I always play to live. That's what I think is fun in the game. 
But okay, let me try to clarify again.
Let us say that we have person X and Y.
X is active within the game. Posts often, but ultimately he isn't all that helpful. He gives no new information, is very undecided, can't bring himself to vote. In the end, he plays, but he doesn't make the game and townies progress.
Y isn't active at all. He has posted maybe once or twice, if that much and doesn't really care about the game much. He helps the Town just as much as X does.
In THIS instance, I will vote for Y, because while both are equally negative to the Town, at least X will have more fun by sticking around.
It is a player to player mentality. Not an IG mentality that makes me say that.
And bear in mind that this is a completely hypotetical situation. In most circumstances there's gonna be an avid poster that notifies him or herself as more scummish than the others, true, but again, this is hypotetical.
Or to write it in plain black. If I had to pick between Shaddus and Archer2 to vote for, I would vote for Archer2, because Archer2 is not playing for some reason, so he/she will not be as disappointed as Shaddus from being lynched.
But okay, let me try to clarify again.
Let us say that we have person X and Y.
X is active within the game. Posts often, but ultimately he isn't all that helpful. He gives no new information, is very undecided, can't bring himself to vote. In the end, he plays, but he doesn't make the game and townies progress.
Y isn't active at all. He has posted maybe once or twice, if that much and doesn't really care about the game much. He helps the Town just as much as X does.
In THIS instance, I will vote for Y, because while both are equally negative to the Town, at least X will have more fun by sticking around.
It is a player to player mentality. Not an IG mentality that makes me say that.
And bear in mind that this is a completely hypotetical situation. In most circumstances there's gonna be an avid poster that notifies him or herself as more scummish than the others, true, but again, this is hypotetical.
Or to write it in plain black. If I had to pick between Shaddus and Archer2 to vote for, I would vote for Archer2, because Archer2 is not playing for some reason, so he/she will not be as disappointed as Shaddus from being lynched.
QUOTE(Kiradawea @ Dec 5 2008, 11:52 AM) 590522
I always play to live. That's what I think is fun in the game.
Or to write it in plain black. If I had to pick between Shaddus and Archer2 to vote for, I would vote for Archer2, because Archer2 is not playing for some reason, so he/she will not be as disappointed as Shaddus from being lynched.
Or to write it in plain black. If I had to pick between Shaddus and Archer2 to vote for, I would vote for Archer2, because Archer2 is not playing for some reason, so he/she will not be as disappointed as Shaddus from being lynched.
You should be comparing Archer2 to someone like Runther, because Shaddus is not being "unhelpfull" he is being potentially detrimental!
Sorry I haven't been posting!
Reading over all of the posts, including Daganev's helpful post count list, I still think it would be better to vote for an inactive person than Shaddus. Even if Shaddus is making nonsensical, detrimental comments, at least he's posting. But someone who doesn't comment on the game is not helping at all. (I am somewhat guilty of this, haven't been able to get on computer much and when I do my connection is awfully slow
)
But yes Shaddus, do post and give us info!
Oh, and Unvote. Random vote isn't helping much.
Reading over all of the posts, including Daganev's helpful post count list, I still think it would be better to vote for an inactive person than Shaddus. Even if Shaddus is making nonsensical, detrimental comments, at least he's posting. But someone who doesn't comment on the game is not helping at all. (I am somewhat guilty of this, haven't been able to get on computer much and when I do my connection is awfully slow
)But yes Shaddus, do post and give us info!
Oh, and Unvote. Random vote isn't helping much.
Oh man, you guys posted a lot since when I left last night. 
Not entirely certain what went on with the Shaddus bandwagon, and if it's still continuing but I guess from reading it had to do with him comparing what people have done skill wise with the actual game?
Not entirely certain what went on with the Shaddus bandwagon, and if it's still continuing but I guess from reading it had to do with him comparing what people have done skill wise with the actual game?
