Mafia Signups

by Ryleth

Back to The Real World.

Daganev2008-08-31 08:47:43
QUOTE(Shiri @ Aug 31 2008, 01:35 AM) 552315
I don't see the problem then. If you vote them for their consistent previous behavior and they react maturely instead of having a temper tantrum and lashing out at people, you can change to someone else. It's just that that hasn't happened yet in the case of certain individuals.


Except that of course once a bandwagon starts, there is nothing a person can really do to prove that they won't behave a certain way in the future... which is the whole point.
Shiri2008-08-31 08:52:57
QUOTE(daganev @ Aug 31 2008, 09:47 AM) 552318
Except that of course once a bandwagon starts, there is nothing a person can really do to prove that they won't behave a certain way in the future... which is the whole point.

I don't see why not.
Unknown2008-08-31 09:11:03
Could we at least agree that it is a terrible tactic in general? You most likely have no idea what role someone has. If you go "lol, I hate player A Vote: Player A" and then a bunch of people agree, then congratulations, there is the serious potential you killed the doctor. I mean, look at last game. If Celina didn't bow out she was probably going to get lynched which would of shot scum in the foot, though they did that themselves even before Revan outed his other scum.

Edit: And in fairness to Ryleth if this discussion continues it might as well be its own thread.
Doman2008-08-31 09:23:36
this probably should get its own thread, but, if it's going to go to the degree that some censor.gif is going to get a good role, then ruin the game with their attitude, the game...IS RUINED, it's no fun for anyone, and the entire point is lost.
Shiri2008-08-31 09:29:49
QUOTE(Othero @ Aug 31 2008, 10:11 AM) 552324
Could we at least agree that it is a terrible tactic in general? You most likely have no idea what role someone has. If you go "lol, I hate player A Vote: Player A" and then a bunch of people agree, then congratulations, there is the serious potential you killed the doctor. I mean, look at last game. If Celina didn't bow out she was probably going to get lynched which would of shot scum in the foot, though they did that themselves even before Revan outed his other scum.

It's not a terrible tactic. If someone is going to play such that the town is more likely to lose, lynching them over an unknown is not terrible.

And it's not like Celina didn't have a chance either game. Myrkr's, she flipped out over a bandwagon which wasn't even necessarily going to lynch her, just get discussion, and killed someone basically at random (hitting on the 5/11 chance to get a scum.) Bandwagons generally don't lynch without -any- reason unless A) the day drags on way too freakin' long or cool.gif no one stops them by reminding them bandwagons aren't supposed to do that (unusual.)

EDIT: Fair enough on continuing it in another thread though. Maybe hijack Doman's.
Unknown2008-08-31 13:08:03
Mememe! biggrin.gif
Unknown2008-08-31 14:23:42
Actually, I'm out, man.
Unknown2008-08-31 15:04:59
guess ill play
Ryleth2008-08-31 15:08:57
Xavius has a minute to post if he wants in, before I roll numbers ;p
Xavius2008-08-31 15:12:34
I had to make sure that the other game was actually over. It was way, way too fast for there to be another game already!

But...yeah, it's over. WTF?

In!
Ryleth2008-08-31 15:15:13
And the lucky numbers were:

1 casilu -
2 rika -
3 shiri -
4 othero -
5 furien -
6 saran -
7 arix -
8 archer2 -
9 shaddus -
10 daganev -
11 silvanus -
12 xikue -
13 silferras -
14. xavius -
Doman2008-09-21 17:14:27
Someone pinned the wrong thread
Daganev2008-09-21 22:39:36
fixed