Wat? None dead? Neat!

I think...

Though a question has been nagging on my mind for so long.

Why haven't we brought with us any phoenix down??

Relevant.

So, I bumrushed Dugan and Thiden, and from that nobody died. (as I suspected)

Since its most likely that Terra is still town, and not on some twister charachter, and since Dugan allready partially admited that he isn't town...

Vote Dugan

And I did not get any message from Shad when day broke that I am now on the towns side. As I said on my claim, I am not town I have the chance to become town.

Vote: Dugan

He is the only one that has claimed to not be town, and is a safe person to lynch, unlike me, since I'm town.

And the reason why I'm here is I have a cracked Phoenix esper that gives me a 50% chance to survive a lynch, like the one yesterday.

I suggest bum-rushing Rika, as she is the only that has not claimed a name yet (aside from Dugan), and it is highly plausible that her lie-detector skill could be a mafia skill.

Oh one last thing, I was not allowed to talk about the Phoenix Esper until it was used.

So ... wait. You have a 50% chance to avoid any action taken against you and on top of that have a 50% chance to survive a lynch. That just seems a bit overpowered ...

I posted my role. I am currently not town. I never claimed to be town. I have the chance to become town. I thought the purpose of the game was to stop the mafia ... not just the people who are not currently on the towns side.

VOTE: Silvanus.

You have all of these people who claimed town.

You have all of these people who claim town. You know some of them have to be lying. I am not claiming town, what on earth would I gain from claiming non-town? And Dag, you are right. I am not town, I am a safe bet to lynch ... but I can become town. Why take out a possible future townie than going after the real mafia people?

I have already told you people Rika is Town, I investigated her on the first night...why would you waste an ability on someone that is already confirmed town?

I have also claimed a name. It is Shadow. I am town.

I'm finding Silvanus suspicious, so I'm thinking of using Interceptor to see if Silvanus' claim was real or not. Thoughts?

I say check Silvanus. Dugan is a bit suspicious, but, Silvanus is as well.

I am Locke.

I win with the town, have no alternative win condition, not been culted, and cannot be considered scum.

Ok, claims that I am currently finding suspicious. (not because I think they are lieing about who they are, but because I think they are witholding information/not telling the truth about thier allegiance)

1. Aerton: The ability for Krin to force Aerton's vote doesn't make sense to me, unless Aeroton is scum.

2. Myrkr: With 3 mason groups, it makes sense that one side of one of the mason groups is a scum/townie group.

3. Silvanus: The crazy death/life thing. (but I think Shaddus is just wierd enough for that to be real) BTW, Only scum would want to lynch Silvanus again, without giving us a chance to get new information.

4. Dugan, he might be telling the truth, but if one of the above 3 arn't scum, he must be. (btw, Dugan why arn't you claiming a name at all????)


Here is my list of poeple we know are townies:
1. Arix
2. Daganev
3. Kiradawea
4. Krin

Here is my list of people who are 80% townies:

1. Rika
2. Amarysse
3. Esano
4. Ilyarin
5. Thiden

Dag, I am voting for Silvanus again. And I have two reasons. First, his ability claims. 50% immune to any targetted ability, now on top of which he has a 50% chance to avoid being lynched. Not a nightkill, he posted 50% chance to avoid being lynched. Why would a townie have a 50% chance to avoid being lynched? Reason number 2, he posted that you should use your bum-rush ability on Rika. She can use her ability to verify a post. Why on earth would you want to block someone who can tell whether a post is truthful?

I did read the fine print in my role again, and the Phoenix Esper is only a one shot power.

This is Shaddus first mafia game as moderator, why do you still find non-typical things suspicious? Have you met Shaddus?

*shares the jerky* Here are my notes from partially re-reading the thread...

1:Rika - claimed Shadow (town) - reliable 2 shot lie detector.
2:Arix - confirmed Edgar () - confirmed chainsaw daykill.
3:Myrkr - claimed Biggs (town) - confirmed inactive mason pair with Wedge.
4:Daganev - claimed Sabin (town) - confirmed bum rush ability.
5:Kiradawea - claimed Cyan (town) - claimed revenge death.
6:Amarysse - claimed Relm (town) - powers unknown.
7:Thiden - name unknown - claimed investigator.
8:Krin - reliable Mog (town) - reliable tracker & ability to change Umaro's vote.
9:Aerotan - claimed Umaro () - powers unknown.
11:Dugan - name unknown. - claimed neutral survivor sort with a chance to become town.
12:Silvanus - claimed Locke (town) - claimed 50% chance of targetted abilities failing, and some sort of anti-lynch.
13:Esano - confirmed Setzer (town) - confirmed coin flip (gained one-shot ability to investigate).
16:Ilyarin. - confirmed Gau (town) - confirmed leap ability.

Okay well let's see... I'm still suspicious of Silvanus, he's got a lot of powerful (and strange) abilities for someone who's town. FoS Silvanus.

Going back, I see that Daganev potentially did something really stupid when he bumrushed Thiden and Dugan, which was to say "If I'm right, nobody will die tonight." This is pretty much a clear sign to the mafia, if they are not Thiden and Dugan, to do nothing tonight because they can instantly shift suspicions onto those two. Oops Daganev! I think you normally have more wit than that in a mafia game. However. The ability itself plays out so I don't really think you're scum.

Amarysse needs to come back. <3

I agree that having three mason pairs is excessive. It's pretty likely, therefore, that atleast one is a town-scum pairing IMO. Biggs/Wedge are the only names I recognise, and from where I recognise them, they weren't particularly "friendly". Therefore, FoS whoeverTheOneLeftAliveIs

I'm pretty comfortable that Kiradawea is town after Esano's test.

So from the list... The people I think we should be looking at are:

Arix
Myrkr
Thiden
Aerotan
Dugan
Silvanus

---

Actually I'm also really suspicious of Aerotan now. He's not claimed any abilities, and a pretty-much-confirmed town can change his vote, which would be unusual if Aerotan was town. So, Vote: Aerotan.

And just what are you implying?

Ooh, Shaddus is around, and I'm feeling lucky ....

FLIP COIN

Be nice to me, Shaddus, like you were last time?

I am here, and checking, I promise!

It's just... We got Fallout 3 last night... I started playing around 2am, when my sweetie quit to go to bed... and it's now 8:45.

Oh! Silvanus needs to add, "and cannot be considered scum" to the end of his "check me!" line if Rika's going to verify him.

I do think it's suspect that he can avoid investigations, and haven't made any secret of that, but now I also think it's strange (in light of the phoenix/esper claim) that he could avoid a lynching, as a townie.

Will post again when I awaken from the coma I'm about to fall into now. Oh, but it's so worth it.