Those extra kills were mine, I had my tank and went after Shaddus, S.A. W. roleblocked me and got caught in the blast.

No, silly, they're the ones we could have recruited. R.O.B would have been able to recruit Pichu. I was the only one without any recruit ability.

I knew it! I did ask you about your final smash, just that the ensuing mess I made didn't let me proceed with that.

Also, Kira, I enjoyed it despite it being brain-numbingly hard for the mafia to win. I sort of enjoyed the adrenaline rush, and waiting for the night actions, and the dawn, and such.

If I remember right my kills were Shaddus, Shamarah, S.A.W., Solanis with the pokeball, Diamondais, and one other I forget.

Yeah, all things considered it wasn't a really boring game, it just wasn't particularly...balanced.

Oh, almost forgot. Nightactions.

Night 0:
Pikachu (Noola): Befriend Casilu
Link (Rika): Protect me
Mario (S.A.W.): Fludd Daganev
Fox (Dai): Watch Shiri
Wolf (Renthur): Track Arix
Sheik (Furien): Stalk Shiri
Ganondorf (Doman): Curse Casilu
Bowser (Casilu): Kidnap Doman
Snake (Shiri): Mafia kill Arix
R.O.B. (Harkux): Mafia kill Arix
Sonic (Diamondias): Mafia kill Arix
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Mafia kill Arix
Pit (Daganev): Do nothing
Peach (Esano): Do nothing
Midna (Kiriwe): Do nothing
Yoshi (Archer2): Swallow Daganev
Lucario (Fania): Aura Sense Doman

Night 1:
Pikachu (Noola): Befriend S.A.W
Link (Rika): Protect Daganev
Mario (S.A.W.): Fludd Diamondais
Fox (Dai): Watch Caerulo
Wolf (Renthur): Confront Dai
Sheik (Furien): Stalk Kiriwe
Ganondorf (Doman): Dead
Bowser (Casilu): Kidnap Tekora
Snake (Shiri): Call Colonel regarding Llandros
R.O.B. (Harkux): Dead
Sonic (Diamondias): Mafia kill S.A.W
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Taint Fania
Pit (Daganev): Shoot Sadhyra
Peach (Esano): Do nothing
Midna (Kiriwe): Hide in Twilight
Yoshi (Archer2): Swallow Narsrim
Lucario (Fania): Aura Sense Narsrim

Night 2:
Pikachu (Noola): Befriend Sadhyra
Link (Rika): Protect Me
Mario (S.A.W.): Fludd Archer2
Fox (Dai): Dead
Wolf (Renthur): Track Sadhyra
Sheik (Furien): Stalk Diamondais
Ganondorf (Doman): Dead
Bowser (Casilu): Kidnap Sadhyra
Snake (Shiri): Call Colonel regarding Llandros
R.O.B. (Harkux): Dead
Sonic (Diamondias): Do nothing
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Mafia kill Sadhyra
Pit (Daganev): Fly Caerulo
Peach (Esano): Dead
Midna (Kiriwe): Do nothing
Yoshi (Archer2): Swallow Solanis
Lucario (Fania): Aura Sense Archer2

Night 3
Pikachu (Noola): Befriend Fania
Link (Rika): Protect Me
Mario (S.A.W.): Fludd Renthur
Fox (Dai): Dead
Wolf (Renthur): Confront Shaddus
Sheik (Furien):
Ganondorf (Doman): Dead
Bowser (Casilu): Kidnap Fania
Snake (Shiri): Call Otacon regarding Renthur
R.O.B. (Harkux): Dead
Sonic (Diamondias): Mafia Kill Rika
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Taint Fania
Pit (Daganev): Mirror
Peach (Esano): Dead
Midna (Kiriwe): Hide in Twilight
Yoshi (Archer2): Swallow Caerulo
Lucario (Fania): Aura Sense Kiriwe

Night 4
Pikachu (Noola): Missing
Link (Rika): Dead
Mario (S.A.W.): Dead
Fox (Dai): Dead
Wolf (Renthur): Confront Shamarah
Sheik (Furien): Stalk Renthur
Ganondorf (Doman): Dead
Bowser (Casilu): Dead
Snake (Shiri): Mafia kill Shamarah
R.O.B. (Harkux): Dead
Sonic (Diamondias): Nothing
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Dead
Pit (Daganev): Nothing
Peach (Esano): Dead
Midna (Kiriwe): Nothing
Yoshi (Archer2): Swallow Shamarah
Lucario (Fania): Missing

Night 5
Pikachu (Noola): Hot spring.
Link (Rika): Dead
Mario (S.A.W.): Dead
Fox (Dai): Dead
Wolf (Renthur): Confront Diamondais
Sheik (Furien): Stalk Archer2
Ganondorf (Doman): Dead
Bowser (Casilu): Dead
Snake (Shiri): Dead
R.O.B. (Harkux: Dead
Sonic (Diamondais): Nothing
Mr Game&Watch (Caerulo): Dead
Pit (Daganev): Fly Noola
Peach (Esano): Dead
Midna (Kiriwe): Dead
Yoshi (Archer2): Hot spring
Lucario (Fania): Hot spring

I really hope the trend of giving everyone powers doesn't continue around here, because it really really makes the game totally unenjoyable. Mafia isn't about everyone having abilities and tons of chaos--it's about interaction and socialization. The games around here are something totally separate from mafia, and I think, if they are going to continue, they need to have their own separate category/games.

Like. run a Traditional Mafia and this Super Mafia separately, so people like me who want nothing to do with the circus-like games don't get sucked into one without knowing what it's going to be.

To be fair, some of the games with themes and stuff turn out really well (Shamarah's carebears one was excellent, as was Silferras' pokemon one - although the latter had like a million claim options.) Then again, I think there were a couple vanillas in the first one and nothing crazily complicated, despite Balizar's hilarious attempt to convince us that there was.

I think we could do with some variety though. It's a bit late for Daganev to do anything with his setup, but maybe Silferras' will be a simpler analytical one.
EDIT: Oh, Ryleth's army game was excellent too, and that had a theme. Shaddus almost wrecked us pretending to be an investigator that game, before owning himself with a fake mod quote...

Wait.. wtf..



How the hell did I die this night? Nobody targetted me.

You roleblocked Renthur and he ran you over with his tank.

I don't think it was particularily unbalanced in favour of Town. Scum had three potential suspects that they could've recruited (Pichu required Pika and Lucario to be dead, Lyn required Mario and Peach to be dead, Midna required Link and Zelda to be dead). There was a serial killer out there, though I didn't intend for him to know that so early. Mafia (and kids) would've never been killed in Daily Events, and their final smashes were designed to help them kill reliably. Ressurection would only be sure on Lyn, Pichu and Midna, which again would actually benefit scum. There were many factors involved to try and shift the direction in Scum's favour.

...that..is retarded.

The fact it took us until da 4 to even get the opportunity to recruit them, particularly since we had no idea what the reqs were and all the aforementioned roleblocking/doctoring/rezzing/invincibility would have gotten in the way, says a lot about the feasibility of that.

The daily event thing didn't work out so well because we only had 4 (well, 3 but that's our fault) chances out of the whole team at actually hitting it, and then we thought it might have been necessary to hit a day event for the recruitment opportunity since we were getting desperate by then.

You know, you could've just asked me "what does this mean?"

I did, if you remember. (or didn't delete your PMs.) You said "I'll tell you when it comes up."

EDIT: BTW, we did think Daganev was lying, we just didn't think we could take the risk with how much against us the odds already were. Plus, it accounted for the three deaths that one night if SAW tried to block Daganev's pit target and got owned.

Of course, some simple research would have forced us to conclude that "pit" has no such ability, so that one is really our own fault. But I don't think it would have mattered.

Yes, I did. But I'm pretty sure I mentioned that you could investigate them for more information. If I didn't, then I'm sorry.

You definitely didn't. I just wiped all the PMs but I remember this chain of events:

Someone reveals Sham:
I PM you, asking if I can do anything to Sham since you had the "look out for Lyn" in my roleclaim:
You said "I'll tell you if it comes up"
I concluded from your PM that I should just wait for the opportunity and kill someone else in the meantime (and save him with my pokeball)
You PMed me night 4 telling me I was able to recruit him if I attacked him
I attempted that
It failed

I was just pissed off that it seemed (to me) that everybody else got flavor confirmations except me, especially when I hid in twighlight during the day.

I really enjoyed this game, personally.

Though, the reaction here has me thinking that the game I'm planning will not be liked so now I'm thinking of bowing out of running it.