Reiha2009-05-15 15:01:00
QUOTE (daganev @ May 15 2009, 07:55 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Firstly, Frodo's roll makes perfect sense to me. (the cult thing does not, turning invisible does)
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
Post?
Daganev2009-05-15 15:01:41
What does a beaver trapper do?
Reiha2009-05-15 15:02:00
Daganev2009-05-15 15:02:24
QUOTE (Fania @ May 14 2009, 11:27 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I gave it to Reiha cause I didn't think she was scum.
Reiha2009-05-15 15:02:48
That, and nothing else.
If I die, I'm taking someone with me.
If I die, I'm taking someone with me.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:03:46
Man, you arn't even close to a lynch, but too late now.
Shiri2009-05-15 15:06:12
QUOTE (daganev @ May 15 2009, 03:55 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Firstly, Frodo's roll makes perfect sense to me. (the cult thing does not, turning invisible does)
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
If Fania, is a cult leaer, we will know when we lynch reiha, because Fania said she gave the ring to Reiha.
While the electron is not a person, it is something that people out side of lusternia would know about. So far everything has been realworld oriented. I'm sorry, but IllusionSelf doesn't sound very PopCulture like to me. (electron may not either, but if thats the case it should be a choice between the electron and illusionarySelf, not Frodo and illusionary self.)
We didn't believe myrkr's claim as doctor, and I don't want to risk killing off another doctor. I mean really, whats the connection between "hope" and doctor? It's very flimsy. Plus, claiming to have nightkill defences is a clasic scum fake roleclaim. Doctor isn't.
That's not true at all. Why would you just randomly believe Fania calling out targetting Reiha, when the tracker is already dead so there's no risk of anyone disproving her?
And the reason there's less risk of killing off another doctor is because this would be the first game, ever, where we have two doctors. It's possible! But not unlikely. And all these little inconsistencies add up in Fania's role - cult makes more sense than raw doctor does with the ring. Having it was bad, not good! He had to ditch it, he certainly didn't give it away.
Shiri2009-05-15 15:08:54
Wtf. Well, if I'm dead, LYNCH FANIA TOMORROW GUYS
Daganev2009-05-15 15:13:21
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 08:06 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
That's not true at all. Why would you just randomly believe Fania calling out targetting Reiha, when the tracker is already dead so there's no risk of anyone disproving her?
And the reason there's less risk of killing off another doctor is because this would be the first game, ever, where we have two doctors. It's possible! But not unlikely. And all these little inconsistencies add up in Fania's role - cult makes more sense than raw doctor does with the ring. Having it was bad, not good! He had to ditch it, he certainly didn't give it away.
And the reason there's less risk of killing off another doctor is because this would be the first game, ever, where we have two doctors. It's possible! But not unlikely. And all these little inconsistencies add up in Fania's role - cult makes more sense than raw doctor does with the ring. Having it was bad, not good! He had to ditch it, he certainly didn't give it away.
Firstly, this is not true. In the super smash brothers game, we had multiple doctor like roles, each one slightly different.
Secondly, lieing about who someone targeted at night, is not very common. Normally you want to lie as little as possible, just incase there are ways for people to find out. If Fania thinks there could be two doctors, she could also think there could be two tracker types.
Frodo gave the ring to sam gamgee at one point. Frodo was not adverse to giving the ring away when it was important to do so.
My power has nothing to do with my charachter. What does "I have a bad feeling about this" have to do with "no night kills, no lynch"?
Daganev2009-05-15 15:15:01
Reiha, what does your skill do? Does it end the day?
Shiri2009-05-15 15:17:04
I have no idea because you never explained what your role actually IS and I never pressed you on it.
Fania2009-05-15 15:19:35
Well if there is another tracker they are welcome to track my actions tonight. Do you want me to give you a heads up about who I'm going to have my ring protect? I have someone in mind already, but I'm open for suggestions.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:22:06
QUOTE (Fania @ May 15 2009, 08:19 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Well if there is another tracker they are welcome to track my actions tonight. Do you want me to give you a heads up about who I'm going to have my ring protect? I have someone in mind already, but I'm open for suggestions.
Give it to whomever you think the scum might target tonight.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:25:33
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 08:17 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I have no idea because you never explained what your role actually IS and I never pressed you on it.
Forget my role.
You saw me post "I have a bad feeling about this" (a quote from starwars)
When I posted that, there was a "no lynch, no nightkills" affect. What is the connection between those two things?
Shiri2009-05-15 15:33:44
...I have no idea, because I don't know what your role is. I can't just forget your role and then understand the ability. The connection is critical! Obviously. Going aggro on someone for tracker powers makes no sense without the context of Rasputin.
Ring protection is highly dubious with access to Fania's roleclaim.
Ring protection is highly dubious with access to Fania's roleclaim.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:36:22
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 08:33 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
...I have no idea, because I don't know what your role is. I can't just forget your role and then understand the ability. The connection is critical! Obviously. Going aggro on someone for tracker powers makes no sense without the context of Rasputin.
Ring protection is highly dubious with access to Fania's roleclaim.
Ring protection is highly dubious with access to Fania's roleclaim.
Ok, whats the connection between Raskilokov? (sp?) and "tracking"?
Or between Obama and being a doctor?
Or the Pope and being a Vigilante?
Shiri2009-05-15 15:42:14
Hrm. Ok, I guess when you put it that way only half of each ability makes sense.
But you're still counting on "two straight up doctors, one of them randomly weaker than the other in that they have to keep posting about it." Ugly.
But you're still counting on "two straight up doctors, one of them randomly weaker than the other in that they have to keep posting about it." Ugly.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:46:35
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 08:42 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Hrm. Ok, I guess when you put it that way only half of each ability makes sense.
But you're still counting on "two straight up doctors, one of them randomly weaker than the other in that they have to keep posting about it." Ugly.
But you're still counting on "two straight up doctors, one of them randomly weaker than the other in that they have to keep posting about it." Ugly.
Actually, I'm relying on the fact that if Fania is infact town, she will be dead soon anyways. (and we will know if she was lying or not) And if she isn't then we can look into her again if we don't find somebody soon.
Shiri2009-05-15 15:49:37
She won't be dead as long as you play with that thought in mind though! Because then the scum know perfectly well that they can just get her lynched, and the chance of her interfering is low anyway, especially since the cop (if we have one) isn't out.
Daganev2009-05-15 15:55:17
QUOTE (Shiri @ May 15 2009, 08:49 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
She won't be dead as long as you play with that thought in mind though! Because then the scum know perfectly well that they can just get her lynched, and the chance of her interfering is low anyway, especially since the cop (if we have one) isn't out.
If you say so. Whatever keeps the doctor alive and people not dieing works for me.
You assume that we won't find other scum in the next day or so. Which is highly unlikely at this point. If fania is scum, then we will find one of her partners. If fania is not scum then we will find one of the 5 or so other scum folk.
