BobStar's real death sentence

The Chambers of the Pantheon
Yeah, everything's real sparkly and god-like in here. Pretty atypical of the Elders, it's likewise splattered with copious amounts of pornography.. and, uhm, the by-products of pornography. Shiri, the asexual robot is here. He wields a keyboard in his left hand and the Hammer of /hijack in his right. Nyla, the Soulless is not here. He clearly doesn't wield the skull of Erion in his left hand and a deflated condom in the right. Supreme Lord of Pwnage, Soll is here, surrounded by a miasma of wailing souls and kray-zee stuff. He wields the Scythe of Pwn in both hands. The soul of Jack roams the land, bodiless and pissed-off. Summer, and the other Soulless are here. They each wield a ribcage of Erion in their left hand and a few strans of Erion hair in their right.

Shiri, the asexual robot types, "So, uhm, wassup?"

Supreme Lord of Pwnage, Soll, smiles and says, "Guess."

Summer, the other Soulless bonks Soll on the head with her mallet.

Soll narrows his eyes at Summer in an unnerving manner.

Supreme Lord of Pwnage, Soll, frowns and says, "Imma bonk every1 on da head 4 bein an asssssssss, like!"

Raises his scythe, like, and smashes it down on every1s heads1!"!21!"4312!!11111one!!!11

Soll rubs his tummy and goes 'mmmmmmmm.'

Raising His scythe high in the air, Soll swings it round in an arc, cleanly cutting BobStar in two, then two again, and then a few more twos.

The soul of Jack says, "Wewt!"

The soul of BobStar says, "Dangit."

The soul of Erion says, "Haha. Whore"

The soul of Nyla says, "Muhaha. I'm in less pieces than you!!"

All the Gods jump onto Nyla and tear Her soul into thousands of tiny little pieces, and let BobStar laugh at Her soul.

Bet you killed me on purpose,

Just cos

Umm... Are you accidentally framing Elders again or trying to tell us something?

He's framing. Probably because I like to him.

Either that or he got his records mixed up.

Bah. Well, it was fun

Shoshana
Tsuki
Anonymous
Shiri
Kashim
Rauros
Lyren
Summer
Jalain
Annelia
Erion (Randomly pwnt on Night 1)
Silvanus (Melted for being Soulless on Day 1)
Dyr (Him has been writhed up into a small ball on Night 2)
Etanru (Mauled by assorted astral zoology on Day 2)
Jack (Turned out to be voting himself for no good reason on Night 3)
Daganev (Was executed, theoretically, on Day 3)
Shamarah (Got dusted with a "beastie-corpse" crafted dagger on Night 4)
Nyla (Went swimming with the merians on Day 4)
BobStar (Went to go look for himself and got lost on Night 5)

Ugh. I just copied Jack's. Blame him. I altered everything that was wrong, that I saw, but my head skipped that. It should, of course, say 'Divine'

Also, to clarify, this will end when the Soulles outnumber the Elders.

You sound so sure that's gonna happen. :/ We have no chance of killing them all now?

I am not a female!!!!!

You can't lie to Yourself forever.

Nyla's about as masculine as Shiri.

That's what you get for picking the furry midgets and the butterfly people.

I have my masculine moments damnit. Dont hate on the pretty butterflies

Even if all the Soulless are still alive (slim chance of that, but it's possible), there would be 5 soulless to 5 non-soulless, so Elders, we're still in this. We just have to make sure that we keep getting Soulless.

So, the question is: was Nyla a Soulless?

The answer: no.

Why?

Daganev "revealed" himself to be a Guardian, and also, from the way I understood it, "revealed" Nyla as a Seer. If Nyla was a Soulless, I would think more people would be swaying votes away from him (his fellow Soulless maybe). Since there was not a single post trying to sway the votes away from Nyla (other than from Nyla himself), I can only conclude that Nyla was just another poor Elder/Seer who got stabbed in the back by his fellow Elders.

(30 seconds of silence as we mourn the loss of Nyla...)

.
.
.
.
.
.
.

Okay, so back to business.

Dead:
Erion (Not a Soulless)
Silvanus (Soulless)
Dyr (Not a Soulless)
Etanru (Soulless)
Jack (Not a Soulless)
Daganev (Not a Soulless)
Shamarah (Not a Soulless)
Nyla (Not a Soulless)
BobStar (Should be a Soulless, but is not... freaky stuff going on)

Assuming the Soulless do not kill themselves at night, that leaves us with 7 dead non-soulless and 2 dead Soulless (Silvanus and Etanru). That leaves us with 7 Elders against 3 Soulless, so we're in a good position to win this. We just have to be more careful of who we pick.

I think everyone should go back and read what's happened so far. Go ahead, I'll wait...
.
.
.
.
Okay, welcome back.

Now, IMNSHO, I think the other 3 Soulless are as follows: Shiri, Shoshona, and Annelia. My reasoning: these 3 have consistantly voted together every day since the start of the game. Everyone else has diverged slightly, but these 3 always vote in unison.

Evidence:


Also, Nyla practically pointed Shiri out as a Soulless. I think Nyla seered Shiri and found it to be true. Since Nyla was most definetely a Seer, that means Shiri is most definetely a Soulless.

So I suggest the following plan:

Today: we all vote Shiri
Tomorrow: We all vote Shoshona
Day after tomorrow: We all vote Annelia, and win the game. *rejoice*

It's as simple as that. Come on Elders, let's do this right and win this game.

So I'll start off. I vote Shiri.

I suspect the other Soulless just didn't want to be pointed at as well, especially since they knew Nyla was going down. (Dags being the exception there.)

I very much doubt Shoshana and Annelia are Soulless. I'm not really sure why, beyond them actually saying it, it's just a gut feeling.

I'm gonna lean towards what I've been thinking of doing already after Tsuki's hints, and vote for Anonymous. I have my suspicions about Rauros as well (the sudden random vote change during the last day makes me wonder), but I guess we'll see. If we don't win after killing Anonymous, we can vote off Rauros the next day.

How can we win when there are definetely at least 2 or 3 Soulless still out there? Dag and Nyla were not Soulless (we've already established this)

Unless you mean "we" as in the Soulless, and by killing Anon, you are saying there are really 5 Soulless and Anon is not one of them...

Well, that just strengthens my argument.

Shiri is definetely a Soulless.

No, we haven't established that Dags and Nyla weren't Soulless. It's pretty obvious that they were, really. I explained how that didn't need to be the case.

I hope you're not right, but I don't think I need to worry that you are. The logic doesn't follow. With Daganev and Nyla hooking themselves together, as it were, the general belief would have to be either for or against their claims. Many of us pointed out things that made for skepticism that prevented belief, which I still think was at least one thing we have gotten right. So far as the idea that there would've been swaying votes away from Nyla, once we voted Daganev away, it would have been pretty clear that we didn't believe the Daganev/Nyla claims and that Nyla would be going next. Why would a Soulless try to go against the majority to no purpose but creating suspicion against him or herself?

Also, your evidence linking Shiri-Annelia-Shoshana isn't conclusive. Each person they were voting against also got voted off, showing that there was enough supporting belief/suspicion against them. Thus it was reasonable that they'd be voting against that person, and not necessarily for the same reasons.

That said, I'm going to agree with myself from long before and vote against Anonymous again. Silence is much more of a concern right now, since I don't and can't know what a silent one is plotting, but the silence draws less attention than chatter and is thus more likely to be overlooked.

Rauros
Out of the silent camp who have we got so I can pick and choose and not just go with the majority for once

Here's my list, broken up by dead/alive, dead by time and in order under time, and then listed alphabetically for the living.

Night:

1. Erion
2. Dyr
3. Jack
4. Shamarah
5. BobStar

Day:

1. Silvanus
2. Etanru
3. Daganev
4. Nyla
5.

Alive:

1. Annelia
2. Anonymous
3. Jalain
4. Kashim
5. Lyren
6. Rauros
7. Shiri
8. Shoshana
9. Summer
10. Tsuki


Out of those still alive, my impressions of the quieter ones include Annelia (slightly, not as quiet), Anonymous, Lyren, and Shoshana (also, not as quiet). I could check again in a few hours (not enough time to do so now), but I believe Anonymous might've only posted to vote against Silvanus that first day. Lyren's been more active in voting, but not so much in talking outside of that.