I disagree. Wisp is not unfun or unbalanced 1-on-1. In fact, it can be a very useful utility ability to fight/save persons and affords wiccans more control on forest environments (which was the point). It is being removed for group combat reasons and as such, I don't feel it is unreasonable that we be compensated with something on par for 1-on-1 combat.

Furthermore, the notion that remove wisp removes nothing vital is subjective. Removing teleport from Planar would be removing nothing "vital" to me, but I'm sure there are many many people who adore teleport and would despise being without it at this point.

As for an upgrade, I feel that word is misleading. Wisp is not being upgraded. Becoming "different" does not necessarily imply "better."

If you're gonna get rid of demesne summon, you have to get rid of wisp summon as well. It doesn't make sense otherwise. Replace the summons with another skill

The point that was being discussed was that wisp -was- going to be removed (most likely) and as such, the willowisp fae will need a new task/ability.

Ah sorry for being misleading new skills replacement yes thats fine I said but we wont need an upgrade.

What suggestions do you have for new tasks and abilities that don't significantly affect Wiccan combat?

I have a few, but I'm not stupid enough to post them on forums for others to whine about. I will take ideas from the Moondancers as usual and submit something in an envoy report.