Amarysse2007-07-02 12:27:13
Good game. It was interesting to watch, but way too frustrating for me. I'm still annoyed that it was my first game, and you guys decided to "kill" me on the first day. Not to mention that I could have come back, if certain requirements were met. I know it's just the way the game played out, but it still left a bad taste in my mouth. There was no explanation, I had no idea what was going on with my role, and I didn't get to actually do anything as I didn't last through the first night.
Thanks for letting me play, anyhow, Requiem.
Thanks for letting me play, anyhow, Requiem.
Shiri2007-07-02 13:43:38
Died too fast to care. Heh.
EDIT: That was one crap role you gave me though. *peer*
EDIT: That was one crap role you gave me though. *peer*
Unknown2007-07-02 16:19:28
@Amarysse: To be fair, Okin died at the same time you got kidnapped, so he didn't really have a chance to do much.
@Shiri: I'm thinking that it might have been mean to stimulate conversation by using half the playerbase as canon fodder. I promise that next time I GM, I'll use a different mechanism.
I was telling Bali that next time I'll just have everyone set as investigators, and then just modkill someone during the night. And sometimes during the day. And then I'll tell someone halfway through that the town wins if they vote unanimously for me, but then I'll kill anyone that does.
@Shiri: I'm thinking that it might have been mean to stimulate conversation by using half the playerbase as canon fodder. I promise that next time I GM, I'll use a different mechanism.
I was telling Bali that next time I'll just have everyone set as investigators, and then just modkill someone during the night. And sometimes during the day. And then I'll tell someone halfway through that the town wins if they vote unanimously for me, but then I'll kill anyone that does.
Unknown2007-07-02 19:44:01
Very good game. If anyone does another I might play.
Daganev2007-07-03 00:51:11
Why didn't Shayle die the first night since we were talking to eachother?
Unknown2007-07-03 02:35:14
The mason groups didn't affect each other because it wasn't an action that went through me. Plus, I can't officially prove that you guys were actually talking.
Saran2007-07-03 06:14:25
I'd need about 14 people for the game I'd like to run, think there is enough interest?
Unknown2007-07-03 06:36:55
I'm definitely in. I'd just start a sign up thread and go from there.
Unknown2007-07-03 08:37:11
Ah it's not your fault I was killed req (well, I could say it was) it's just frustrating, I can never play past day one on these forums now.
Iridiel2007-07-05 14:06:20
I loved the game, even if I was lynched very very fast