You know, I realize what Shiri meant, but damn, he's REALLY gunning for me, isn't he. 
Thanks for the helpful modhint! 
I'm confused too. I take it that this has about the same state of canon as the UN game had.. But with the span of the Marvel series and all its spinoffs, I really don't know what to think.
At least we didn't lose Shaddus, though, or it would have be a three-person loss for the town in the first day/night cycle alone. Until our investigator gets solid scum information (I presume they haven't, or they would have spoken up; please don't do so otherwise!), I think we can work on the 3-scum, one SK (Galactus?) premise for now.
I'm confused too. I take it that this has about the same state of canon as the UN game had.. But with the span of the Marvel series and all its spinoffs, I really don't know what to think.
At least we didn't lose Shaddus, though, or it would have be a three-person loss for the town in the first day/night cycle alone. Until our investigator gets solid scum information (I presume they haven't, or they would have spoken up; please don't do so otherwise!), I think we can work on the 3-scum, one SK (Galactus?) premise for now.
Modhint number two: This game is as canon as a mafia spinoff game can get, really. I.e you will not be seeing a supervillain like Mandarin being a good guy! 
.
.Add me in the same boat as Diamondias. I had a real 
up evening and I will post something in the morning when I wake up.
up evening and I will post something in the morning when I wake up.QUOTE(daganev @ Oct 30 2008, 05:04 AM) 577397
Actually, this line confuses me... can you explain it a bit better?
You thought silver surfer must be scum, because of galatixa.
You thought silver surfer must be scum, because of galatixa.
Sure. Basically, your second line is wrong. I thought A) Krin was lying about being Silver Surfer to save Shaddus, and just playing badly (also note last game where he didn't even bother roleclaiming as a mason at all), due to his refusal to give any details and the fact he was trying to get me to roleclaim for pressuring Shaddus over his bad logic, or
he was the silver surfer and that was a scum role because of galactus. That's not a complicated part of the canon or anything, it's like the main point of the silver surfer other than that he's silver and has a surfboard.Then I DIDN'T use complicated canon knowledge to pair up Silver Surfer with the Invisible Woman like they said. I probably should have checked but their posting was just really bad.
QUOTE
What you should have been thinking was, what scum would be stupid enough to claim a mason pair, when as soon as one of them is investigated at night, you will lynch both of them?
He could have said his name was Sam and he was a mason with Shaddus. It really shouldn't have made a difference. Cause again, what scum would claim mason when they don't know who the investigator is yet?
He could have said his name was Sam and he was a mason with Shaddus. It really shouldn't have made a difference. Cause again, what scum would claim mason when they don't know who the investigator is yet?
I did this once with Dylara, and it worked pretty well actually. I didn't pick up an investigate at all, though I eventually got vigged when Shamarah put that piece together with an unrelated one beyond my control.
Also we know Krin plays badly from last game so it's not like it was out of the realms of possibility that he just incorrectly thought it was a good tactic. He's new at it anyways. Dugan had some pretty obvious scum tells from last game, that's how I was able to vig him.
I apparently am bordering on lurker. 
I don't really have anything too constructive to add to the conversation, unfortunately...
I don't really have anything too constructive to add to the conversation, unfortunately...
I'm also bordering(?) on lurkiness, but I'll try to avoid it.
The Surfer/Invisible Woman mason pair was a bit odd, although I can see in hindsight where it came from. I kept my vote on Shaddus because, simply, Krin's roleclaim (and Shaddus', although that came later) wasn't believable. Or it might be because I always have difficulty deciphering Krin's posts without automatically adding a whine to it.
But the fact that we had a resser and a roleblocker means this is a high-powered game. Most of this seems to be countered by a chance to fail/succeed. Hopefully, the scum is affected by similar limitations - and after we get one of them, we'll know roughly how likely they are to hit.
The Surfer/Invisible Woman mason pair was a bit odd, although I can see in hindsight where it came from. I kept my vote on Shaddus because, simply, Krin's roleclaim (and Shaddus', although that came later) wasn't believable. Or it might be because I always have difficulty deciphering Krin's posts without automatically adding a whine to it.
But the fact that we had a resser and a roleblocker means this is a high-powered game. Most of this seems to be countered by a chance to fail/succeed. Hopefully, the scum is affected by similar limitations - and after we get one of them, we'll know roughly how likely they are to hit.
