Alternatively you could have every single player be a leper with half a hand and the potential to tear apart creation itself.

so lots of derranged kethurus

Hey, that's it! We can form separate clans that go to war over which parts of The Land must be disbelieved first! There's the conflict we were lacking. For my own part, I'm going to found the clan that doesn't believe there's really a joke carved into Revelstone, that the giants are all pulling our leg.