Mafia: My Little Pony vs. Care Bears

by Shamarah

Back to The Real World.

Shamarah2008-07-04 22:35:21
Vote Count



Casilu - 11 (Jigan, Silferras, Sarrasri, Furien, Lorick, Arix, Shayle, Balizar, Amarysse, Karnagan, Visaeris)
Jigan - 3 (Shiri, Exeryte, Casilu)
Shiri - 1 (Sthai)
Balizar - 1 (Othero)
Furien - 1 (Silvanus)
Exeryte - 1 (Diamondais)
Visaeris - 1 (Rika)

13 to lynch.
Rika2008-07-04 22:36:31
Meh, was hoping you'd take the opportunity to provide us with a full claim. You've had your chances, now it's time to move on. On the bright side, if you are indeed who you say you are, I'll know who to vote for the next day.

Unvote: Visaeris
Vote: Casilu
Casilu2008-07-04 22:37:46
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 4 2008, 03:36 PM) 528874
Meh, was hoping you'd take the opportunity to provide us with a full claim. You've had your chances, now it's time to move on. On the bright side, if you are indeed who you say you are, I'll know who to vote for the next day.


That is a full claim. Only thing I missed was that I was called a twit. I was not given one restriction which even made me suspicious.
Amarysse2008-07-04 22:37:54
QUOTE(casilu @ Jul 4 2008, 12:57 AM) 528534
Vote: Shiri

Sorry, but something feels off.



QUOTE(casilu @ Jul 4 2008, 01:15 AM) 528559
No idea, instinct for me.



QUOTE(casilu @ Jul 4 2008, 04:01 PM) 528779
I never said it was Shiri. I just said something felt weird. I think it was Jiggy-poo more than Shiri, personally. I don't trust the Jiggles.

Unvote
Vote: Jigan


QUOTE(casilu @ Jul 4 2008, 05:13 PM) 528837
I am, actually. My main reason for voting on Shiri was to apply some first day pressure and get things moving. Something just felt off about voting for him, but I'm still not sure what that is. And really, I couldn't get any more specific about my role unless it was a direct quote, I was given no conditions, and even asked because I just thought it was a one-time thing, but it seems it is not.


...And these are just the posts relevant to the question I've asked repeatedly that you still haven't clearly answered.

Casilu, even if your roleclaim is false, for all we know you might still have a way to avoid dying at night, so your being alive tomorrow wouldn't really prove much, would it? You have not made any convincing arguments that you're not scummy. If you aren't, I'm going to feel bad if you're lynched, but I would think you could have a much more solid defense.
Unknown2008-07-04 22:40:09
So we're sitting at 12/13.. Now we wait for one of the largely inactive people to get involved..

Thusfar it's been the same group of people doing almost all of the talking.
Casilu2008-07-04 22:41:23
QUOTE(Amarysse @ Jul 4 2008, 03:37 PM) 528876
...And these are just the posts relevant to the question I've asked repeatedly that you still haven't clearly answered.

Casilu, even if your roleclaim is false, for all we know you might still have a way to avoid dying at night, so your being alive tomorrow wouldn't really prove much, would it? You have not made any convincing arguments that you're not scummy. If you aren't, I'm going to feel bad if you're lynched, but I would think you could have a much more solid defense.


I would know I should have given it a restriction if it was false. I would have tried to make it more believable. I'm not a complete idiot. I know how to lie. I would have said like I can hide once or something, not every night without restriction.
Casilu2008-07-04 22:43:17
Also, I forgot who said it, but that is a really specific name and was one of the first on the wiki, wouldn't it make sense that Shamarah would have given that role to someone else knowing that a lazy Mafia-person would just pick the first one on the list?
Amarysse2008-07-04 22:46:20
QUOTE(casilu @ Jul 4 2008, 05:43 PM) 528880
Also, I forgot who said it, but that is a really specific name and was one of the first on the wiki, wouldn't it make sense that Shamarah would have given that role to someone else knowing that a lazy Mafia-person would just pick the first one on the list?


...Or, instead of trying to throw up defenses based on speculation, you could just address the issue I've been harping about for the last couple of pages, and I'd be more likely to consider retracting my vote.
Unknown2008-07-04 22:48:30
QUOTE(Amarysse @ Jul 4 2008, 03:46 PM) 528885
...Or, instead of trying to throw up defenses based on speculation, you could just address the issue I've been harping about for the last couple of pages, and I'd be more likely to consider retracting my vote.


I think it's kind of interesting that you keep giving her chances as she just keeps digging her hole deeper and deeper.

I'm just enjoying watching. I think we're past the point of no return on this one.
Casilu2008-07-04 22:50:26
QUOTE(Amarysse @ Jul 4 2008, 03:46 PM) 528885
...Or, instead of trying to throw up defenses based on speculation, you could just address the issue I've been harping about for the last couple of pages, and I'd be more likely to consider retracting my vote.


I can't even defend it to me. I thought Shiri seemed suspicious early on, as well as the Jiggles, but something didn't feel right when I was voting for him. In all the Mafia games I've played with Shiri, I've always trusted him, even ask him on the American revolution one, on Night one I told him my role.
Amarysse2008-07-04 22:53:42
QUOTE(Visaeris Maeloch @ Jul 4 2008, 05:48 PM) 528888
I think it's kind of interesting that you keep giving her chances as she just keeps digging her hole deeper and deeper.

I'm just enjoying watching. I think we're past the point of no return on this one.


The only two times I've tried playing, I've ended up dead almost immediately. The first time was a nightkill (I think on the first night, or maybe second), and the second, I took over someone's role and they were also immediately nightkilled. So... I've gotten to watch a lot of games in-progress, but I don't have a lot of practical experience, and I really am going to feel bad if I helped lynch someone who turns out to be innocent.

That being said, I just want her to answer the darned question. dry.gif
Amarysse2008-07-04 22:58:46
Bah, ninja'd! tongue.gif

In any case, that still doesn't explain why you voted for Shiri over Jigan, but I guess we'll find out whether you were telling the truth about your role or not.
Casilu2008-07-04 22:59:50
QUOTE(Amarysse @ Jul 4 2008, 03:58 PM) 528896
Bah, ninja'd! tongue.gif

In any case, that still doesn't explain why you voted for Shiri over Jigan, but I guess we'll find out whether you were telling the truth about your role or not.


Mostly because of every first day I've played so far, random pressure on the first day to see who does what. People already started going for Shiri, so I did too.
Karnagan2008-07-04 23:11:02
What do you think of all this, Xiel?
Arix2008-07-04 23:12:00
Hi Xiel!
Xiel2008-07-04 23:13:00
Vote: Casilu

Extensive claims of innocence when proven false is a no-no.

Though I AM suspicious of Amarysse who's just going for the jugular.


(Did I do it right? sad.gif)
Xiel2008-07-04 23:13:45
You people scare me. I was just trying to word my sentence right. -weep-
Karnagan2008-07-04 23:14:18
You did.

Sorry Cas... that's a lynch.
Casilu2008-07-04 23:15:47
Just bury me in an expensive pyramid, to hell with a cheap funeral.
Shamarah2008-07-04 23:16:05
That's a lynch!

Casilu - 13 (Jigan, Silferras, Sarrasri, Furien, Lorick, Arix, Shayle, Balizar, Amarysse, Karnagan, Visaeris, Rika, Xiel)
Jigan - 3 (Shiri, Exeryte, Casilu)
Shiri - 1 (Sthai)
Balizar - 1 (Othero)
Furien - 1 (Silvanus)
Exeryte - 1 (Diamondais)
Visaeris - 1 (Rika)

13 to lynch.