I think I've been fairly useful so far this game. What have you brought to the table?

Came home from a loooong night.

Anyway, just wanted to say that when people say they have a list and they don't post it, they do it for a reason. When two people do it, the fact there is a reason should be more obvious.

I agreed at first, but if it was easy enough to find (what exactly did you google, Myrkr? I tried things like "list of pokemon clones" and whatnot and checked bulbapedia, but found nothing useful) that even 1 of the scum could have found it without too much effort, which 3 of you finding it seems to indicate is true, there isn't much point keeping the townies who somehow can't find it in the dark.

Yes, that is mostly true. Two things however.

1. Town have no need for the list when roleclaiming. They have their true roles to use. It is not really that important for every member of the town to have the list.
2. Even if person number three thought it was better to share, don't you think it would be better to ask and let a few people answer before going "Ohai. I is smartz" and just doing it anyway? This is the style Shaddus has, and when it comes to daykilling, it can turn out very bad.

Both fair points, I guess. I don't think it's that big of a deal though, for the reason I mentioned, even if it was a net negative.

It was a joke. And you wanted to burn the Togepi....

Damn straight. I've got my serious face on this game, though.

@ Shiri: I went to Bulbapedia and typed in "Pokemon the First Movie", and then scrolled down to the list of Pokemon.

@ Rika: I thought it would be easier for us to figure out who is which clone, that way we can narrow down who the imposters are. Sure, it might have been a stupid move. But we've narrowed down a lot who can be who, and if we have a cop and someone who claims suspiciously, we're set, aren't we?

Erm, not really. Look at it this way: There is no comfirmation that the scum will be pokemon that are outside of the list. For all we know, they could be pokemon in the cloned list, but just not clones.

Secondly, not just us town have narrowed down the list. You have narrowed it down for the scum as well. Previously, there was the very slim chance that the scum might not be able to find the list and thus claim carelessly, condemning him. However, now the scum have no need to worry about that.

Reading over the new posts, and my mind hasn't changed. I think Bali has been trying overly hard to put Shiri in the scum category, and I don't see it.

It would be nice to hear Llandros' role too since it is odd to claim like that out of the blue (although I really thought Jack last game was lying since he did that too, but he wasn't).

Honestly, Jack doing that last game looked more like a noob move than a scum move too, I just calculated it as being in my interests to pretend otherwise (not banking on Silferras self-owning due to Casilu being awkward with explaining the rules.)

I didn't consider that.

No offense, but at least twice people said their reasons not to post the list... you either didn't care, or didn't read.

Or am in searing(sp?) pain thanks to a tooth growing into my jaw and didn't read correctly.

The second one then n_n

In my defense, I was scum at the time, and never actually thought you scum , I just needed someone to be lynched who wasn't part of our list of suspects

And you would have gotten away with it, too..if it weren't for us meddling kids!

Dugan typically works 10 hour shifts, which happened yesterday (noon to 10 pm for any that might care). After a bad night at work, I really didn't have any thinking capabilities left (and more honestly, didnt' feel like reading through eight pages of bs). Apologies to Shiri for jumping on his case like that, that guru (goru or whatever) was uncalled for.

At this point, I do not think Tekora is scum. He did this to me in the past, that is just what he does. This game, he chose Shiri.

Likewise, I do not think Shiri is scum. While I will admit I cannot follow his logic on a lot of his posts, for me, it looks like Shiri is just being Shiri and not Shiri is trying to pretend to be town.

I am confused by Llandros still for his vanilla claim and then his silence. Though if he is a vanilla townie, he might not care what happens in the game. But since he did throw that out there, I see no reason why not drop the name as well.

UNVOTE Casilu.
VOTE: Llandros

Actually, part of the reason Shiri is #1 on my suspects list is because he's NOT playing like he usually does. He's being very UN-Shiri-like. Which I interpret as a scum tell.