Shiri2008-05-17 03:49:23
19 people, so 10 for a lynch I think.
Vote: Celina. I still want to hear from Silvanus though.
Vote: Celina. I still want to hear from Silvanus though.
Shiri2008-05-17 03:53:08
QUOTE(Shamarah @ May 17 2008, 04:47 AM) 512774
I believe you, as mason is the one role that is almost impossible to fakeclaim, but why on earth did you decide to claim right now? What possible purpose did that serve?
Because otherwise posting REVIVE DIAMONDAIS with no context would be really awkward?
Unknown2008-05-17 03:56:53
Wow that was a pretty lucky shot in my opinion. Let's see if we can do it again for another night!
And yeah Shiri why'd you do that, it's like putting a large bullseye on your behind :'(
I don't have a great suspicion of Celina because her very vague defense seemed unintentional and unrelated to the plot, didn't seem like she was trying to deter our votes away from Veracruz. But wait, if I'm defending her now and then she's Mafia that makes me suspicious then doesn't it
In any case, time pressure + gut feeling will just have me FoS Silvanus, FoS Othero for now. I'd like to hear Arix explain his blunder too, to confirm or disconfirm my suspicions on the former. Othero for reasons I implicitly made in my post... and I just sense something fishy (being from Celest I should know fishy :> )
And yeah Shiri why'd you do that, it's like putting a large bullseye on your behind :'(
I don't have a great suspicion of Celina because her very vague defense seemed unintentional and unrelated to the plot, didn't seem like she was trying to deter our votes away from Veracruz. But wait, if I'm defending her now and then she's Mafia that makes me suspicious then doesn't it
In any case, time pressure + gut feeling will just have me FoS Silvanus, FoS Othero for now. I'd like to hear Arix explain his blunder too, to confirm or disconfirm my suspicions on the former. Othero for reasons I implicitly made in my post... and I just sense something fishy (being from Celest I should know fishy :> )
Shamarah2008-05-17 03:59:01
QUOTE(Shiri @ May 16 2008, 11:53 PM) 512780
Because otherwise posting REVIVE DIAMONDAIS with no context would be really awkward?
That didn't mean you had to claim mason. You could have claimed one-shot resurrector or something.
Oh well.
Saran2008-05-17 04:00:22
QUOTE(Othero @ May 17 2008, 01:44 PM) 512772
I'm thinking Diamondis was not a mafia kill as she was not shot. Someone else with a different power must of done it as it is a different kill and they had the special power of blocking her role. So Mafia got blocked?
And Vote:Celina for now as she did want to defend Mafia.
And Vote:Celina for now as she did want to defend Mafia.
I wouldn't rely heavily on the night kill messages really, either someone blocked the mafia and could loudly declare as such right now or being a mason caused a different death method via night kill
Shiri2008-05-17 04:01:00
I know it's putting a bullseye on me, but I'm already getting in that position by being so active and everyone can tell I'm town no so the mafia have little chance of deferring attention to me. Plus, I wanted to rezz Dylara before they sniped me and I lost the opportunity.
Also, since you're going away you may as well vote someone (preferably Celina but there are other suspicious people wandering around.)
Also, since you're going away you may as well vote someone (preferably Celina but there are other suspicious people wandering around.)
Shiri2008-05-17 04:01:50
QUOTE(Shamarah @ May 17 2008, 04:59 AM) 512784
That didn't mean you had to claim mason. You could have claimed one-shot resurrector or something.
Oh well.
Oh well.
Hm. Ok, I didn't think that far ahead, my bad. Although then it would have raised the question of why I didn't rezz Xavius or Rika or whoever, right?
Saran2008-05-17 04:02:40
QUOTE(Shamarah @ May 17 2008, 01:59 PM) 512784
That didn't mean you had to claim mason. You could have claimed one-shot resurrector or something.
Oh well.
Oh well.
There would have quite quickly been demands as to why he would use it on an unknown role and not one of the known townies that had died.
Shiri2008-05-17 04:03:27
Right, that too, if I wasn't a mason I wouldn't have known Dylara was innocent.
Arix2008-05-17 04:04:12
I would vote for Celina, but I don't want to jump on the bandwagon, even though her defense of Veracruz seems suspicious now.
FoS: Celina
And Shou, what blunder?
FoS: Celina
And Shou, what blunder?
Unknown2008-05-17 04:06:47
I presume that would be posting during the Night?
Arix2008-05-17 04:08:10
I wanted to bump the thread and forgot we couldn't post at night
Shiri2008-05-17 04:09:23
Posting at night is a relatively minor crime. There are other reasons to vote for Arix, but Celina is definitely in the hotspot right now.
Kaalak2008-05-17 04:09:56
Very interesting so far
I'm very curious why the "murder weapon" has changed now
I'll read and post tomorrow!
I'm very curious why the "murder weapon" has changed now
I'll read and post tomorrow!
Arix2008-05-17 04:10:26
I really don't understand why people would vote for me, other than just not liking me for some reason
Xenthos2008-05-17 04:13:16
QUOTE(Shou @ May 16 2008, 11:56 PM) 512782
I don't have a great suspicion of Celina because her very vague defense seemed unintentional and unrelated to the plot, didn't seem like she was trying to deter our votes away from Veracruz. But wait, if I'm defending her now and then she's Mafia that makes me suspicious then doesn't it
You're already looking pretty clean, just being one of the first votes for Veracruz (I'm going to agree with Shiri's observation-- those who were instrumental in swinging the vote towards Veracruz are most likely not scum. Would've been easier just to let Shiri hang).
That said, I think I disagree with your assessment that it was a vague defense. It seemed to be about as strong a defense as someone can put up without drawing too much suspicion at the time ("Don't vote for him, he's just a bit of an idiot. Let's vote / bandwagon on this other guy instead"). The other posts she made after that were just further confirmations of the Shiri vote, and nothing else as of yet. She has a bit of explaining to do at the very least, and I would like to hear that.
Unknown2008-05-17 04:13:55
I thought the thread was pinned.. Anyway, I don't see any concrete reason to vote for you as of yet, Arix, and I'm guessing that the previous votes were pretty much just people trying to get things to move along.
Anyway, I'mma going to keep my vote back for the moment, at least until I get the time to go home and poke a bit at the previous posts. Uni open house later, whee!
Anyway, I'mma going to keep my vote back for the moment, at least until I get the time to go home and poke a bit at the previous posts. Uni open house later, whee!
Okin2008-05-17 04:14:53
QUOTE(Shou @ May 17 2008, 02:26 PM) 512782
Wow that was a pretty lucky shot in my opinion. Let's see if we can do it again for another night!
Congratulating the town = scummy.
QUOTE(Shou)
I don't have a great suspicion of Celina because her very vague defense seemed unintentional and unrelated to the plot, didn't seem like she was trying to deter our votes away from Veracruz.
Defending Celina = scummy.
QUOTE(Shou)
But wait, if I'm defending her now and then she's Mafia that makes me suspicious then doesn't it
Realises her defense of Celina is scummy and pre-defends, but somehow the defense of Celina still manages.
Giant FoS: Shou
Arix2008-05-17 04:16:12
I'm not too suspicious of Celina, I'm just KINDa suspicious. She probably knew as much about his role as any of us did
Shiri2008-05-17 04:21:13
So, votecount:
Arix: 1 (Silvanus)
Celina: 3 (Okin, Othero, Shiri)
Needs 10 total!
We need more votes. We have a clear target here (I just saw Celina lurking, but she didn't post, hmm) rather than these FoS's.
Arix: 1 (Silvanus)
Celina: 3 (Okin, Othero, Shiri)
Needs 10 total!
We need more votes. We have a clear target here (I just saw Celina lurking, but she didn't post, hmm) rather than these FoS's.