Builder Gods Versus Coder Gods - why the disparity

by Neuf

Back to Common Grounds.

Nocht2008-08-29 17:09:54
I don't think the topic is something to get yourself that angry about.
Myndaen2008-08-29 17:11:42
QUOTE(Desitrus @ Aug 29 2008, 10:03 AM) 551596
I'm sure that Charune is a creative void, like all other programmers. Especially ones that have played RP Enforced MUDs for years. This isn't some random sample of humanity at large, it's a MUD where the vast majority of people can already write and be creative. Take the office example I provided. Everyone there is proficient with a PC and Windows. Not everyone there is capable of creating a VB App to sit on top of a proprietary contacts database. This proficiency doesn't mean that the programmers are failures at Windows and need the secretaries to hold their hand while they do it. The environment they exist in leads to a certain common skillset being shared by all departments. So too, in an RPE environment, easily 95% of the people there are already creative and possess writing skills. You get the few amazingly bad typists and uncreative people, but by and large the people here are already creative and able to write/roleplay by virtue of actually being here.


The administrators of Lusternia aren't some random sample of the MUD players at large, it's a small circle where the vast majority of people can EITHER write good code (look at fighters like Narsrim and Thoros) or be REALLY creative (look at RPers like Aiakon and... Other RPers.) Why wasn't Aiakon a good fighters? Why couldn't Thoros write an emote/roleplay to save his life?

This still holds true in the havens. You have people who can't really code for crap, you have people who can't really be creative for crap. Sorry, but I just disagree with the administrators of Lusternia being a niche of people who are all always creative and can code everything they could possibly want.
Desitrus2008-08-29 17:12:22
QUOTE(Nocht @ Aug 29 2008, 12:09 PM) 551599
I don't think the topic is something to get yourself that angry about.


Which part of that was angry? Sure there's sarcasm, I hear I'm a pretty sarcastic guy. On the whole it was mostly plausible examples of skillsets and comparisons regarding resource allocation. Do offices make you angry Nocht? Repressed cubicle anxiety?
Daganev2008-08-29 17:12:30
sad.gif Some of us have amazing writing abilities; it just doesn't show up in our writing. sad.gif

For I have perfect spelling... but sometimes the letters get all jumbled.
Myndaen2008-08-29 17:13:06
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 29 2008, 10:12 AM) 551602
sad.gif Some of us have amazing writing abilities, it just doesn't who up in our writing sad.gif

For I have perfect spelling, just sometimes the letters get all jumbled.


Don't forget your grammar, too. tongue.gif
Desitrus2008-08-29 17:14:47
QUOTE(Myndaen @ Aug 29 2008, 12:11 PM) 551600
The administrators of Lusternia aren't some random sample of the MUD players at large, it's a small circle where the vast majority of people can EITHER write good code (look at fighters like Narsrim and Thoros) or be REALLY creative (look at RPers like Aiakon and... Other RPers.) Why wasn't Aiakon a good fighters? Why couldn't Thoros write an emote/roleplay to save his life?

This still holds true in the havens. You have people who can't really code for crap, you have people who can't really be creative for crap. Sorry, but I just disagree with the administrators of Lusternia being a niche of people who are all always creative and can code everything they could possibly want.


You think Thoros and Narsrim can't roleplay? I believe your arrogance and distaste for certain people is clouding your vision. They can both role-play perfectly well when they want to. Aiakon was a better fighter than you have ever been and he's one of the most creative people I know. I also know for a fact that he can code, and what? Who said all of the people in the havens can code everything they want AND always be creative? That is the exact distinction I am making. They can all write, but can they all code on par with someone who does it professionally? I sincerely doubt it.
Nocht2008-08-29 17:15:28
I'm sitting in a cubicle right now actually...

And as a side note, let's talk nice to each other.
Desitrus2008-08-29 17:16:16
QUOTE(Nocht @ Aug 29 2008, 12:15 PM) 551605
I'm sitting in a cubicle right now actually...


Get some Motivational posters up then and turn that frown upside down!
Unknown2008-08-29 17:16:36
QUOTE(Nocht @ Aug 29 2008, 01:15 PM) 551605
I'm sitting in a cubicle right now actually...


Me too. smile.gif
Moiraine2008-08-29 17:19:28
QUOTE(Desitrus @ Aug 29 2008, 05:16 PM) 551606
Get some Motivational posters up then and turn that frown upside down!


laugh.gif
Daganev2008-08-29 17:20:17
Boo cubicles!

If your cubicle has solid wooden walls, is it still a cubicle? *prays not*
Unknown2008-08-29 17:24:53
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 29 2008, 01:20 PM) 551610
Boo cubicles!

If your cubicle has solid wooden walls, is it still a cubicle? *prays not*


Yes. Yes it is. Just more flammable.

I think we should create forum-Orders of Creative Gods, Coding Gods, and "All of the Above" Gods, complete with Shrines and everything.
Moiraine2008-08-29 17:25:53
I elect myself head of the Order of the "None of the above" Lazybones Gods. freaked.gif
Charune2008-08-29 17:33:44
An interesting thread.

On the subject of creativity - I do not consider myself to be the most creative. However, I am very good at the implementation of existing ideas. We have people who excel with new ideas and people who excel with making those ideas reality. There are some who are very good at both as well.
Myndaen2008-08-29 17:34:52
QUOTE(Desitrus @ Aug 29 2008, 10:14 AM) 551604
You think Thoros and Narsrim can't roleplay? I believe your arrogance and distaste for certain people is clouding your vision. They can both role-play perfectly well when they want to. Aiakon was a better fighter than you have ever been and he's one of the most creative people I know. I also know for a fact that he can code, and what? Who said all of the people in the havens can code everything they want AND always be creative? That is the exact distinction I am making. They can all write, but can they all code on par with someone who does it professionally? I sincerely doubt it.


They can all write, but can they all write on par with someone who does it professionally? I sincerely doubt it.

Your point is being mired in an attempt to discredit me for your personal dislike for me. What are you arguing? You said in your previous posts that the people in the havens who aren't coders aren't likely to get what they want because they can't code. Now you're saying that everyone has some measure of skill with writing and coding, but then why can't everyone get whatever "rp gimmicks" they want?

All I'm saying is that for the most part the people in the havens can EITHER write great events, descriptions, design great areas, etc. OR code amazingly complicated systems, and that VERY OFTEN, they help each other out. I believe it's not correct to say that people who can't do things themselves don't get anything like those who can, even in a "general" sense.
Unknown2008-08-29 17:58:00
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 30 2008, 01:20 AM) 551610
Boo cubicles!

If your cubicle has solid wooden walls, is it still a cubicle? *prays not*


Is it still a cubicle if it only has three sides? freaked.gif
Desitrus2008-08-29 18:26:39
QUOTE(Myndaen @ Aug 29 2008, 12:34 PM) 551616
They can all write, but can they all write on par with someone who does it professionally? I sincerely doubt it.

Your point is being mired in an attempt to discredit me for your personal dislike for me. What are you arguing? You said in your previous posts that the people in the havens who aren't coders aren't likely to get what they want because they can't code. Now you're saying that everyone has some measure of skill with writing and coding, but then why can't everyone get whatever "rp gimmicks" they want?

All I'm saying is that for the most part the people in the havens can EITHER write great events, descriptions, design great areas, etc. OR code amazingly complicated systems, and that VERY OFTEN, they help each other out. I believe it's not correct to say that people who can't do things themselves don't get anything like those who can, even in a "general" sense.


Could everyone building for IRE write professionally and be published? I sincerely doubt it. Could everyone coding for IRE do it professionally? I bet so. My point was simple, that the two aren't mutually exclusive but most everyone CAN write, but most everyone can't CODE on par with professionals. You just like to sit behind your neat little walls and poke out as usual.

Pay attention to the bolded area because I never said that. I said they have to ask for coders to help with it. I said that coders tend to get it done faster because they just do it themselves. If there's no OLC mechanic for prog'ing it yourself, you have to ask someone who can manipulate the source. It's a resource not available to you. It causes the time disparity that Neuf mentioned. You know, the original post that some of us at least attempt to adhere to? Once again you come and twist my words out of your personal hatred for me, it's rather cute, but it still doesn't work.

I remember Charune's roleplay and it isn't near as bad as he's playing it down just to appease people. Good game on dropping the Thoros and Narsrim bits though, I'm sure if Narsrim could still post he'd be rolling your face clean off at the moment. Why in the world did you bring up Aiakon out of the blue though, I wonder... Yes, yes I wonder.
Doman2008-08-29 18:30:48
Desitrus, You're awesome, but I'm detecting a tiny bit of elitism here.
Desitrus2008-08-29 18:33:23
QUOTE(Doman @ Aug 29 2008, 01:30 PM) 551634
Desitrus, You're awesome, but I'm detecting a tiny bit of elitism here.


I've never denied such. don-t_mention.gif
Hazar2008-08-29 20:59:12
Elitism tends to crop up around programmers because it's a field where numbers do not easily outweigh skill, and individuals can be as effective as teams. As such, talent rises to the top.