Amarysse2008-07-05 20:52:46
I really have to agree with Visaeris. Casilu's had many, many opportunities to defend herself or make a decent argument for her innocence. I kept trying to pressure her for something, anything that seemed sincere, but she wouldn't stop being evasive. I suppose I should have taken the hint when she refused to answer questions earlier, and instead flatly said she wouldn't be saying anything else until she got the necessary 10 votes to force a roleclaim.
Rika2008-07-05 20:53:52
Myrkr, I feel you are misrepresenting Casilu's defenses. All those statements above them were made this day. Those defenses were made the last day. Casilu hasn't yet been around to say anything else.
Unknown2008-07-05 20:53:53
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 01:52 PM) 529143
Bleh, Xenthos ninja'd me. I need to read these things more carefully, especially when I just woke up. But still, why would Shiri roleclaim so early on?
Unvote: Shiri
Unvote: Shiri
What
Were you even..
You participated int he bandwagon.
He was near lynch. he roleclaimed.
Xenthos2008-07-05 20:54:58
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 04:52 PM) 529143
Bleh, Xenthos ninja'd me. I need to read these things more carefully, especially when I just woke up. But still, why would Shiri roleclaim so early on?
Unvote: Shiri
Unvote: Shiri
...
Because you, and 10 other people, led a bandwagon on him, which was only stopped by his roleclaim. After which, you unvoted him.
I'm going to vote: Casilu at this point, but Rika... you're not a newbie to this. What the heck are you going on about?
Unknown2008-07-05 20:56:07
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 01:52 PM) 529143
Bleh, Xenthos ninja'd me. I need to read these things more carefully, especially when I just woke up. But still, why would Shiri roleclaim so early on?
Unvote: Shiri
Unvote: Shiri
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 01:53 PM) 529146
Myrkr, I feel you are misrepresenting Casilu's defenses. All those statements above them were made this day. Those defenses were made the last day. Casilu hasn't yet been around to say anything else.
I'm really starting to get a dirty, dirty feel reading these posts.
Casilu has had many chances, why does she get another? what more is there to say that she hasn't refused to say?
Furthermore, you *know* Shiri roleclaimed on day 1. You were there.
FOS: Rika
Amarysse2008-07-05 20:58:18
It would be nice to hear what Casilu has to say about the pardon, but unless it also provided completely incontrovertible proof of her innocence, I don't think it will help her at this point.
Unknown2008-07-05 20:58:30
Vote Count:
Casilu: 12 (Jigan, Bali, Arix, Silferras, Visaeris, Othero, Amarysse, Myrkr, Celina, Xenthos)
Casilu: 12 (Jigan, Bali, Arix, Silferras, Visaeris, Othero, Amarysse, Myrkr, Celina, Xenthos)
Unknown2008-07-05 20:58:32
One more thing about giving Casilu another chance. If she is scum there is a good chance she has some sort of last ditch power.. Sham used a bunch last game. We really shouldn't give her the chance to use one.
Unknown2008-07-05 20:58:49
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 04:53 PM) 529146
Myrkr, I feel you are misrepresenting Casilu's defenses. All those statements above them were made this day. Those defenses were made the last day. Casilu hasn't yet been around to say anything else.
Oh! I know that.
The defenses she made the last day are the ones that made everyone suspicious, aren't they, and make those statements today?
I'm saying that what made me suspicious is that she had said those things, not that she had said them today.
And those statements are very convincing. If it's a one-shot ability, and her only ability, the only reason she would use it is to save her tushy and make sure she doesn't die on the first day.
But that would put her up to be lynched another day, wouldn't it?
What if she has that ability, and it is a one shot, but she's not really a pony or pro-pony? She could have done it, then, so that a pro-pony will protect her. And that would be bad bad bad.
Or an anti-pony could have the ability and used it on her, knowing she's anti-pony too!
It just doesn't seem like something a pony would do. Nope.
Unknown2008-07-05 20:58:52
err bollocks. 10. Sigh. My hangover's killing me. 2 to go
Rika2008-07-05 20:59:20
I actually unvoted Shiri because everyone else unvoted. I was just voting with the bandwagon then. At the same time, I thought I should vote Visaeris, and so I did. I really do need to start reading with more detail/more carefully. But usually, on day one, it's all just random voting anyway.
Unknown2008-07-05 21:00:24
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 01:59 PM) 529155
I actually unvoted Shiri because everyone else unvoted. I was just voting with the bandwagon then. At the same time, I thought I should vote Visaeris, and so I did. I really do need to start reading with more detail/more carefully. But usually, on day one, it's all just random voting anyway.
... That's not completely terrible at all. Investigator can we get a snoop on rika tonight please?
Amarysse2008-07-05 21:00:41
QUOTE(Visaeris Maeloch @ Jul 5 2008, 03:58 PM) 529154
err bollocks. 10. Sigh. My hangover's killing me. 2 to go
Little too much Pony Punch, Vis?
Unknown2008-07-05 21:01:43
QUOTE(Amarysse @ Jul 5 2008, 02:00 PM) 529157
Little too much Pony Punch, Vis?
More like 24 ozs of scotch straight up without dinner last night...
Man things were movin, I tell you what.
Rika2008-07-05 21:02:12
Sure, waste an investigation on me. It'd just prove my innocence.
Lorick2008-07-05 21:02:53
Eh, regardless, still no word or new clues or suspicions.
Vote: Casilu
Vote: Casilu
Unknown2008-07-05 21:03:45
QUOTE(rika @ Jul 5 2008, 02:02 PM) 529159
Sure, waste an investigation on me. It'd just prove my innocence.
And yet, I'm still waiting for an explanation as to what particular part of my proof against Casilu you disagree with.
You say you want to give her a chance for more information. How many more chances does she get? Let's set some hard numbers. Do we ask her 3 more times and if she continues to be evasive then we lynch?
I'm open to being reasonable, but you need to step up and explain why you haven't voted against Casilu with the preponderence of reasons to do so.
Shamarah2008-07-05 21:04:16
"Casilu is at 1 from re-lynching" Vote Count
Casilu - 11 (Jigan, Balizar, Arix, Silferras, Visaeris, Othero, Amarysse, Myrkr, Celina, Xenthos, Lorick)
Jigan - 1 (Shiri)
12 to lynch.
Casilu - 11 (Jigan, Balizar, Arix, Silferras, Visaeris, Othero, Amarysse, Myrkr, Celina, Xenthos, Lorick)
Jigan - 1 (Shiri)
12 to lynch.
Unknown2008-07-05 21:04:57
Where's my damn pony picture, Shamarah?
Unknown2008-07-05 21:05:12
Oh it just hadn't loaded. Very good then, carry on.