I just wanted to ask if it wouldn't be possible to add barghasts and redcaps to Faethorn too. I don't know too much about fae and all, but it seems that the main argument of Moondancers I am arguing with about wether Mother Night is completely warped and twisted or not is that there are no redcaps and barghasts in Faethorn and therefore only Mother Moon keeps the Fae completely pure.

Redcap, barghest, and slaugh are for the Shadowdancers what the maiden, mother, and crone are for the Moondancers ... representations of the avatars of Mother Night or Mother Moon respectively. Their followers can call them, but otherwise they're existing only as/within the avatars.

Really? Oh, then I got something wrong there. Or the Moondancer Ash argued with didn't know that either.

Plus, if they were in faethorn, you'd be bringing barghests and redcaps to Moon, which wouldn't make sense.

Redcaps, Barghest and Slaugh are tainted. They have a strong spiritual connection to Mother Night. They don't live in the Faethorn.

I already admitted defeat.

Never admit defeat - only concede your points.