He is?
Vote: Silvanus

I've been thinking about it and I've decided it could actually be advantageous for us not to lynch today. The greatest advantage we have in this game over the scum is that we can freely share any information we get from our roles. Instead of lynching someone who could help us in the long run, we can find out more tonight (including whether or not Casilu is a terrorist).

Unvote
Vote: No lynch <-- mind the double

Oh :censored:

Got ninja'd..

Well.

Remind me to e-thump Casilu sometime.

You miscounted. I went and counted before I posted, and again after this bit.


Unofficial vote count:
Daganev - Noola, Doman, Furien
Casilu - Myrkr
Silvanus - Rhayni, Arix, Simon, Shiri, Casilu
No Lynch - Rika(x2)

When Casilu added her vote, he was at 7. Then of course, Rika retracted hers.

At least, I think I counted right.

Hmm! You're right! False alarm, sorry.

Silvanus,

You seem to think I came up with assumptions based on nothing. I thought I explained myself rather well. I looked at Daganev's wagon and at the behavior of people on and off of that wagon. You and Silferras stuck out to me and appeared to me to have a possible connection. And don't forget I mentioned Furien as well. I'm here to play mafia and for you that may be sitting back and not talking and not voting, but for me it's the opposite. I -actively- seek scum, and the best way for me to do that is to seek out anything that might be suspicious and talk about it. However, I also back up what I say with votes because I think people who don't are pansies talking out their rear-ends.

And are you trying to say that because I've played a lot of mafia, I should keep quiet and not give any thoughts because too many people in the game are inexperienced? Part of my experience is also having played with people entirely new to mafia. It doesn't matter which forums people are on. And forgive me if I don't have a meta on you or anyone else, but I find that part of this game rather exciting. There's no preconceived notions of certain players to muddle my thoughts.

Preview: Oh well, nevermind.

You guys are confusing me with the votecountingness.

unvote

No more near-misses. I'm not done with this discussion.

vote: Silferras

FoS still holding on Silvanus

Do not want to vote Silferras today. If you're suspicious of both, please kill Silvanus today and save Silferras for tomorrow. Even if she is scum, it's in her interests to kill Casilu, AND ours, so I want to give her that chance.

Sorry, I forgot Silferras was that person.

Fine, fine.

unvote, vote Silvanus

Although I'd personally like to hear from both Furien and Silferras before a lynch happens.

Vote: Shiri

Whatever happened to pushing people for information? You seem more intent on killing to advance the day, regardless of who it actually is, just so Silferras can kill Casilu tomorrow and you can do whatever tonight. To me, it seems scummy pointing people to come to a lynch soon, with 'please kill Silvanus today.'

What do you mean, whatever happened to it? Is there any that hasn't been given out? Daganev was supposedly away (I can believe that), Rhayni and Arix gave their input, Arix also gave my input, Silferras confirmed someone as not the Canadian...is anything missing?

Seems like a pretty fragile accusation there...and besides, the alternative you seem to be presenting involves killing Silferras, the only person able to cleanly kill the Canadian, such that we won't be able to realistically tell if she's a scum or canadian and force us to potentially blow ourselves up getting rid of her.

I didn't alter any alternative, I suggest gathering more information, and there are still very few who have posted less then me. The only way we have to gather more information is from discussion and poking and proding people, and you seem more intent on ending that to get a new day to get more hardcore evidence by lynching me.

Seems to me like a mafioso pushing for a lynch so they can go on another free day, and do more damage.

None of you are going to consider the no lynch option?

No lynch is a bad idea, it just leaves us open to mafia without gaining any information on voting patterns.

I am going to unvote since we got some posting back. I probably won't be around much tomorrow

If you didn't offer any alternative, then criticising the only constructive plan is highly scummy.

No lynch is bad because then we don't have a chance to kill the mafia, and our information gain isn't any more reliable than the average night.

Did some posts get deleted? I could have sworn i saw more...I made an unvote post for sure

Meh, ignore me, forum bug