Envoy Changes

by Xenthos

Back to Common Grounds.

Unknown2005-09-19 23:22:16
QUOTE(Xavius @ Sep 19 2005, 06:19 PM)
It would be an upgrade if, say, the system checked for conglutination before checking for deepbond. It's a bit more of a liability now.

And you mention downgrades. Like, more than one downgrade. I see one piddly downgrade and one piddly (and bugged, apparently) upgrade.
189137



A bit?
Torak2005-09-19 23:22:41
So bring your familar with you off plane..its really not difficult.
Ialie2005-09-19 23:23:29
QUOTE(Xavius @ Sep 19 2005, 06:21 PM)
Ialie, would you rather spend 18 power and have to replace your bond, or spend 10 power and snuggle your bond looking for consolation when you get back to Prime?
189140




18 power.


I am not sure what the snuggle comment is supposed to mean. But I would rather transmigrate and not lose any experience than conglutinate.
Xavius2005-09-19 23:24:21
QUOTE(Ye of Little Faith @ Sep 19 2005, 06:22 PM)
A bit?
189141



I don't have an animal bonded, and would rather not at the moment. The announce says that you need eq for most bond abilities now. I'm going to bet 100 gold and a honeycake that it's significantly harder for someone to force you to summon your bond back now. Go test, Kalo.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:25:08
QUOTE(Ye of Little Faith @ Sep 20 2005, 01:21 AM)
How many necromancy users would still use it if they had to keep their demon alive?  And their demon could die in a single cudgel blast from me?  Eh?
189139


That's unrelated, come on. You have to choose just like you always had, nothing changed in that aspect?

And a demon is very important to my offence, I don't know why you're trying to compare it to your fluffy which is more fancy than essential.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:26:21
QUOTE(Torak @ Sep 19 2005, 06:22 PM)
So bring your familar with you off plane..its really not difficult.
189142



Right, if I'm bashing. But I'm not going to bring it into the middle of a horde of Fesixes with me. If I transmigrate, I'm off eq for a good bit of time. I'd be dead by the time my eq was back. Pointless. But I'm not going to leave it sitting around a sphere, either, because it could be killed by any *novice*.

If I'm fighting off-plane, you can simply give your demon dominate, and make him make me bond recall. And in, what, one, MAYBE two cosmic fires I'd be dead. Because my fox can't take anything more.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:28:08
QUOTE(Xavius @ Sep 20 2005, 01:19 AM)
It would be an upgrade if, say, the system checked for conglutination before checking for deepbond. It's a bit more of a liability now.
189137


If there's some problem with determining which one has priority (I'm not sure if I understand you correctly), it will surely be worked out. If your animal is on the same plane, it goes off. If not, conglutinate.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:28:27
QUOTE(Kashim @ Sep 19 2005, 06:25 PM)
That's unrelated, come on. You have to choose just like you always had, nothing changed in that aspect?

And a demon is very important to my offence, I don't know why you're trying to compare it to your fluffy which is more fancy than essential.
189145



I'm simply saying. Perhaps a demon was a bad relation. However, if you had to keep a mob that dies in 1-2 hits on the same plane as you in order to lich - would you? Now what if I could force you to call it to you, while we're fighting? Then, when I kill it in a single cudgel, because cudgels are sick vs mobs, and you'ld instantly die and have to pray.

All of this, and it costs 18 setup, and 10 when you die.
Lisaera2005-09-19 23:28:56
QUOTE(Ye of Little Faith @ Sep 20 2005, 12:11 AM)
It was asked for in exchange for various other grevious flaws seen in Ecology, none of those flaws were corrected, we were only given the downgrades.

EDIT: I just realized you meant because of conglute.  Wow.  No.  As I said, it was looked upon as a downgrade (why would I want to lose ANY experience at all - I don't want to drag my little fox to Nil, while I'm trying to bash a demonlord).  As I said, it was offered as a downgrade in exchange for various upgrades.  I'm sure Gregori can back me up on this.  It wasn't any form of upgrade we requested. tongue.gif
189125



That was a bad idea then, because each suggestion is judged separately, just because you suggest something that can be seen as a downgrade does not make any suggestions that can be seen as upgrades any more likely.
Torak2005-09-19 23:28:58
Well, if I understand correctly I could do the bond recall thing on prime too, unless I am mistaken. Regardless no novice is going to be on astral bashing, leave it at a safe area(Given its not practical). I see this as an upgrade if anything provided you have conglut. If you don't well.. you are SOL
Unknown2005-09-19 23:29:20
QUOTE(Kashim @ Sep 19 2005, 06:28 PM)
If there's some problem with determining which one has priority (I'm not sure if I understand you correctly), it will surely be worked out. If your animal is on the same plane, it goes off. If not, conglutinate.
189147



It still works that way. If people would rather conglute than transmigrate, they can just not deepbond. WOW. NOVEL CONCEPT, THERE.
Xavius2005-09-19 23:29:48
Seriously, someone go check if you can recall while off eq now. If you can't, then you should be fine. Yes, it's still a bit more of a liability, but only a little bit.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:30:59
QUOTE(Torak @ Sep 19 2005, 06:28 PM)
Well, if I understand correctly I could do the bond recall thing on prime too, unless I am mistaken. Regardless no novice is going to be on astral bashing, leave it at a safe area(Given its not practical). I see this as an upgrade if anything provided you have conglut. If you don't well.. you are SOL
189150



The only people saying it's an upgrade are necro users. No surprise, there.
Estarra2005-09-19 23:31:53
QUOTE(Gregori @ Sep 19 2005, 04:19 PM)
The Transmigration change was asked for by me, with enhancements to balance it out and make it so that our familiars could actually be useful to us. All that we got was the penalty to balance the upgrade. This was in no way intended and I would rather Transmigration not have been touched instead of making it so that deepbonding is a pointless endeavour.


I'm not sure what enhancements you are talking about. The only thing that came across my desk was a very convoluted request for making familiars not die during the transmigration process that would be very difficult to code. Anyway, I didn't like this idea at all. Even looking at it again, I have no idea how this "enhancement" would have anything to do with limiting transmigration to same plane.

The was the same-plane request:
QUOTE
Transmigration changed to same plane only (this may sound like not much concerning Prime, but as one advances to higher planes it gets more and more dangerous)


The was my notation:
QUOTE
Hmm, ok if that's what they want. -Estarra

Ialie2005-09-19 23:32:03
QUOTE(Torak @ Sep 19 2005, 06:28 PM)
Well, if I understand correctly I could do the bond recall thing on prime too, unless I am mistaken. Regardless no novice is going to be on astral bashing, leave it at a safe area(Given its not practical). I see this as an upgrade if anything provided you have conglut. If you don't well.. you are SOL
189150





A novice also wouldn't have trans ecology so this is a moot point.
Torak2005-09-19 23:32:10
HA! That is just great...How long has Xavius been a necromancer? Maybe you don't understand that YOUR envoy suggested it. YOU have to live with it, bitch at him, not the forums.

Ialie, the novice comment was aimed at Kalo's complaint that a novice could randomly come on astral and kill it while he bashed.
Unknown2005-09-19 23:32:34
QUOTE(Xavius @ Sep 19 2005, 06:29 PM)
Seriously, someone go check if you can recall while off eq now. If you can't, then you should be fine. Yes, it's still a bit more of a liability, but only a little bit.
189152



No, you cannot. But still. Gods, this is just pissing me off. What a waste of credits. I'd have transed planar if I wanted something like this.
Ialie2005-09-19 23:33:15
QUOTE(Estarra @ Sep 19 2005, 06:31 PM)
I'm not sure what enhancements you are talking about. The only thing that came across my desk was a very convoluted request for making familiars not die during the transmigration process that would be very difficult to code. Anyway, I didn't like this idea at all. Even looking at it again, I have no idea how this "enhancement" would have anything to do with limiting transmigration to same plane.

The was the same-plane request:
The was my notation:
189155






PLease Estarra! It is not what I want! I have never wanted it this! PLease please please please change it back! Please I will give you cookies I swear! One every day for the rest of your life!
Unknown2005-09-19 23:33:29
QUOTE(Torak @ Sep 19 2005, 06:32 PM)
HA! That is just great...How long has Xavius been a necromancer? Maybe you don't understand that YOUR envoy suggested it. YOU have to live with it, bitch at him, not the forums.
189158



He offered it as a downgrade in exchange for various SORELY NEEDED upgrades to an otherwise USELESS pet. However, as Lisaera has pointed out, an Envoy should NEVER suggest downgrades, only upgrades, as nothing is taken as a whole, instead only in part.
Gregori2005-09-19 23:34:05
QUOTE(Lisaera @ Sep 19 2005, 05:28 PM)
That was a bad idea then, because each suggestion is judged separately, just because you suggest something that can be seen as a downgrade does not make any suggestions that can be seen as upgrades any more likely.
189149



So effectively what you are saying is don't bother to send in a balanced envoy report because the full suggestion of something will not be looked at for the overall merit, but each piece of it will be viewed seperately.

Just for the record this was the full suggested change:

QUOTE
Further to suggestions found in my Envoy report. I would like to explain my ideas
for Transmigration and Familiars.

Currently Familiars either function as a show piece, a tool to spy on your friends,
or as a game mechanic to get a lich-like free death. There is no reason at all to
take your familiar into any situation that might harm it. While this may be the
whole idea of Familiars, it defeats the purpose of them being able to spy on or
attack others, and even those limited abilities are only effective against those you
know won't raise arms against it.

My suggestions are as follows in order to make Familiars more useful:

1) An ability to train the Strength, Speed, and Constitution of Familiars
  (As per IRE Paladin/Infernal Falcon training)

2) Transmigration changed to same plane only (this may sound like not much
  concerning Prime, but as one advances to higher planes it gets more and
  more dangerous)

3) Instead of the Familiar ceasing to exist upon Transmigration, it would
  "give up" some of its essence to breathe new life into you. Mechanics
  wise 1/3rd(this either being one full stat or a random amount from each)
  of the Trained Power into your Familiar would be lost. Deepbonds would
  still cost the 10 power, and you would still lose the same power as
  normal upon death. Death of the Familiar would also still cause death of
  the Druid if Deepbonded. Essentially after 3 deaths without retraining
  the Familiar would be at its weakest point, and Transmigrating would
  at this point "kill" the Familiar forcing you to Rebirth a new one.