Perhaps giving the weapon to Methrenton and him handing it back? Though I could have sworn similar coding is involved with nearly all mobs when you give them things they don't want to keep. (not that the message might not be unique like giving Surtami aslaran corpses)

This would be a great addition!! Yes please!

So, earlier today me and a few others did a little tour of Ethereal and talking about the Avatars which reminded me of this (not that I forgot). I just thought it'd be nice to remind of again and perhaps some more of the creative people can think of ways for the quests to work. So with that