Course we could all be wrong and it's a mysterious new person all along. Only time (and more episodes!) will tell.

EDIT:

EDIT: First series, not first game, wtf am I on about.

Your theories are starting to frustrate me

1. You were wrong about sylar, so why do you think in this case you might be right? (i.e. the show doesn't really try to trick the viewers all that much, or say that something is real when it is not.) What you see is what happened.

2. The Hatian takes away people's memories.

3. The inivislbe man who helped peter, was one of the original company men.

4. Watch it again, there is no astral projection. Where are you even coming up with this?

5. Don't forget there is a period of 4 months between Peter exploding, and what you see happening now. Everything that you see happening now (except for Hiro) is happenings 4 months after Peter exploded, unless it specifically says otherwise.


Anyone notice the traintrack music, whenever clair has to make a decisions, like she is a "crossing"? Or the watch ticking music whenever Sylar is about to kill someone? And whats up with the cockroach?

For most of these it just meh it's fun to talk about the possibilities it doesn't matter wether they are true or not, for example omg everyone who thought candice died was wrong "oh noes!" and the show let it's viewers believe that. I never expect to be right I just expect to open my mind and let it wander to see what possibilities I could find.

I just threw the ando thing out there, in a story if you knew the entire time that what ando saw was just a planted memory then the reveal would be a bit "...and?" while the characters are going "omg". It's like right now, you believe that someone was physically there and don't agree with other possibilities, it may be true and quite probably is, however in a world with superpowered people thing can happen. (You could also reference Nikki/Jessica at the start of the season until Nikki found out I don't remember knowing about her alter ego)

however
1.

2. Planting is different to taking

3. Cool so maybe it was him, however if that is what you believe then things such as how he survived come into question.

4. I wasn't actually suggesting that, just that a possible explanation is that she somehow has a presence that can be sensed and that this person has some ability to sense that presence when it comes into close proximity or focus to them. Astral projection that was just a term that popped into my mind while trying to explain my thought.

5. Umn k?

One of my friends commented that sylars theme music is only played when he is about to attack a hero but I can't be bothered checking, I think it's just his suspense builing music but they could have something there.

mitbulls: You don't know that the sword wouldn't have helped. Hiro "couldn't" use his powers for a long time in the first series because he didn't have Kensei's sword.

I think it's more likely to have been a projected person (there's no reason why Ando couldn't see it too) simply because you don't hear a person flying away and, shocked though he may have been, Ando isn't thick enough to miss something like a flying person.

Also, you're clearly wrong about the show saying when something is real and when it's not, daganev. The whole Candice character puts the lie to that.

The ticking's just part of Sylar's theme music. It played all the time in the first series - the episode when you see him not crazy and the one when he goes to see his mum especially.

I love the ticking music, it's badass.

Have you seen series 1 of Prison Break? One of my favourite characters in that is the unkempt, innocuous guy who breaks Paul's finger when he gives him lip. The fact that he doesn't look dangerous just makes him more sinister.