Mafia: Mirror Image

by Unknown

Back to The Real World.

Rika2009-04-14 01:45:27
SOMEONE FINISH MYRKR OFFFFFF
Unknown2009-04-14 02:52:28
Kiriwe or Tekora = the better lynch.

Two people died Night 2. Myrkr cannot be one of the people doing the killing, so you have to assume she either is A: just a goon, and not responsible for sending in a nightkill. B: Targetted me using some other skill, cannot be a roleblock (which is usually a scum role.) because my action was used. You have to ask yourself why exactly are you wagoning her? Just cause its easy?

Lets say for instance someone blocked Shiri night one. Arix, like the fool of a baggins he is, goes and gets himself killed by Shiri via his effect. That leaves one extra nightkill, most likely an SK. Night 2, that SK gets a kill, and the scum group gets a kill. So, on average, every night, there are 2 kills between an SK and scumgroup - thats about average for a game this size (no more, no less). Myrkr is not part of that because she was targetting me. If she was lying, why would she lie about targetting me? Its simply not a good fakeclaim because IT DOESNT ADD UP AND DOESNT MAKE SENSE.

All voters on Myrkr, please re-evaluate and consider what I have said. Tekora is a good lynch based on scum tells alone, and Kiriwe was defending Shiri hardcore Day 1.

Myrkr is a claimed bodyguard who has been confirmed by a tracker who was instrumental in lynching the scum godfather.

Listen to reason.

Please.
Diamondais2009-04-14 02:56:53
Unless there is more than one protector role, I don't believe it.
Unknown2009-04-14 02:58:38
What would she be doing targetting me?

Give me a feasable story.
kiriwe2009-04-14 02:59:12
My issue with Myrkr's claim is that her ability has the same name as Shiri's. I don't think she's an SK based on the fact that she targetted Bali and he didn't die, and she wasn't the Mafia that kills people, but I just don't trust that ability claim.

There are other things she could be doing with her night ability that isn't killing people.
Rika2009-04-14 02:59:22
Orrr you had a doctor protecting you and we have a third night killer (vigilante comes to mind). Seriously, her roleclaim was just bad.
Rika2009-04-14 03:02:32
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 14 2009, 02:58 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
What would she be doing targetting me?

Give me a feasable story.


Cult. More reason for us to kill Myrkr.
Dugan2009-04-14 03:03:30
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 13 2009, 09:52 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Kiriwe or Tekora = the better lynch.

Two people died Night 2. Myrkr cannot be one of the people doing the killing, so you have to assume she either is A: just a goon, and not responsible for sending in a nightkill. B: Targetted me using some other skill, cannot be a roleblock (which is usually a scum role.) because my action was used. You have to ask yourself why exactly are you wagoning her? Just cause its easy?

Lets say for instance someone blocked Shiri night one. Arix, like the fool of a baggins he is, goes and gets himself killed by Shiri via his effect. That leaves one extra nightkill, most likely an SK. Night 2, that SK gets a kill, and the scum group gets a kill. So, on average, every night, there are 2 kills between an SK and scumgroup - thats about average for a game this size (no more, no less). Myrkr is not part of that because she was targetting me. If she was lying, why would she lie about targetting me? Its simply not a good fakeclaim because IT DOESNT ADD UP AND DOESNT MAKE SENSE.

All voters on Myrkr, please re-evaluate and consider what I have said. Tekora is a good lynch based on scum tells alone, and Kiriwe was defending Shiri hardcore Day 1.

Myrkr is a claimed bodyguard who has been confirmed by a tracker who was instrumental in lynching the scum godfather.

Listen to reason.

Please.


The first bold. When Shiri got lynched, his TAG ability went to the next person in the scum list. It said so on his role reveal. Shiri was the godfather. She might be third on the list of scum.

yes, she is a claimed bodyguard. You can prove that she targetted you with an ability, but not what the ability is. She claimed ditto, the copy pokemon. She could be telling the truth, that her ability allows her to take place of the person being lynched, thereby saving them and dying herself. Or, as I really think, she is scum and she can mimic whatever alignment she copies. I have had that ability before when I was mafia in another game. I was not the godfather, but I could copy the alignment of anyone I chose.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:05:32
QUOTE
Unless there is more than one protector role, I don't believe it.


QUOTE
Orrr you had a doctor protecting you and we have a third night killer (vigilante comes to mind). Seriously, her roleclaim was just bad.


Unlikely. Since Dia has basically claimed doctor that leaves her and Myrkr - thats a doctor and a bodyguard. Thats not unlikely. 3 kills a night? I highly doubt that.

QUOTE
My issue with Myrkr's claim is that her ability has the same name as Shiri's. I don't think she's an SK based on the fact that she targetted Bali and he didn't die, and she wasn't the Mafia that kills people, but I just don't trust that ability claim.


Ditto has always had the transform ability. Shiri's ability was named transform, and it was a passive ability that kept him from being discovered by a cop. I think there is a difference.

The only avenue I think you can pursue with Myrkr targetting me is claiming that she might be a scum investigator. You know how overpowered a scum cop would be? Thats an entirely broken role for the most part, and is rarely, IF EVER played in games. You guys are forgetting that I am the one that wanted Myrkr to claim initially so I could see if she claimed BG or Doctor. Since she did, I am satisfied. All the arguements on her now are quite flimsy.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:07:01
NEVER ASSUME CULT.

Dugan2009-04-14 03:08:47
QUOTE (Myrkr @ Apr 11 2009, 07:13 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I expected this.

Go ahead, lynch me. If I end up town, you might kick yourself in the butt. However, I'm not going to fight it. There's no point in it.

I targetted Bali with my transform ability because I thought the scum would come to kill him last night since he's a very useful player. But if you really think I'm lying, go ahead and lynch me.


I also get stuck on this quote. Specifically, "If I end up town, you might kick ..." She put in if I end up town, not when I end up town. If you are town, why would it be if I end up town, you are or you aren't. Its not an if. Also, she cannot remember who she targetted on night one with this ability. I just find that a bit hard to believe.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:09:41
Oi!

I've said my peace, for the most part - concerning Myrkr. Dugan - Myrkr targetted me NIGHT 2. If the tag ability did pass on, it wasnt to her. The scum got their kill. That has to mean SOMETHING.
Rika2009-04-14 03:10:30
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 14 2009, 03:05 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Ditto has always had the transform ability. Shiri's ability was named transform, and it was a passive ability that kept him from being discovered by a cop. I think there is a difference.


What is your point? The fact is that Shiri had a ability called "Transform" and Myrkr has also claimed the same, but with another effect.
Dugan2009-04-14 03:10:59
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 13 2009, 10:09 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Oi!

I've said my peace, for the most part - concerning Myrkr. Dugan - Myrkr targetted me NIGHT 2. If the tag ability did pass on, it wasnt to her. The scum got their kill. That has to mean SOMETHING.


Yeah, it might mean she is scum #3 and currently, scum #2 has TAG.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:11:35
I really take her blaize "giving up" posting style sort of as a resignment to her fate, knowing that no matter what she posts, she cannot stop the lusternian bandwagon of fury.

I will totally eat crow though if she turns scum. I admit, I see how the wording there is cause for concern.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:12:46
QUOTE
Yeah, it might mean she is scum #3 and currently, scum #2 has TAG.


Exactly, that -COULD- be the case...but its just another thing in Myrkr's favor why it COULD NOT be the case.
Fania2009-04-14 03:12:50
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 13 2009, 07:52 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Myrkr is a claimed bodyguard who has been confirmed by a tracker who was instrumental in lynching the scum godfather.

Listen to reason.

Please.


Wait, who was she confirmed by again?
Rika2009-04-14 03:13:28
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Apr 14 2009, 03:11 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I really take her blaize "giving up" posting style sort of as a resignment to her fate, knowing that no matter what she posts, she cannot stop the lusternian bandwagon of fury.

I will totally eat crow though if she turns scum. I admit, I see how the wording there is cause for concern.


I think Estarra said the same thing when she disagreed that 12 strength was bugged. Turns out it was!

Now, let's kill Myrkr off.
Unknown2009-04-14 03:14:55
QUOTE
Wait, who was she confirmed by again?


ME.

I cannot confirm her alignment, but I can confirm that her story is indeed true - she did target me during the night.

Unknown2009-04-14 03:16:31
If you want to confirm ME, ask Furien.

Furien, were you "sleeping"/not doing anything Night 1?