Unknown2007-03-25 10:26:31
If I could one day be half the awesomeness Estarra is, I'd be one happy little munchkin.
I have to say I've been incredibly impressed by so many of the changes I've read about (and less so by others, but that's normal), but at the same time I wonder if so many upgrades might possibly cause some problems. I can't say I have the experience to judge effectively, which is why I ask, but do you all think that with resurrection, healing and escape abilities becoming more and more widespread the 'permanence' of action in Lusternia is reduced at all?
Perhaps I'm just imagining things in a different way than the reality, which is quite likely.
Still, I really do want to congratulate the admin on taking such bold and innovative steps with this wonderful world. For all the criticism, I know they really are some of the most amazing that you can find. I'm sure with time the divide between player expectation and admin response will gradually get smaller and smaller. And in the meantime, there are apparently aethership battles! Wheeeeee!
/random post from the grave
I have to say I've been incredibly impressed by so many of the changes I've read about (and less so by others, but that's normal), but at the same time I wonder if so many upgrades might possibly cause some problems. I can't say I have the experience to judge effectively, which is why I ask, but do you all think that with resurrection, healing and escape abilities becoming more and more widespread the 'permanence' of action in Lusternia is reduced at all?
Perhaps I'm just imagining things in a different way than the reality, which is quite likely.
Still, I really do want to congratulate the admin on taking such bold and innovative steps with this wonderful world. For all the criticism, I know they really are some of the most amazing that you can find. I'm sure with time the divide between player expectation and admin response will gradually get smaller and smaller. And in the meantime, there are apparently aethership battles! Wheeeeee!
/random post from the grave
Valaria2007-03-25 10:37:38
if estarra give them lichdom, why not give celest their pretty angel wings and in bonus of be holy being that magnagora so fear? ok i kid.. ignore me, I never exists in this post at all.
*poof*
to be honest i have no good idea for Celest with their construct idea.
*poof*
to be honest i have no good idea for Celest with their construct idea.
Aiakon2007-03-25 10:48:44
QUOTE(Nico @ Mar 25 2007, 07:33 AM) 393391
Wow, just reading this thread has substantially lowered my opinion of the collective Lusternia playerbase. Of course, it was never very high to begin with...but now I actually feel dirty, and substantially less intelligent, for even being associable with the lot of you.
Q F T
Aiakon2007-03-25 10:52:21
QUOTE(Verithrax @ Mar 25 2007, 08:22 AM) 393416
Consistent inflammatory bollocks
Stop Trolling
Karnagan2007-03-25 11:35:28
Ok, first off? Estarra is the best admin I've seen. He doesn't preside over an insanely bugged game, an utter lack of quests/bashing, boring rooms with literally no difference between them, absurd player-killing rules that lead to lolzpk, idiotic city balances, tiny organizations with even smaller populations, an ungodly reliance on bashing as measuring your importance to an organization, updates that only happen once in a year, or ridiculous class imbalances that LITERALLY make the game unplayable. That alone makes him better than the executive producer of every other text mud out there. He honestly invests a lot of work into meeting every criticism, never mind things that are legitimately wrong. I would put even money on the fact that Estarra yanked the new Celest construct because players are upset because he was trying to calm things down in the playerbase. I feel bad because Estarra genuinely feels bad.
Nico: fine. We will state as fact experience has worth. Ok. Let's take a situation where someone has 10 power upon activating Trueheal. If they had all of their defences stripped, got thrown off balance for 5 seconds, lost all of their active power (the 10 points you see in the prompt), and then had no ability to put their 0p Trueheal back up again without first regenerating their active personal power? THEN it would be comparable to Lichdom for value of use. As it is, for any Necromancer with tri-Trans guild skills and any hope of getting buffs, ArchLichdom's bonus to stats is +1 STR and +1 INT. If you are not a Necromancer? You get the buffs only at night, and during the day you suffer through -1 buffs to both stats. You can escape even the most dire situations with one Trueheal while bashing, so you suffer even less than any Magnagoran with Archlich. If you use a ton of power, and therefore it has no value to you? Fine. I'd settle for Upgraded Trueheal merely taking all the power in your personal reserves (ex. the amount shown in your prompt). I would still think it's better than Lichdom. But with the proposed Upgraded Trueheal, even if you can only use it once before you can't use it again, you have the ability to teleport out and re-establish it. This is while keeping all of your defenses, balances, and power. Liches are not given the same leeway. You have a Champion helm and admit to chasing power to the point you are rarely able to use more than 5 points worth at any given time. Assuming you kill people who cannot or will not take hundreds of units of power from their Nexus just to fight a duel- I'm one of them- maybe this says more about your consumption of your active power than the validity of Trueheal. I'm trying to ask you to think briefly about this. By all accounts you're a very strong Champion- one fight with you "convinced" me that a reflex system upgrade was long overdue. So just think about it.
Catarin: I understand that non-Sacraments users need to consume 20 power (!) to be able to cheat death. See my response to Nico. In addition, I would say that if my body could be retrieved during a village revolt, and then resurrected for 1 power? I would be a LARGE fan of Sacraments. For that matter, if I could get a prismatic barrier merely by keeping my power up, then running off without any EXP, defense, or power loss, that would be even better. In fact, it would be the best skill in the game. In the spirit of really helping Celest, let me suggest a new skill that the construct would grant Sacraments users.
SPECIAL TRUEHEAL: DEUSEX
Syntax: DEUSEX
Cost: 5 power units (Pool of Stars)
The Holy Supernals smile upon your perfect dedication to the Light. If you pray to them for deliverance while enveloped in the Angel Aura, the Blessed Ones will instantly place your battered form at the Pool of Stars on the Prime Plane. You may use this ability at any time, regardless of your physical state. Be warned: this ability will strip all of your defences, including your Angel Aura. This ability will also consume 10 power: if you have less than 10 personal power, it will be taken from your reserves. If you do not have any power in your personal reserves, none will be taken. The Holy Supernals will only grace you with this ability 3 times in one month.
***
Yeah, you suddenly stop having to pray with this skill. It's designed so that anyone can use it, regardless of condition. Now we can't kill you if you're seriously trying to evade us: even a Lich can't evade death 3 times in one month without running a serious risk of being caught as they reform, then killed. And when this happens, a Magnagoran will lose all of their undead bonuses and all of your personal power. This is a GUARANTEED escape from death, which is more than anyone can say for Lich. If anyone can think of a good way to alter this proposed skill for fairness, in one direction or the other, I'd love to hear it.
Nico: fine. We will state as fact experience has worth. Ok. Let's take a situation where someone has 10 power upon activating Trueheal. If they had all of their defences stripped, got thrown off balance for 5 seconds, lost all of their active power (the 10 points you see in the prompt), and then had no ability to put their 0p Trueheal back up again without first regenerating their active personal power? THEN it would be comparable to Lichdom for value of use. As it is, for any Necromancer with tri-Trans guild skills and any hope of getting buffs, ArchLichdom's bonus to stats is +1 STR and +1 INT. If you are not a Necromancer? You get the buffs only at night, and during the day you suffer through -1 buffs to both stats. You can escape even the most dire situations with one Trueheal while bashing, so you suffer even less than any Magnagoran with Archlich. If you use a ton of power, and therefore it has no value to you? Fine. I'd settle for Upgraded Trueheal merely taking all the power in your personal reserves (ex. the amount shown in your prompt). I would still think it's better than Lichdom. But with the proposed Upgraded Trueheal, even if you can only use it once before you can't use it again, you have the ability to teleport out and re-establish it. This is while keeping all of your defenses, balances, and power. Liches are not given the same leeway. You have a Champion helm and admit to chasing power to the point you are rarely able to use more than 5 points worth at any given time. Assuming you kill people who cannot or will not take hundreds of units of power from their Nexus just to fight a duel- I'm one of them- maybe this says more about your consumption of your active power than the validity of Trueheal. I'm trying to ask you to think briefly about this. By all accounts you're a very strong Champion- one fight with you "convinced" me that a reflex system upgrade was long overdue. So just think about it.
Catarin: I understand that non-Sacraments users need to consume 20 power (!) to be able to cheat death. See my response to Nico. In addition, I would say that if my body could be retrieved during a village revolt, and then resurrected for 1 power? I would be a LARGE fan of Sacraments. For that matter, if I could get a prismatic barrier merely by keeping my power up, then running off without any EXP, defense, or power loss, that would be even better. In fact, it would be the best skill in the game. In the spirit of really helping Celest, let me suggest a new skill that the construct would grant Sacraments users.
SPECIAL TRUEHEAL: DEUSEX
Syntax: DEUSEX
Cost: 5 power units (Pool of Stars)
The Holy Supernals smile upon your perfect dedication to the Light. If you pray to them for deliverance while enveloped in the Angel Aura, the Blessed Ones will instantly place your battered form at the Pool of Stars on the Prime Plane. You may use this ability at any time, regardless of your physical state. Be warned: this ability will strip all of your defences, including your Angel Aura. This ability will also consume 10 power: if you have less than 10 personal power, it will be taken from your reserves. If you do not have any power in your personal reserves, none will be taken. The Holy Supernals will only grace you with this ability 3 times in one month.
***
Yeah, you suddenly stop having to pray with this skill. It's designed so that anyone can use it, regardless of condition. Now we can't kill you if you're seriously trying to evade us: even a Lich can't evade death 3 times in one month without running a serious risk of being caught as they reform, then killed. And when this happens, a Magnagoran will lose all of their undead bonuses and all of your personal power. This is a GUARANTEED escape from death, which is more than anyone can say for Lich. If anyone can think of a good way to alter this proposed skill for fairness, in one direction or the other, I'd love to hear it.
Krellan2007-03-25 11:45:10
i thought estarra was a woman? :S
Karnagan2007-03-25 11:49:15
It's Pat!
... I don't know what the hell he/she/it (artificial intelligence) is anymore.
... I don't know what the hell he/she/it (artificial intelligence) is anymore.
Elostian2007-03-25 14:14:25
Some say she has more computing power than Big Thought.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
Unknown2007-03-25 14:16:29
So, if I'm not wrong, the Magnagoran's one gives a vitae effect without the exp loss to everyone in city, stat bonus at times, stat reduction at times, no stat reduction and coldaura for people with (Trans?) Necromancy. For 10 power? And there was the additional RP value of being undead? And it's sort of fine?
Angelfont
An Angelaura def, which does as Lich does, instead of stat changes, they get:
- Celestialism Wings and includes an angelic prefix to their race
- A Halo def for everyone (maybe boosted)
- Ablution and Lustration upon being rezzed by Angelaura (also maybe boosted)
- Whoever already has Halo, gets +1 to int
- Whoever has Ablution and Lustration, gets +1 str
Would that work?
Angelfont
An Angelaura def, which does as Lich does, instead of stat changes, they get:
- Celestialism Wings and includes an angelic prefix to their race
- A Halo def for everyone (maybe boosted)
- Ablution and Lustration upon being rezzed by Angelaura (also maybe boosted)
- Whoever already has Halo, gets +1 to int
- Whoever has Ablution and Lustration, gets +1 str
Would that work?
Clise2007-03-25 14:23:55
It has been shot down. No clones of liches allowed
Unknown2007-03-25 14:36:09
An observation:
The logic behind the involvement of trueheal in the construct seems to follow this line:
o Lich is Magnagora's most influential/effective/powerful survival ability
o Magnagora's construct gives them universal lich
o Celest needs an equivalent
o Celest's most powerful/effective survival ability is thought to be trueheal
Therefore Celest should have universal trueheal.
The idea lacks imagination. Surely it's better for Celest to take its time and think of something as original and imaginative as the constructs of the other organisations?
The logic behind the involvement of trueheal in the construct seems to follow this line:
o Lich is Magnagora's most influential/effective/powerful survival ability
o Magnagora's construct gives them universal lich
o Celest needs an equivalent
o Celest's most powerful/effective survival ability is thought to be trueheal
Therefore Celest should have universal trueheal.
The idea lacks imagination. Surely it's better for Celest to take its time and think of something as original and imaginative as the constructs of the other organisations?
Clise2007-03-25 14:51:22
QUOTE(Elostian @ Mar 25 2007, 10:14 PM) 393495
Some say she has more computing power than Big Thought.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
I sense a pointy shoe incoming .. better duck
Gwylifar2007-03-25 15:00:15
QUOTE(Nico @ Mar 25 2007, 03:33 AM) 393391
Honestly, I don't understand the vehement anti-Celest trend out there. I noticed it before I left, and it was part of the reason I stopped playing, but to see it still is disheartening. Sure, we may deserve some of the anger due to our wars, but seriously. It's as if you people want to bathe in our blood by the gallons.
People in Lusternia really, really hate Celest. Just like they really, really hate Magnagora, Glomdoring, and Serenwilde. It's really unfair how fair it is.
I am always reminded of that Monty Python sketch where John Cleese is sitting at a patio table going on about the commies, when I hear the levels of rage people get under them about being anti-this and pro-that nation in Lusternia.
So, anyway, how about them constructs, eh?
Malarious2007-03-25 15:22:08
Please keep on topic.. however couple replies to things that werent on topic.
@Zacc
You truly have no clue about much of anything in Lusternia it seems, your ideas have all been rather bad, and people should knwo I am not one for personal attacks. As for jumping you with Krellan.. you are a city enemy I wanted blood and he was up there.. I checked he said sure. Not a big deal.
@Nico
Envoys are and are not biased. I naturally I have my guilds interests concerned. However that doesnt mean I wont look at other skills nor does it mean I will -try- to make us overpowered.. it wouldnt be too hard. I try to keep a balance and get things done and make the guild happy. I try to look at things as if I had them, not as how I see them.
Anyway.. wonder what will come of when AngelFont returns
P.S. Cherubs to slay Cherubs to slay
@Zacc
You truly have no clue about much of anything in Lusternia it seems, your ideas have all been rather bad, and people should knwo I am not one for personal attacks. As for jumping you with Krellan.. you are a city enemy I wanted blood and he was up there.. I checked he said sure. Not a big deal.
@Nico
Envoys are and are not biased. I naturally I have my guilds interests concerned. However that doesnt mean I wont look at other skills nor does it mean I will -try- to make us overpowered.. it wouldnt be too hard. I try to keep a balance and get things done and make the guild happy. I try to look at things as if I had them, not as how I see them.
Anyway.. wonder what will come of when AngelFont returns
P.S. Cherubs to slay Cherubs to slay
Unknown2007-03-25 16:01:39
QUOTE(Tresalyne @ Mar 25 2007, 08:36 AM) 393498
An observation:
The logic behind the involvement of trueheal in the construct seems to follow this line:
o Lich is Magnagora's most influential/effective/powerful survival ability
o Magnagora's construct gives them universal lich
o Celest needs an equivalent
o Celest's most powerful/effective survival ability is thought to be trueheal
Therefore Celest should have universal trueheal.
The idea lacks imagination. Surely it's better for Celest to take its time and think of something as original and imaginative as the constructs of the other organisations?
The logic behind the involvement of trueheal in the construct seems to follow this line:
o Lich is Magnagora's most influential/effective/powerful survival ability
o Magnagora's construct gives them universal lich
o Celest needs an equivalent
o Celest's most powerful/effective survival ability is thought to be trueheal
Therefore Celest should have universal trueheal.
The idea lacks imagination. Surely it's better for Celest to take its time and think of something as original and imaginative as the constructs of the other organisations?
Lich provides an ability to resurrect, which Magnagora didn't have... if you were a Geo who died on Nil and you didn't have conglutination and somoene used lastrites on your corpse, you'll have to pray... if you were an Aquamancer and you died on Nil and someone ate your corpse, someone could also sacrifce and resurrect you..
Celest has two ways of Resurrection, one of them that does not need a corpse. Magnagora didn't have none for their people...
Besides, if you think about it, Lich does fit the RP(people don't help you, you help yourself) and does not unbalance them at all.... Want balance? Alright.. make it so that you lose experience when you die and lich... if a normal dying costs you 20%, make it that when you Lich you lose 10% and when you die as a lich lose the other 10%... But I don't think experience should be the issue here, most of the playerbase can gain 20% by killing things for half an hour, so why strip that bonus for lich? Most of the people who use Lich just heartstop in order to get liched so they can be an undead...
Giving Celest Sacrifice for 0 power and the life of the Sacrificed is good
Ashteru2007-03-25 16:09:54
20% for me isn't done in half an hour. I am happy if I only need half a week for that.
Unknown2007-03-25 16:11:08
QUOTE(Ashteru @ Mar 25 2007, 10:09 AM) 393506
20% for me isn't done in half an hour. I am happy if I only need half a week for that.
that's why I said most of the player base.... now shush, minority and go guild hop or something
Ashteru2007-03-25 16:15:00
How about you go into Faethorn so I can hop onto you.
Unknown2007-03-25 16:17:14
QUOTE(Ashteru @ Mar 25 2007, 10:15 AM) 393509
How about you go into Faethorn so I can hop onto you.
Dude... I'm cool with you and Aiakon, but I don't swing that wway
Vaerhon2007-03-25 16:22:21
QUOTE(Elostian @ Mar 25 2007, 02:14 PM) 393495
Some say she has more computing power than Big Thought.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
Some say she sucks the moisture out of ducks.
All we know is... she's called Estarra.
Sucks... the moisture... out of ducks?
I have not the words.
I do, however, hypothesize that Divine-scale zaps may exist for the Eternal.
QUOTE(Tresalyne @ Mar 25 2007, 02:36 PM) 393498
The idea lacks imagination. Surely it's better for Celest to take its time and think of something as original and imaginative as the constructs of the other organisations?
Believe you me, other ideas were floated. Here's your chance to float one yourself!
For my part, I like the idea of the Light filling the body wholly. Borrow some of Ayridion's style, with white and heatless flames curling out of one's mouth or eyes from time to time. It won't be quite as apparent as being undead, but could show up in look, or semi-randomly, or as an alteration or addition to certain emotes, or some combination of the above.
Imagine...
Forren blinks, briefly shuttering the infernos of white flame that are his eyes.
Forren smiles wryly, releasing a flicker of white flame from the corner of his mouth.
Help me out here - there have got to be other neat ways to depict this.
Mechanically, who knows?
Keep the original contruct powers, less trueheal, and... make dazzle more like blanknote? So people can't just redef sixthsense instantaneously? Although that, or at least some work on dazzle, probably belongs with a general envoy slot, actually.
I did like the archetype-specific minor buff idea - flaming swords! Flaming angels! Flaming staffs! Flaming instruments! - but I can certainly see why generic benefits are better avoided.
Maybe an option to flare the aura, losing it to do room damage? Have to weigh problems with getting resurrected after losing the aura and attendent benefits mid battle against the chance to set fire to several foes.