QUOTE(Thul @ Aug 15 2008, 10:02 PM) 546495
I should not have lived that long. 
Turns out I'm a bit of a dumbass and didn't connect the doctor ability to Maylea, until a few days later when I actually got around to reading her writeup. The line about protecting the other elders with enchantments is actually in there... go fig. 
Thanks for playing along with the bomb thing, Shiri. That was great. 
Turns out I'm a bit of a dumbass and didn't connect the doctor ability to Maylea, until a few days later when I actually got around to reading her writeup. The line about protecting the other elders with enchantments is actually in there... go fig. Thanks for playing along with the bomb thing, Shiri. That was great. But I thought the bomb thing was cool.
QUOTE(Xenthos @ Aug 16 2008, 03:52 AM) 546528
I actually guessed "Thul is the doctor" once I went through all the roles and realized it couldn't really be anyone but him. And then figured Shiri was covering it up. Though by then, it was nearly the last day, heh.
That was the point I pulled out the "Zetsu was lying about the armour" part, but...
QUOTE(Shiri @ Aug 15 2008, 10:59 PM) 546534
That was the point I pulled out the "Zetsu was lying about the armour" part, but...
Yeah, except I didn't buy it. There was no reason for him to lie about the armour, and if he actually had, you'd have gone after him for it. Immediately. Having people think you're highly resistant to nightkills is a better strategy than inviting them to target you at a 50/50 shot.
That was fun! If Bael didn't get ninja-lynched, the Fates probably wouldn't have been offed so quickly. Still, good game and awesome ending. 
I'm glad Town lost. Eh, but I still think it was stacked agaisnt the Traitors.
1) The ridiculous amount of Nightkill immunity abilities I mean, maybe if we had it or something. Both my mafioso's died to a NK.
2) One-shot investigation. I thought it was unlimited, then Myrkr was like "Oops, it's not ." I was going to have her use it on Thul.
3)The revive might have worked, if Silvanus didn't already have the ability.
4)Mason Groups (though this worked agaisnt all the scum, somewhat).
5) Shou, seriously, WHY!? Even if I had killed her after finding that out, I would've been lynched because everyone would have noticed her dogging me all the time and say "Well, I guess that means Archer's Fain.", at least the smart people would.
Otherwise, nice game! Still pissed about the ninja-lynch! Die Revan. :|
1) The ridiculous amount of Nightkill immunity abilities
I mean, maybe if we had it or something. Both my mafioso's died to a NK.2) One-shot investigation. I thought it was unlimited, then Myrkr was like "Oops, it's not ." I was going to have her use it on Thul.
3)The revive might have worked, if Silvanus didn't already have the ability.
4)Mason Groups (though this worked agaisnt all the scum, somewhat).
5) Shou, seriously, WHY!? Even if I had killed her after finding that out, I would've been lynched because everyone would have noticed her dogging me all the time and say "Well, I guess that means Archer's Fain.", at least the smart people would.
Otherwise, nice game! Still pissed about the ninja-lynch! Die Revan. :|
QUOTE(Archer2 @ Aug 17 2008, 05:07 AM) 546742
I'm glad Town lost. Eh, but I still think it was stacked agaisnt the Traitors.
1) The ridiculous amount of Nightkill immunity abilities I mean, maybe if we had it or something. Both my mafioso's died to a NK.
2) One-shot investigation. I thought it was unlimited, then Myrkr was like "Oops, it's not ." I was going to have her use it on Thul.
3)The revive might have worked, if Silvanus didn't already have the ability.
4)Mason Groups (though this worked agaisnt all the scum, somewhat).
5) Shou, seriously, WHY!? Even if I had killed her after finding that out, I would've been lynched because everyone would have noticed her dogging me all the time and say "Well, I guess that means Archer's Fain.", at least the smart people would.
Otherwise, nice game! Still pissed about the ninja-lynch! Die Revan. :|
1) The ridiculous amount of Nightkill immunity abilities
I mean, maybe if we had it or something. Both my mafioso's died to a NK.2) One-shot investigation. I thought it was unlimited, then Myrkr was like "Oops, it's not ." I was going to have her use it on Thul.
3)The revive might have worked, if Silvanus didn't already have the ability.
4)Mason Groups (though this worked agaisnt all the scum, somewhat).
5) Shou, seriously, WHY!? Even if I had killed her after finding that out, I would've been lynched because everyone would have noticed her dogging me all the time and say "Well, I guess that means Archer's Fain.", at least the smart people would.
Otherwise, nice game! Still pissed about the ninja-lynch! Die Revan. :|
Maybe Raezon should have got one or two more investigates. Or I could have just made the Traitors a cult.
QUOTE(rika @ Aug 16 2008, 04:43 PM) 546857
Maybe Raezon should have got one or two more investigates. Or I could have just made the Traitors a cult.
You must have been screaming at the computer when everyone fell for the Lyreth bit.
QUOTE(Myrkr @ Aug 16 2008, 08:47 PM) 546861
You must have been screaming at the computer when everyone fell for the Lyreth bit.
Oh, right, I forgot. *headbutt Myrkr in the face for
1)Getting me lynched
2) Defending Shou and stopping her from getting lynched.
QUOTE(Archer2 @ Aug 16 2008, 04:49 PM) 546863
Oh, right, I forgot. *headbutt Myrkr in the face for
1)Getting me lynched
2) Defending Shou and stopping her from getting lynched.
1)Getting me lynched
2) Defending Shou and stopping her from getting lynched.
I 
you?