Well, in ANY case, we don't have ANYTHING to go on now

We know that Jack isn't loyal to the shipwrecked survivors, but that seems a poor excuse for a lynch.

True... he's got a win condition that is pro-town, doesn't he? So, he's a good guy. Course, he's also been used once to attack folks. But, that might've been a one-shot.

well, if he wins, we lose, AND we have to kill him to win. Town condition is that only town members are around

Oh, I thought if he found that dude he's looking for he became town and so that's his win condition. I must've misunderstood what I read!

Hmm. Wow.

I'm gonna have to Vote Furien now. Cause, if that's Jack being used (and it seems like it is!) then it's obviously not a one shot after all, and that plus his being loyal to Rapture and all unless he finds that dude he needs to find to become town makes him kinda dangerous, I think.

I'll change my vote if something better comes up, but for now, Jack seems like a liability to the Town.

Bah... bolding. Vote Furien

Definitely. Vote: Furien

Eek.

I'm alive, thankfully, although my abilities have been disabled. So I suspect that someone didn't want me to use my daykill.

Jack is definitely a threat to the town as Noola said, and since we have nothing else to go on I'm going to Vote: Furien.

It's Ryan. Let me pull my list out...

3) Shaddus Mes'ard- Unknown
5) Kiradawea- Corpse investigator, likely not Ryan.
6) Morhgor- Vanished, likely not Ryan.
7) Serella- Disabled against my own will, not Ryan.
9) Aerotan- Unknown
10) Casilu- Telekinetic, likely not Ryan.
11) Doman- Unknown
14) Diamondais- Unknown
15) Reiha- Unknown
16) Noola- Not Ryan (my own investigation)
17) Renthur- Not Ryan (investigator powers)
18) Furien- Not Ryan, obv.
20) Thiden- Unknown

Ryan is either:

Shaddus, Aerotan, Reiha, Doman, Dia or Thiden.

First unconfirmed person to jump on the bandwagon? Aerotan.

Vote: Aerotan

Not saying you're wrong about your list of suspects, Furien, cause, obviously it's one of those people.

But, say it's not Aerotan who's Ryan. That'll leave both you and Ryan around for another day... and, I'm sorry to say you're a hazard to the Town in a situation like that - who knows if you might be used again? In fact, I bet you would be cause whoever is Ryan (if it's not Aerotan) will want to get all the use he/she can from you before it's too late. Now, if someone can pinpoint Ryan absolutely, I'm all for lynching a Ryan suspect instead, but as it stands, with only a kinda flimsy voting suspicion... my vote is gonna have to stay where it is.

Two things.

First, if I were Andrew Ryan, a man whose response to people interrupting his utopia is to crucify them and leave them to rot in public view, why would I bother being secretive about how I kill?

Second, wasn't it Atlas who was controlling Jack? Ryan had all the splicers everywhere ever to do his dirty work, remember. The only command Ryan ever gave Jack was to kill him.

Sooo...grasping at straws much?

List 1- The first possible Ryan suspects I figured (from my previous list)

Shaddus, Aerotan, Reiha, Doman, Dia or Thiden
|
v

List 2- I did research, noticed that Thiden was Tenenbaum and Shaddus was completely clueless (may be a bluff). Both have offered little to the overall conversation.

Aerotan, Reiha, Doman, Dia

|
v

List 3- Did more research. Doman was the one roleblocking Morghor, which lead to him pulling a ninja vanish. Doman is town.

Aerotan, Reiha, Dia.

One of these three is Ryan.

Aerotan- Put up a good defense, I guess, but there's still no proving him. I couldn't find a roleclaim or any other form of confirmation.

Reiha- Has posted...almost nothing of substance in the entire game. Literally, several of her posts consist of 'Okay, someone start a bandwagon and I'll join'. If a Ryan, not a great one.

Diamondais- Has posted nothing of great substance as well. No roleclaims, just a few vague ponderings, has made no assertions or pressure for the entire game. Evasive, almost.


IMPORTANT: THIDEN

You're Tenenbaum. In the game, Tenenbaum was able to save Jack from the mind control trigger phrase (Would you kindly) and give him control of his body again. Can you do anything for me here, at all? At night?



Town: The manipulation seems to work just like my own power. 50% kill chance, 50% roleblock. There's also a chance that it's either a roleblock OR a kill, specifically, and the kill charge has been used up. But that's me being hopeful.

Going to wait on Thiden to post back.

I have no clue as to what Furien is talking about, as I've never played the game. I have a basic idea on what he means, and I think I'll go with him for now. Unless someone can explain why they are voting for Furien and give a good reason why I should, as well?

FOS:THIDEN

Somewhere way back near the beginning, you said 'So all our roles are basically people in the game?'. Struck me as essentially clueless. If you were scum you'd have researched your role to make sure you didn't accidentally reveal yourself.

Vote Count:



--

With 13 alive, it's 7 to lynch.