, who ever the seer actually, is, since you know if you are a Seer, verify people with Sham until you find an Elder God. Once you find an elder god, keep that in your knowledge, and attempt to keep votes off of them. If we get down to one Seer, 5 Elders and 5 Soulless, the Elder's still have a chance to win.

The Seer's are the only ones who can truly know if someone is an Elder God or a Soulless God.

SEERS: If you get a PM from a supposed Seer saying who one of the Elder's is, CHECK THEM! If you two find each other, it will be easier to accomplish the goal you have with the Elder's and Guardians.

Silv there is no reasoning for ANYbody to be a Soulless God, the Seers will just have to wing it, and hope they don't get randomly chosen or found out.

I guess it's about the same as when a bunch of you suddenly up and voted for Shoshana for no reason that I could see. (IE. there is a reason, just well hidden)

Thats the reason why I voted for Shoshana.

My thought process was Shoshana wanted us to vote off one of the Guardians.

That's assuming that Eldanien is indeed a Guardian, and not a cohort of say Silvanus. Silvanus stating so blatantly and outright can mean two things, one, he is a Seer, and has verified that Eldanien is a guardian, and gotten Eldanien to protect him, or he is a Soulless. Therefore, I vote Silvanus as a Soulless God because either he is a Soulless, and we would do well to have him gone, or he is a Seer and is protected by Eldanien, in which case he won't die.

And also I reenforce my descision with the fact that Silvanus was the one who , out of the blue, voted for Erion because he 'wasn't interested' in the game. A random assumption like that should not be made without further evidence.

Seraphi, if you continued to read what I said, I gave more in-depth reasoning.

But you just pointed something out to me Seraphi.

If Eldanien is a Guardian.. why did he survive the night?

I hold my vote on Silvanus, he almost guiled me into turning my attention to Eldanien. Perhaps Eldanien was not protecting anyone? Or perhaps he's not a Guardian, or even an Elder.

Actually, no one is protected in the day. Guardians protect only at night. So if you aren't convinced that Silvanus is a Soulless, don't vote for him.

After sitting back and reading what everyone has to say, I'm gonna vote for soll. He's active yet too quiet, and he acts suspiciously.