Divine Intervention

by Vix

Back to Common Grounds.

Malicia2005-10-24 13:49:22
Not you! You really want me to find that thread? sad.gif


I so will.
Unknown2005-10-24 13:51:11
As long as it's not me, that's ok. tongue.gif
Malicia2005-10-24 14:16:18
This one!


http://lusternia.ire-community.com/index.php?showtopic=5912


I love the posts by Jadryga and Narsrim. If you compare them... Teehee.

Narsrim didn't mind her until he was wisped and slain by her in Glomdoring. Munsia as well.
Viravain2005-10-24 16:35:15
Except I've never wisped, or killed, either Munsia or Narsrim. Astraea has even said she was the one to do so (and only to Munsia). Take a look here, and scroll down a bit.

Why a few insist on spreading things that are not true, I do not know, but it will only weaken their arguements more than it could ever strengthen them when those claims are proven false.
Revan2005-10-24 17:08:29
Maliii, no crushing our egos, you naughty girl!!
Qaletaqa2005-10-24 17:22:41
New Celest has lost a lot of players to Serenwilde and Magnagora over the years however we do not have gods killing offenders. The largest thing I saw was when Magnagora had killed all city defenses and only about eight people were online and Isune basically shielded the Pool of Stars.

Defensive measures I see however offensive I do not see the need. But in Viravains case alone I fully support her in whatever she is doing as it is consistent and she is not drastically altering the balance when like people have said there aren't really people defending. Which brings me back to the old days when Magnagora was constantly raiding Celest and we had basically no defenses and all statues were destroyed. Even our commodity shop was broken into and all comms bought out.

And lastly no patron of any city will sit there idly when you kill their own members in front of them. That is just expecting way too much and it is in character for them to slay you on sight. However, nowadays with the guards being so brutal they don't usually have to resort to this.

And I didn't read all eight archived posts so don't flame me!
Qaletaqa2005-10-24 17:38:46
QUOTE(Malicia @ Oct 24 2005, 06:39 AM)
That's so true, Iridiel.

Hey, have you noticed that a few certain people that claimed that Viravain was the absolute ruin of Glomdoring  are now praising her?  laugh.gif 

I -wish- I felt like digging around and finding that thread. Heh. Anyawys,   I admire her rp. I don't like the ooc imbalance it causes. It isn't fair to the other organizations that have suffered the same.

Morik, you're clueless. We struggled -alot-. We grew in numbers. People stopped arguing with each other and worked together. We made demense plans, pushed people to train, discussed influencing, CF'ed our hardest workers up (we have a large amount of high CF individuals) and still, we find ourselves outnumbered from time to time. We manage. I've gotten quite used to the 'Win some, Lose some' thing. You don't see thread after thread in the Idiots section about how hopeless everything in the SW is. After SW kicked out (I got to push the eject button, whee!)  Nikua, we began to ascend.

Malicia, my weetle character, would love to help Celest out. I really could care less if Glomdoring controls a village. If we could strip every village from Magnagora, barring Angkrag and Acknor, I'd be happy. We had them down to one village, at one point. For me, it's not about winning. It's about crippling your ego. Making them eat humble pie. Victory is so much sweeter, being the emerging underdog.  As it goes, they're enemies and we would rather not see a village covered in taint. Together, SW and Celest have kicked ass but Celest has to understand that some Serens want very little to do with the cities. It annoys me at times, in game, but I have to respect it.

It's been a year. Glomdoring is not a 'new' commune and Celest has been out as long as we have. Fix what's going on internally and stop accusing others of taking what's yours. SW and Celest still need each other from time to time, but many Celestians (that I've talked to, at least) are ready to stand on their own and can't figure out why it simply is -not- happening. 
211525



Yeah I'm with you on that note. I'd like Celest to do her own dirty deeds without Serenwilde but for the moment a lot of there players help supplement our need for a fighting force from time to time. I think it would help if we put our arena together faster so we could have easier access to combat. However, Celest has always been more character centered in that regard. We do have more women in Celest than Magnagora. Don't hate!

Lastly, seriously I am really impressed with SW and how largely its grown mostly due to its entirely neutral standing against magnagora and celest. As well as good organization, fighters, and leadership.
Jadryga2005-10-24 17:50:30
QUOTE(Malicia @ Oct 24 2005, 09:39 PM)
Hey, have you noticed that a few certain people that claimed that Viravain was the absolute ruin of Glomdoring  are now praising her?  laugh.gif 
211525



IF I'm included in that few certain people, you either haven't quite read my post properly or you've missed my point completely.

I like the concept of Viravain. It's creative and most definitely interesting, giving us a breath of fresh of air, something different from the usual high, mighty and dignified divine. She's psychotic, she's wild, she doesn't give two hoots about whether people like her or not, so long as they listen and don't harm her forest.

Unfortunately, it doesn't mean she's good for Glomdoring.

What I didn't like, was that the way the concept of Viravain was executed before, while absolutely fascinating, was counter-productive to the growth of Glomdoring. Insane leaders provide excellent material for books and stories, I love reading or hearing about wacky leaders, but to actually live under them, or watch friends suffer under them, is a different story. Hitler was charismatic, he got things done, he was psychotic, fascinating, unique. But was he good for Germany? No.

As an objective player, I'd love to watch Viravain's insanity develop, and see what drama comes out of the commune next. As a Magnagoran, I'd prioritise the growth and prosperity of an ally nation over the whims and fancies of an insane goddess.

It's a love-hate relationship.

It's admittedly hard to execute the concept of an insane leader and at the same time have your nation grow and prosper under your rule. There's a really fine line to walk, and it'll take a ton of thought and planning to perhaps be able to slip beneficial decisions under the mask of an insane whim. But that was the chance Glomdoring took, I should think. Or at least, the producers.
Unknown2005-10-24 17:51:20
Just read the whole thread and since there were to many quotes.

It's quite sickening the amount of times I saw, we're new, we're immature, we can't do it because we're picked on. I remember logging on one morning at 9AM Est and hearing that raiders were in ethereal. I remember logging off that SAME day at around 6pm EST with over 15 deaths AND Ethereal still being raided. Where was OUR divine help? Don't complain that you're constantly raided and you need a break when I can find countless other threads of Serens going WTF stop constantly killing us and the only response being STFU and deal.

I don't know how often Viravain or Shakiri(sorry if I spelled it wrong multitaskign and didn't look) help out, but to claim you need divine assistance because you're being attacked constantly is joke. Celest, and Serenwilde did, do, and more then likely will continue to get wailed on constantly, and the only ones we have (Only speaking of Serens here) to depend on is our ourselves.

Divine assistance to further roleplay, divine intervention when something the commune/city is seconds away from being burned and razed with salt spread over the earth is understandable, even accepted, but Divine assistance because, they are kicking our butt's and in the seven months we've been out, we haven't been able to stand on our own two feet, is silly.

Anyway just my two cents, if you don't agree that's fine, not my place to tell you your own opinions.
Jadryga2005-10-24 17:52:05
Poop, I pressed Quote instead of Edit.

Bedtime.
Munsia2005-10-24 18:24:09
QUOTE(Malicia @ Oct 24 2005, 10:16 AM)

Narsrim didn't mind her until he was wisped and slain by her in Glomdoring. Munsia as well.
211540


tongue.gif I've never liked her. Still dont
Jadryga2005-10-24 18:28:35
Bah, post deleted, cos I saw something redundant.

Don't mind me, time to sleep.
Corr2005-10-24 19:47:39
QUOTE(Kidchex @ Oct 24 2005, 05:51 PM)
Just read the whole thread and since there were to many quotes.

It's quite sickening the amount of times I saw, we're new, we're immature, we can't do it because we're picked on.
211578



If you read those posts more closely you will notice it is Serenwilde and Magnagoran charachter names that are saying that, while the Glomdoring charachter names said that they are able to hold thier own.


Looking at the culture scores, and Topguilds, I think its very clear that Glomdoring has the smallest population of all the cities. I'm guessing that has more to do with OOC reasoning of players rather than IC developments because of all the complaints I saw in other threads that Glomdoring was stealing people from the other places.
Ashteru2005-10-24 20:47:13
I think you all forget something. We are talking about Viravain helping when -PRIME- Glomdoring was raided. Kidchex gave the example of Faethorn, which is simply not Serenwildes at the moment. It's neutral. No one -forces- you to defend it.
Sure, if I was Hartstone there, I'd have gone. But it's a bit like the Catacombs at the moment, seeing Faethorn is neutral and doesn't belong to anyone, but is still protected by a certain group.
And well, the PRIME place of the commune bein raided, something that should be the SAFEST spot for the inhabitants, and still being killed there...pretty disheartening.
Narsrim2005-10-24 20:51:00
QUOTE(Ashteru @ Oct 24 2005, 04:47 PM)
I think you all forget something. We are talking about Viravain helping when -PRIME- Glomdoring was raided. Kidchex gave the example of Faethorn, which is simply not Serenwildes at the moment. It's neutral. No one -forces- you to defend it.
Sure, if I was Hartstone there, I'd have gone. But it's a bit like the Catacombs at the moment, seeing Faethorn is neutral and doesn't belong to anyone, but is still protected by a certain group.
And well, the PRIME place of the commune bein raided, something that should be the SAFEST spot for the inhabitants, and still being killed there...pretty disheartening.
211600



That's a rather twisted argument. Faethorn is no more "neutral" that Earth, Water, Celestia, Nil, etc. While Queen Maeve may not be pledged to Moon or Night (becuase it is impossible to accomplish as the quest is botched at the moment), people were entering (Magnagora and Glomdorians) and slaying Fae (which is a bit crappy for Glomdoring's RP because they are supposed to be pro-Fae too...)... so that isn't exactly "neutral"
Xenthos2005-10-24 20:52:56
QUOTE(Narsrim @ Oct 24 2005, 04:51 PM)
That's a rather twisted argument. Faethorn is no more "neutral" that Earth, Water, Celestia, Nil, etc. While Queen Maeve may not be pledged to Moon or Night (becuase it is impossible to accomplish as the quest is botched at the moment), people were entering (Magnagora and Glomdorians) and slaying Fae (which is a bit crappy for Glomdoring's RP because they are supposed to be pro-Fae too...)... so that isn't exactly "neutral"
211602



OOCly, we enslave them. We had to kill them for a long time, the only reason we don't have to kill them is because Maeve *forced* us not to by casting a spell so their corpses couldn't be given to their avatars. How does this make us pro-Fae? On an OOC level, that is, ICly we're doing things this way in their best interests, of course. ninja.gif
Ashteru2005-10-24 20:55:37
QUOTE(Narsrim @ Oct 24 2005, 08:51 PM)
That's a rather twisted argument. Faethorn is no more "neutral" that Earth, Water, Celestia, Nil, etc. While Queen Maeve may not be pledged to Moon or Night (becuase it is impossible to accomplish as the quest is botched at the moment), people were entering (Magnagora and Glomdorians) and slaying Fae (which is a bit crappy for Glomdoring's RP because they are supposed to be pro-Fae too...)... so that isn't exactly "neutral"
211602


Well, I was more technically talking. I said myself that I'd still go up there and get my sorry ass to defend as well.
And it doesn't -have- to be bad RP per se, I think. Just some of the Gloms don't listen to their avatars THIS time and still carry on killing.
(Of course this applies only if the avatars first said 'Kill Fae' and now say 'Bring the little cuties to me')

But essentially, Nil/Celest/Earth/Water have drawbacks for their 'owners' if something happens to, say, the Earthlords or the Supernals. Faethorn has nothing like that for Serenwilde nor Glomdoring.

EDIT: Bleh, next time edit sooner, Xenthos. tongue.gif

Well, seeing that the Glomdoringers aren't allowed to give the fae to the avatars by a third force, this means they could still follow their (the avatars) words and kill Fae just for the sake of it. Maybe if they RPed a little after it and then offered the corpses at a shrine or something, it would be better.
Narsrim2005-10-24 21:04:18
QUOTE(Xenthos @ Oct 24 2005, 04:52 PM)
OOCly, we enslave them.  We had to kill them for a long time, the only reason we don't have to kill them is because Maeve *forced* us not to by casting a spell so their corpses couldn't be given to their avatars.  How does this make us pro-Fae?  On an OOC level, that is, ICly we're doing things this way in their best interests, of course.  ninja.gif
211604



Then you shouldn't object OOCly to Narsrim and the Moondancers (this is in book of things to do) going to speak with Maeve and saying:

Why would you ever allow Glomdoring to even remotely have a chance to gather your favor when they in fact still murder your beloved people?

As it stands, Glomdoring has sacrificed what small claim it may have had to Faethorn.
Xenthos2005-10-24 21:07:38
QUOTE(Narsrim @ Oct 24 2005, 05:04 PM)
Then you shouldn't object OOCly to Narsrim and the Moondancers (this is in book of things to do) going to speak with Maeve and saying:

Why would you ever allow Glomdoring to even remotely have a chance to gather your favor when they in fact still murder your beloved people?

As it stands, Glomdoring has sacrificed what small claim it may have had to Faethorn.
211611



Not at all. Maeve is a dual nature. Half of her IS Glomdoring, and she can't deny it. You can talk to her all you want, if you enjoy wasting your breath. The goals of Glomdoring's greater spirits are also half of her goals- if they will the death of her subjects to be enslaved, then so does half of Maeve's spirit.
Munsia2005-10-24 21:08:45
QUOTE(Xenthos @ Oct 24 2005, 05:07 PM)
Not at all.  Maeve is a dual nature.  Half of her IS Glomdoring, and she can't deny it.  You can talk to her all you want, if you enjoy wasting your breath.  The goals of Glomdoring's greater spirits are also half of her goals- if they will the death of her subjects to be enslaved, then so does half of Maeve's spirit.
211616


but death isnt the means to enslave her subjects. So therefor you are acting against Her