Just a big WTF to Shadow.

The game would have been very different, if people were not told who converted them etc.

Yeah...Casilu and Silferras were both made aware Alianna was the scum leader, which certainly didn't help our cause even without the 5/5 thing.

Well, for instance, I knew it was her, which is why I tried for Saran.

But then, when I knew Furien was about to get lynched anyway, I figured , hey, I would have a few more days, and not look AS suspicious, by changing my vote.

Yeah, makes sense, but by then I think Ryleth had decided that by process of elimination you were our last convert (since we'd be trying to get the vig/rezzer...neither he nor we knew Casilu and Silferras had our identities) so he was bound to go for you anyway. Not that it was a bad move, you didn't really have any other option.

You know, you could have just agreed with me with ryleth being the US.... silly people. (I thought ryleth was either the doctor or the reviver, didn't realise they were both!)

I could, but I think my position was stronger by jumping on you commies (I was sure you were scum, even before Doman died) since I figured you'd be a threat and we didn't need two chances a night to lose a convert (grah.) What I -should- have done, though, was pressured to lynch you first. If you looked like you were going to get out of it I still could have nuked you.

And I hadn't picked up on the tells that Ryleth was giving to be doctor/reviver, what gave that away?

So like...

I won this game right, because I blew up UK and USSR and got modkilled for "being an idiot?" How about a keen sense of who was who and saying GG to the fact that I killed a member of mafia and cult revealing their roles on day one.

But no.

You only nuked because you got pissy. Don't even try to play it off like you weren't doing anything but raging.

Keep in mind, the game before this, Celina ragekilled Rika on day 1, and Rika was scum.

Yes, ragekills can get lucky, doesn't mean you should do them

I would have modkilled Silvanus even if the nukes would have hit townies.

Like hell was that a "keen sense of who was who", heh.

I actually just asked Revan who I should nuke.

It was Revan's keen sense to pick out two people, so props to him.

Ok, let me tell you something. It wasn't his "keen sense" either.

Umm, didn't silvanus just admit to breaking ANOTHER rule?

Yup.

Revan wasn't playing, that's not quite the same.

Yeah, talking about the game is okay, like "Oh man, the game is fun" but actually talking about what you plan to do, and the gameplay itself, is not cool

I dunno, I don't think it'd be too bad if you talked to say...Aison about it.

I see your point, but I disagree. If you're asking for advice, you're not playing the game yourself