Mafia: Elder Wars Redux

by Rika

Back to The Real World.

Shiri2008-08-08 03:55:52
Oh yeah, Myrkr goes in the same category as Silferras/Shayle/Aesyra, though I'd like to hear more from her too since all I remember from her is saying that her gut feeling was that she didn't know who was suspicious.
Unknown2008-08-08 04:02:55
QUOTE(Myrkr @ Aug 7 2008, 07:01 AM) 541921
I'm not sure if we should vote for Shou or not. Call it... instinct? confused.gif


I said this after people voting for Shou.

A couple of posts later, Shou roleclaimed as Eventru.
Unknown2008-08-08 04:13:45
I feel compelled to point out that even though I have felt since early on that Lorick is suspicious, and haven't changed my mind since then, I'm not voting for Lorick. I want to make sure people are still aware that it's theoretically possible for Lorick to still be scum. I haven't been encouraging people to vote for him, I'm urging the cop (Shiri) to investigate him.

I voted for Bael for the same reason everyone else was: to put pressure on him.

Unote: Bael
Daganev2008-08-08 04:21:18
You know, I'm starting to find Xenthos suspicious personally.
Shiri2008-08-08 04:22:03
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 8 2008, 05:21 AM) 542312
You know, I'm starting to find Xenthos suspicious personally.

Can you explain why?
Unknown2008-08-08 04:26:59
QUOTE(Shiri @ Aug 8 2008, 12:22 AM) 542316
Can you explain why?


Dag doesn't like bears. He's a Lusternian Stephen Colbert.
Shiri2008-08-08 04:29:10
Heh. Funny you should say that, before he went krokani he used to be one of Lusternia's most famous stupid tae'dae.
Daganev2008-08-08 04:29:38
QUOTE(Shiri @ Aug 7 2008, 08:53 PM) 542284
Main suspects on my list:
Okiisakana
Daganev

I will probably have to reread some stuff later because I haven't got good evidence on anyone off the top of my head.
Silvanus and Thul are innocent, and my inclination is to believe Shou.
Xen and Eldritch have contributed useful-seeming stuff in the short span of my memory, as has req.
Revan and Lorick may be subject to an investigation so I want to leave them be.
Shayle, Silferras and Aesyra have not been particularly productive but i don't register them as lurky or scummy either.
Bael will speak up tomorrow and hopefully Zetsu will continue to contribute when not at work.

That leaves the fish dude and Dags, both of whom have aroused my suspicions previously and neither of whom have done much to alleviate it.


Odd, that I got ninjaed by so many comments... anyway...

What exactly has Eldritch contributed that was so usefull? I think everyone on your list has pretty much contributed the same amount, other than Bael and Zetsu.
Unknown2008-08-08 04:30:55
Rika, if you're not too terribly busy (and not already doing it), might we have a vote count, please? Thank you.
Daganev2008-08-08 04:32:21
QUOTE(Myrkr @ Aug 7 2008, 09:26 PM) 542319
Dag doesn't like bears. He's a Lusternian Stephen Colbert.


ROFL... Actually I loved Tae tongue.gif


As to why I find him suspcious.

Well, he keeps hinting at things without actually saying them. The other people who have done that have been jumped on for doing so, while he has not.

The whole, I'm saying things but not really saying things is what has gotten my ears perked.
Unknown2008-08-08 04:32:50
That still doesn't explain why you find Xenthos suspicious Daganev.
Unknown2008-08-08 04:33:03
Bah ninjaed
Xenthos2008-08-08 04:33:24
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 8 2008, 12:32 AM) 542327
ROFL... Actually I loved Tae tongue.gif
As to why I find him suspcious.

Well, he keeps hinting at things without actually saying them. The other people who have done that have been jumped on for doing so, while he has not.

The whole, I'm saying things but not really saying things is what has gotten my ears perked.

I'm kind of interested in what I've hinted at without actually saying... excepting that Bollikin is around and doesn't want to claim yet.
Daganev2008-08-08 04:34:09
QUOTE(requiem dot exe @ Aug 7 2008, 09:13 PM) 542302
. I haven't been encouraging people to vote for him, I'm urging the cop (Shiri) to investigate him.



Now, it is possbile that I have just missread your posts, but that has not been the impression I've been getting from you lately.

I feel as though you have been trying to suggest that the only real way to know for sure is to lynch them.
Shiri2008-08-08 04:34:14
QUOTE(Xenthos @ Aug 8 2008, 05:33 AM) 542330
I'm kind of interested in what I've hinted at without actually saying... excepting that Bollikin is around and doesn't want to claim yet.


Again, is there any disadvantage to bollikin claiming? I feel like we had this discussion but this thread is way too long to find it.
Shiri2008-08-08 04:36:28
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 8 2008, 05:34 AM) 542331
Now, it is possbile that I have just missread your posts, but that has not been the impression I've been getting from you lately.

I feel as though you have been trying to suggest that the only real way to know for sure is to lynch them.


I was getting this impression too, and I am still not totally opposed to the idea, but maybe I just value masons too low.
Xenthos2008-08-08 04:36:53
QUOTE(Shiri @ Aug 8 2008, 12:34 AM) 542332
Again, is there any disadvantage to bollikin claiming? I feel like we had this discussion but this thread is way too long to find it.

We did. I said I didn't think so, but Bollikin feels otherwise and doesn't seem to want to come out just yet. No clue why, especially since it was confirmed that there's no special power there either, but whatever. *prod Bolly*
Unknown2008-08-08 04:37:18
At least to me, Xenthos in and out (from my limited experience and knowledge) of mafia games seems to express himself indirectly. I think Dag might not be used to that, maybe?
Daganev2008-08-08 04:38:26
QUOTE(Xenthos @ Aug 7 2008, 09:33 PM) 542330
I'm kind of interested in what I've hinted at without actually saying... excepting that Bollikin is around and doesn't want to claim yet.


Thats my problem, I can't remember what you have said or not said, except that bollikin hasn't made themsevles known to us yet. Everytime I go to look thinking you havn't posted much, I see that you have. (same concern with lorick, but I know I missed a day of his posting after he claimed him and Revan were together)
Xenthos2008-08-08 04:39:54
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 8 2008, 12:38 AM) 542336
Thats my problem, I can't remember what you have said or not said, except that bollikin hasn't made themsevles known to us yet. Everytime I go to look thinking you havn't posted much, I see that you have. (same concern with lorick, but I know I missed a day of his posting after he claimed him and Revan were together)

Then I think you have some kind of "gloss over Xenthos posts" thing. I've posted way more than I ever do!