[Mafia]Angels and Demons: GAIA

by Daganev

Back to The Real World.

Unknown2009-03-11 03:47:45
Gahh.

We don't need to expose the role of another potential useful-town (diamondais). Odds are that she's the one telling the truth, since she gains nothing by coming out with that - it's something easily checked by investigation or death. If this were nearing the endgame, I can understand why scum would want to play it that way, but we're only on Day 2 and calling someone out like that is just drawing attention to yourself.

Vote: Rika
Unknown2009-03-11 03:49:39
QUOTE (Caerulo @ Mar 11 2009, 02:43 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So Diamondais, does that mean that you are Raphael? You could very easily be a scum who is trying to frame a townie with useful powers. Although, that would mean that you would be outed the moment Rika dies.

So, should we go for Rika, or get Diamondais to convince us that she is Raphael?


Should wait for Rika's reply, because if Diamondais is the real Raphael, then we'd just be offering the mafia more juicy targets. Raphael would definitely be a power role.
Diamondais2009-03-11 03:50:05
I am Raphael, yes. I wouldn't say it otherwise considering if Rika were Raphael and you did lynch her, I would be the next target. tongue.gif

You may be right about your minor claim Silf, seems it ended up causing a bit of stirr in the end.
Rika2009-03-11 03:51:04
Standing by what I have said about my power. If I survive today, I can bring Doman (or whoever) back tonight. Vote: Diamondais
Diamondais2009-03-11 03:54:46
We'll see what happens I suppose, I do believe Rika is lying as I am Raphael.
Unknown2009-03-11 04:00:00
Alright. Hrm, Rika, what is the name of your ability? At the moment, you look scummier than Diamondais.
Unknown2009-03-11 04:06:17
QUOTE (rika @ Mar 11 2009, 11:51 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Standing by what I have said about my power. If I survive today, I can bring Doman (or whoever) back tonight. Vote: Diamondais


You've gotten back confirmation that the attempt last night doesn't count as your first attempt?
Rika2009-03-11 04:10:36
@Caerulo: Err.. doesn't really have a name. It's just resurrection, I guess.

@Silferras: Oh, thought I had posted. Apparently the roleblocked one was counted as a use (albeit unsuccessful, so I can use another tonight).
Unknown2009-03-11 04:12:36
Silferras, does your ability have a name?
Unknown2009-03-11 04:16:34
It doesn't, but it's an extension of the introductory flavour text.
Diamondais2009-03-11 04:23:33
Mine is just a continuation of the flavour text as well, with brackets stating what it does.
Unknown2009-03-11 04:24:43
Both have been posting little. I'm going to go with my gut feeling, and vote for Rika.

Vote: Rika
Zynna2009-03-11 13:26:10
Wow, this is a lot to wake up to! Yesterday was super calm. and now things have exploded! To the task at hand, we can't afford to lose our rezzer.

Vote: Diamondais
Diamondais2009-03-11 14:46:07
It's still pretty quiet. laugh.gif
Unknown2009-03-11 16:12:47
QUOTE (Zynna)
Wow, this is a lot to wake up to! Yesterday was super calm. and now things have exploded! To the task at hand, we can't afford to lose our rezzer.

Vote: Diamondais


If our 'rezzer' is telling the truth. You have a bizarre way of selectively trusting roleclaims and jumping on people for the strangest things.

So, that said, what makes you think Rika's claim is any more valid than Diamondais's? I'm curious.
Zynna2009-03-11 16:29:56
Voting to not kill Doman was not based on trusting his role, as it was on logic. If he was human, killing him was not going to help us get closer to our goal because we have to kill demons, not humans. And, there was no reason for a demon to claim a human role (especially when we didn't know humans were among on); they would have claimed to be an angel. Here, it would be a mistake to lynch Rika. We would be down to ten people, with no demons down, and at a serious disadvantage.
Unknown2009-03-11 16:38:15
How is it logical unless you somehow knew that Doman was actually human as claimed and as he turned out? We didn't know that before we lynched him, obviously, so the 'killing him was not going to help us get closer to our goal because we have to kill demons' wouldn't apply at all.

Same as the current situation. How are you so sure that Rika is on the town's side now that Diamondais has claimed that her role name is the same as the one Rika claimed? Your obstinate refusal to see the logic here and your complete trust in Rika is looking more and more scummy to me, especially since you entirely sidestepped my question.
Zynna2009-03-11 16:49:41
I didn't know that he was human, and I never said that. What I said is that logically he probably was a human and thus not our target (demon). I'm not trying to sidestep your questions. I'm trying to do what is best for the town. And you're right we cannot afford to lose a useful townie with powers.
Unknown2009-03-11 16:53:15
Which we are not sure Rika has. My question is, what makes you think she has the powers she claims, and is the angel she claims she is? You still haven't answered my question.
Enero2009-03-11 19:28:14
Right... right, right, right.
So after reading the latest posts I have some thoughts spinning around my head. Given that most of the time it's hard even for me to understand my thoughts, I'll put down my deductions instead.

For some reason I too believe diamondais more that I trust Rika.
From what has been said, I'm starting to think that both Rika and Zynna are demons, which they both know, and what Zynna is doing is trying to cover up for her.

Since I believe I am right, I will go with the one who has votes already, which is Rika.

VOTE: RIKA