Actually I think thats exactly what you might do.

However the reasoning would be more like: "Ooh, 3 people voted, there's a chance we can lynch em, and since people already gave reasons, I can just repeat one of them."

Since as mafia you don't care who gets lynched as long as its not one of your own.

Its the only concrete information we have outside of Celina's / Casilu's convenient claims.


Also, someone above said that casilu claimed to have a nightkill abiliy. He said he only said that to get the mafia to waste an kill attempt on him. So he was being decietfull with that statement on purpose, to confound the mafia.

So.. vote count..

Silferras 1 Daganev
Celina 1 Shiri

Discuss more!

Well, to get things moving along...I'll go ahead and vote.

VOTE: SHIRI

This might change, since I'm only going on what i percieve to be mildly suspicious reasoning and a hunch.

I think voting Silferras is a bad idea. Just reading over her posts, she doesn't come across as scummy.

Celina has the same ability this game she did in the Sonic game? Damn people getting nightkill avoidance twice *mutter*

You guys are really bad at this. Discuss/vote/lynch more!

Not really much to go on right now.

Oh yeah? MODKILL XEN.. oh wait.

Aww.

I'll sign up to be Doman's ghost, so you can modkill me!

We have four people who haven't posted very much, they are our bottom four lurkers .... Ilyarin, Furien, Celina and Esano. Celina has claimed Capt. America and no one has countered with anything. Ilyarin has had the least amount of input, so since he is flying under the radar ....

VOTE: Ilyarin

What? I'm considered a lurker?

So am I, but that's at least half-deserved. I tend to make few posts, although I try to have them all contain something important.

Plus, no-ones talking.

We're all guilty of that, currently. We could just go out and pick on lurkers as is suggested, but that's always risky after two nights.

It might not be the best strategy, but no one really jumps out at me as being suspicious. Some people playing seemed to have fallen off the face of the world. It seems to be the same people posting again and again, with some staying hidden. We can't really count on any imput from Shiri ... he is off playing his new system.

My train of thought was going after someone flying under the radar and see if anything materializes from it.

As I said, I am posting when I feel I have something to say. I'm not like Shiri or Daganev who post a lot, but I don't think I've been posting minimally. In fact I have been forcing myself to post even when I really don't have much to add, just because otherwise I know I'll be a "lurker". I don't think Shiri is suspicious at the moment so I don't know why Celina is voting for him, I think it's pretty clear why he's not here. I know, atleast, that when I get a new toy I pretty much play with it 24 hours a day for the first week or so. I'm going to have another read over the recent posts and see if I feel anything in particular.

Okay well, currently my only feelings of suspicion are on Daganev and Celina, the former for the strange vote on Silferras and the latter for the strange vote on Shiri. Beyond that I'm not really feeling anything... Not concrete enough to place a vote when so far every death has been one of us. I want to be convinced, or very nearly convinced, that the person I'm voting for is scum before I vote at the moment.

I see Shiri reading the thread at the moment, but there have been problems with the reader reporting thing before haven't there?

Ooh hello Shiri

Er...yo. *actually in the thread, several hours later*

It sounds like the reason Celina is voting me is that she doesn't like the reason I'm voting for her. Which is kind of understandable, I guess (and not in the "of course she would OMGUS vote" way). I'm not in any kind of role that would provide useful information of any kind, so I've only got what's in the thread to work from, and with a bunch of people that aren't posting anything that could put them in the line of fire I can't see much even if I wasn't playing PS3 stuff (DMC3, woo). So I'm just going to keep my vote on Celina because I kind of dislike her roleclaim, and if anything better comes up (or the person trying to bring up something better looks like a scum themselves) I'll change as appropriate.

I don't think my reasoning is that bad, but lacking any support I'll go back to my vote yesterday
unvote
Vote Celina