I can only use either investigate OR protect one person per night. I investigated each night because information is valuable and given that looking back I wouldn't have saved anyone.

All of you APPEAR on the side of the town. However, it might be possible for one of you to be on the side of town but also a threat to us? Such as someone who was town but driven to become a sk, still might appear as town to me but actually isn't. This might also make sense when you consider there was only one death in each of the past two night rather than two and then one, lulling us into a false sense of security as it were.

Wow... I'm so confused.

I thought "Bones" was part of my role name. Will someone please tell me what show I'm from? (!)

The problem with the SK theory, Saran, is that a SK doesn't have a "win-with-the-town" win condition. If they did, that would make them a vigilante - and we'd have won by now.

Obviously, I was -very- wrong about the whole Bali/Saran/Shayle thing, so I don't know where to go from here. I don't even understand how we still have a game running. Othero was a really weird lynch, too, although it makes me think that the remaining scum is one of what Bali called "the little town team" - Anae, Saran and Bali. Well, obviously it IS one of you, because I know I'm not scum - but this should make the three of you consider each other.

If it -was- one of you, obviously that person wouldn't lynch me, because I'm the obvious suspect today. So you all know, I've been submitting night choices about 'tracking' every night, to no effect. Last night, I tried to track Bali. I haven't been able to discern my power having any effect as yet.

I really don't know what to do. You're the three who apparently had every reason in the world to trust one another - if two of you decide to vote against a third for a convincing reason, I'll join you, because at this point I have no information to differentiate between the three of you. Saran's role seems pretty powerful, though.

From what I've seen, we all have the same win condition. The possible loophole here is that one of us could be considered to be "terrorizing the town" if that logic makes sense, otherwise I guess I would go with Bali. He exploded when I voted for him and was insistent on me removing said vote.

There is always the other option where Requiem is just going to let us kill each other off so there is "only one"

oh and okin your show is "Bones" (Channel 7 and Fox8 in Aust) it's also the name of the female lead

oh tripple post

Okin you should also consider that defending Shayle when her role-claim pointed to her being scum also makes you seem sus because even if you weren't on the same team. If your goal was to destroy the town you would have a better chance of doing so with another scummy player around

I realised that, Saran.

The only defence I have against that is

-I freely admitted that I thought Shayle was scum
-Given my knowledge, I DID act in the best interests of the town, by trying to secure a vote for one of you.
-The fact that my pseudo-defence of Shayle would look so bad today is probably the reason I wasn't killed last night.

Who Framed Okin?

Instead of getting bogged down in all the "what-ifs" and "maybes" I'll go with my original gut and VOTE OKIN

Despite Saran's investigations I still think Okin is the best choice.

It occured to me that Anae and Saran could be scum, covering each other (or something else hostile entirely). But if they are, we cannot stop them. A game well played to both if thats the case.

So my vote goes to Okin, whether he be SK or scum. And Okin, if we do lynch you, and you're either SK or scum or cult or w/e, a damn well played game. If you're town, forgive the blunder, lol.

Well, since Bali opened the voting bag, I guess I'll go ahead and Vote: Anae

I have no direct information about her (like the rest of you), but she hasn't been as active; both during the whole game, and in these last, most recent days when there were only a few of us. I think Bali's right in that we have to take a bit of a stab in the dark here, but I'm obviously not going to vote for myself

Bali, Saran - consider that all of our roles say town, so there might be some misinformation here? Maybe go back and look over everything from the beginning which you might not have questioned earlier because we didn't know how evil requiem was. I feel kind of disadvantaged here; all I know is that I win with the town, and one of you three doesn't.

Oh,

I'm going to have to start reevaluating people again, aren't I?

Vote: Okin because you're the only one I haven't spoken to so far.

I believe Saran has been deceiving us. I am going to take a RISK here and say he is scum with the ability to investigate. Ever since I "vouched" for him he has been all too quick to hop on the bandwagon with Anae and I. He has been mixing true information in with lies (the mark of any good liar). I also think he tricked Anae. He wouldn't have hit Anae or I during the night, because we are apart of his supposed "team". Othero was the easiest target. He wouldn't have hit Okin either, because logically he would be next on our list. There was something about his response to my doctor question that just seemed...off. Saran is the puppetmaster investigator, but I don't think he is town anymore. Nothing personal, Saran - but the jig is up.

UNVOTE OKIN

VOTE SARAN

That's a far better reason than mine to vote for someone; all I had on Anae was that she was a bit inactive, at times. Also, you were damn right about Shayle. I guess I have no way to differentiate among the three of you, either, except who's most convincing - and Bali's quite good at convincing people of things. Unvote: Anae, Vote: Saran

Unvote: Saran

I had a thought; I'm still not sure about Anae, and if Bali and I are voting for Saran and we're wrong, Anae can ninja-lynch Saran and win. I'll wait to see what Saran says.

I also took a good long gander at Anae. She's deliberately tried to keep a low profile - although that is suspicious, it doesn't mean she's scum (or SK). I think it's one part being clueless one part trying to hide. Anae you told me you're starting to re-think people. I know you meant Saran. I think we gotta lynch him

Biting the bullet.

Vote: Saran

I'd like to point out in my defense I actually provided information about Okin he didn't share in his roleclaim (i think)

and again I didn't bandwagon, I posted logical reasoning for my vote on shayle which was the only one since the roleclaims. Where as the rest of you were going off "feelings"

VOTE: OKIN

he still seems the most likely to be scum

Please think logically I could have let you kill off Bali yesterday leaving one town left to kill and validating me somewhat. Killed someone during the night, moved to lynch shayle today, etc and would have won. But no I went for the person who we had the best evidence of being scum. By lynching Shayle the remaining scum have a harder time remaining annonymous so they probably wouldn't want that to happen

Oh and in every game I've played night powers are exlusive you can only use one no matter how many you have, therefore I couldn't be investigating you and killing someone

Damn, I'm pissed. Does the day end immediately now? Or can Anae re-vote? If it ends at a moot point, that's just stupid. GAH! Its 2 v 2 now... And if we don't get a proper vote soon will the day just end and whoever or whatever is stalking at night will be able to kill one of us?

Bleh, fugg it.

UNVOTE SARAN

VOTE OKIN

3 Okin, 1 Anae.

Okin yer dead.

Either way it's gg.

Okin = scum town has won
Okin != scum, scum kills tonight and wins tomorrow