Wow.. just.. wow... a whole night's sleep and three exams later, two posts have been made. Here's the vote count.

Celina 2 Shiri Daganev
Dugan 1 Ilyarin

Also, let this be a prod for all of you who aren't even making an attempt to contribute.

I'm still leaning towards Shiri. However, I'll give him benefit of the doubt, and VOTE:CELINA for now. If she turns up town, Shiri is scum.

No he isn't. If you have any better ideas, put 'em up. You'll just screw up by lynching me if I'm wrong on this one, I'm not even confident.

Hey, just reading over some of the posts. This looks pretty fun, though kinda confussing, never done a Mafia game before. If there is going to be another one, I might like to try it.

Might be awhile at this point, usually we do them back to back.


Okay, uh. Conversations. Nobody is really setting off anything for me, sure, there's sketchy like Daganev's "4th vote" theory on Silf, and I don't see Celina so suspicious now. No idea who to vote for.

Personally, my suspicions lie on three people- Ilyarin, Daganev and Celina.

Celina having yet another nightkill resistance amongst the ones we already have in the game strike me as suspicious.

Ilyarin is slightly lurky for understandable reasons, but it still makes me suspicious.

Daganev's pushing against Silferras, though, is swaying me the most. It doesn't make any sense, yet it's still there despite how well Silferras has defended herself.

So, I'll Vote: Daganev for now.

I am not suspicious of Celina. I really think she is who she says she is, expecially since no one has come forward with any counters to it. I wouldn't really call Daganev's actions suspicious, just as I don't really see Shiri as suspicious. Ilyarin isn't really all that suspicious either, he has just be one of the more quieter ones.

What incredibly odd logic, Shaddus.

What doesn't make sense about it, and what better information do we have to go off of at this point?

I would vote no-lynch if if was even feasible, but it's not potential information we want to risk passing up, especially now that we have such a dearth of it. It'd pretty much just give the mafia/SK(?) a free night's romp.

Celina doesn't feel like scum from what I'm reading, but we don't seem to have any other leads at the moment, either. I'll settle for a Vote: Ilyarin for now, unless someone comes up with something. I still remember how Casilu completely pulled the wool over the town's eyes in her first game, claiming inexperience.

If it was even feasible, I mean.

It was the '4th joiner' thing. That seemed really baseless, to me, but you admittedly did go back on this decision, so I should probably do the same.

Unvote
Vote: Ilyarin, lurkiness is bothering me. Talk!

That reminds me of Casilu's earlier "Let's lynch Celina if she isn't NK'd!" thing. Any similarities between the two?

For reference, and so you can use the traceback arrow thing to have a look at context.

Wait, what? Did you quote the wrong post?

No, but maybe I should have quoted this too. Again excusing a scummy move due to inexperience/not thinking.

No, no, I mean it looked like your first quote was meant to have quoted this:



..instead of my another-game Casilu comment, given the context of the response.

Oh. Wait. I'm just confused.

But for some reason, Shaddus' reasoning now sounds a lot like Casilu's previously..

Nobody ever said I was logical.

And Shiri tried to get me lynched the first day. I mean, come on..... Reed Richards JUST died, and now you want to lynch his wife?

On that note, the signup for the next mafia game should be going up within 36 hours.

You didn't have to go and prove it.


You should probably wait until this one's done, to be fair.