It's not like the OP skill mafia where role names matter. I don't think anything except looking at the numbers is going to help evaluate role claims.

Can't edit, but I also realized that I'm probably not the only non-standard role out there. I don't even really know what I do. Nevermind.

Vote: Ashteru

Eh.

Mass roleclaim is an absolutely retarded idea. I hope you weren't seriously suggesting it.

I was. It works brilliantly. I am no longer suggesting it after taking another look at this...stuff I can't use.

Still looking for Tyler.

Am I the only one a bit confused by this?

Anyone know who Edward and Xavier are?

Mass claim day 1 is an absolutely retarded idea. I'd vote for you just for suggesting it if I didn't think you were just doing it because you haven't thought this out properly.

- If we mass claim, the our power roles (doctor in particular) have to either lie or be outed. If someone claims doctor, they will obviously get killed the next night by scum. Therefore the only sensible thing for a doctor to do would be to lie and claim vanilla townie or something, but in that case if it is advantageous for them to claim later in the game they are now caught in a lie (and additionally, lynching a claimed vanilla is seen as less dangerous than lynching a claimed doc).

- Even if it weren't for the above problem, mass claiming still would get us nowhere. We have no way of catching scum who have made up a claim, as we do not have a list of roles that are present in the game, nor does the game have any apparent flavor to catch them out on (or if there is something that differentiates the mafia from the rest of the town, we don't know what it is yet).

No mass claim, please.

Mass claim would ruin alot of hard work. Please no.

If you guys are having a hard time finding a majority, I will just post a 24 hour deadline.

I'm pretty sure a mass claim wouldn't produce factual results for like 90% of the players, so I wouldn't worry about that. Still a bad idea though. I might vote Xavius too, actually. He's smart enough to have a convincing roleclaim himself, but that just makes suggesting it even sneakier.

vote: shaddus

Sorry bub

Shaddus: 4
Revan: 1
Silvanus: 1

Because of the large number of people, lurking is a really good strategy - so, I went down the list to find the first person who hasn't posted. I got to #1.

Vote: Revan

*cough* That's not embarrassing at all.

Unvote: Revan

Please await further voting based on me actually -reading- the posts.

Revan ninja'd you.

Vote: Shaddus

No reason other than he has votes, and it's going to take forever to get a majority.

Except Revan posted 2 posts before you. Different inactive person!

This is what I get for trying to play Mafia and Lusternia at the same time.

Ashteru: 2
Shayle: 1

Ashteru 1 now. I ninja'd you like Revan ninja'd Okin.

My vote isn't random


Vote: Othero