Noola2009-06-27 08:40:11
Isn't anime and manga the same thing, only one's a movie and the other's a comic book?
And, I'm not sure I buy Solanis' claim. Anyone can say, "I'm the doctor." Doesn't make it true. The defense was kinda halfheartedly done. That said, it would suck if he's telling the truth and is the doctor and gets lynched.
And, I'm not sure I buy Solanis' claim. Anyone can say, "I'm the doctor." Doesn't make it true. The defense was kinda halfheartedly done. That said, it would suck if he's telling the truth and is the doctor and gets lynched.
Kiradawea2009-06-27 08:53:01
Hum... I feel it best to believe Solanis, for now.
Shiri2009-06-27 08:57:27
QUOTE (Noola @ Jun 27 2009, 09:40 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Isn't anime and manga the same thing, only one's a movie and the other's a comic book?
And, I'm not sure I buy Solanis' claim. Anyone can say, "I'm the doctor." Doesn't make it true. The defense was kinda halfheartedly done. That said, it would suck if he's telling the truth and is the doctor and gets lynched.
And, I'm not sure I buy Solanis' claim. Anyone can say, "I'm the doctor." Doesn't make it true. The defense was kinda halfheartedly done. That said, it would suck if he's telling the truth and is the doctor and gets lynched.
Yes, to the same way that movies and comic books are the same thing.
Since this is going to become obvious if we lynch him, I'm going to go ahead and say that I'm a ninja and that's why I believe Solanis' claim. I don't understand why it's Kakashi in particular that has healing powers and that could be him completely whiffing on his claim as a scum ninja and forgetting Tsunade or whatever her name was exists (actual healing ninja.)
Or, it could be Casilu screwing with us and or not having actually watched the show herself, either of which are believable.
At any rate, at least some aspect of Solanis' claim seems true.
Unknown2009-06-27 09:02:48
Since you guys think I didn't defend myself with emotion, here I go!!!11
I am your doctor. I save lives. You lynch me, you're lynching this awesome person who can save lives. SO YOU'RE GOING TO REGRET IT YOU LYNCH ME!!!
@Shiri: Casilu misspelt Kakashi, saying Kakashi Hitake rather than Hatake. There are more results for Hatake than Hitake, although Casilu maintains she got it from Naruto fan Wiki.
And, in all honesty, don't lynch me.
I am your doctor. I save lives. You lynch me, you're lynching this awesome person who can save lives. SO YOU'RE GOING TO REGRET IT YOU LYNCH ME!!!
@Shiri: Casilu misspelt Kakashi, saying Kakashi Hitake rather than Hatake. There are more results for Hatake than Hitake, although Casilu maintains she got it from Naruto fan Wiki.
And, in all honesty, don't lynch me.
Noola2009-06-27 09:07:10
Well, since Shiri's kinda corroborated Solanis' story a bit, I'm gonna go ahead and Unvote. I don't wanna risk lynching the doctor.
Dugan2009-06-27 10:20:52
I have to agree with Shiri on this one and I do believe Solanis's claim. Though I don't really see Kakashi as the doctor type. I am a bit troubled by Xikue and his quick vote on Solanis after his doctor claim. That does kind of bother me. I also am a bit troubled by Aetolian. With this many people starting and how often doctors are in a game, in all probability there is at least one, regardless of a 25% avoidance.
Furien2009-06-27 10:22:51
I really am skeptical still as to why he isn't Sakura or the chick with gambling problems. Does the Naruto Wiki say anything about healing on Kakashi's page?
Unknown2009-06-27 10:33:17
It doesnt. I checked narutofanwiki.com AND they also spell it Hatake not Hitake, I'm not sure what site Casilu used.
If this was a fake claim, I wouldn't have put Kakashi and doctor together. I would have claimed -an actual medical ninja- like Tsunade or Sakura.
If this was a fake claim, I wouldn't have put Kakashi and doctor together. I would have claimed -an actual medical ninja- like Tsunade or Sakura.
Siam2009-06-27 10:34:47
Chick with Gambling problems - Tsunade - the fifth hokage is a healer
Kakashi has not shown any capability in performing a healing jutsu over the past 4++ issues of Naruto(manga and anime)
Kakashi has not shown any capability in performing a healing jutsu over the past 4++ issues of Naruto(manga and anime)
Siam2009-06-27 10:35:59
Oh, and why are focusing on konoha ninjas now?
Shiri2009-06-27 11:48:59
Does it really matter? The point is there's a claim that doesn't make sense given the manga and two (or more!) that do, and despite knowing the difference from looking it up on the wiki he chose the one that didn't, which tells me that Casilu might be playing silly buggers. Given that and his claim about boosting other ninjas, which would be kind of awkward if Casilu didn't select Naruto for some reason, the role seems believable.
I did just realise it's possible he was stretching in case there were any non-Naruto ninjas out there, which makes this evidence weaker, but I still think it's plausible. So IMO all we need to do is bitchslap him for starting a trainwreck and gank someone else.
I recommend Llandros but a lurker would also be an acceptable target (Konton?)
I did just realise it's possible he was stretching in case there were any non-Naruto ninjas out there, which makes this evidence weaker, but I still think it's plausible. So IMO all we need to do is bitchslap him for starting a trainwreck and gank someone else.
I recommend Llandros but a lurker would also be an acceptable target (Konton?)
Unknown2009-06-27 11:53:42
I guess this wouldn't be a good time to say that we should lynch Siam Just kidding.
Shiri, why Llandros?
And my role used the word Shinobis, not ninja, not Konoha-ians.
Shiri, why Llandros?
And my role used the word Shinobis, not ninja, not Konoha-ians.
Siam2009-06-27 11:57:32
I personally don't think all of this is about Naruto and/or ninjas.
Unknown2009-06-27 11:58:42
I don't think so either. But from my role, there's bound to be a few. It's a big game.
Shiri2009-06-27 12:03:59
QUOTE (thisismydisplayname @ Jun 27 2009, 12:57 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I personally don't think all of this is about Naruto and/or ninjas.
Huh? Obviously. We already have Dr. Weird from some american cartoon I never watched. But I can tell you that there is certainly 1+ ninja in the game, extremely likely 2+ ninja in the game, and pretty likely 3+ ninja in the game.
I don't like Llandros because of his rather dodgy attempt to criminalise whoever it was (Xiran?) for putting Solanis near lynch range. That paranoia is either the same kind of behaviour that slows the game down to a crawl because people don't want to commit to him, or an attempt to cast some random suspicion on a target for later town distraction while scum get on with their antics. Something has to give.
Someone also said something about rolefishing wrt him but check back on that before you vote him for it if the first thing doesn't hold up in your opinion (but if it doesn't, vote someone else. I recommend not Solanis) because I don't remember it clearly and don't have time to check back on it myself!
Siam2009-06-27 12:27:29
Can we have a vote count, please? I have a 7-10 second latency in the game currently and this means I can't scroll several pages back to tally them. Please, kind soul! Thank you.
Aerotan2009-06-27 13:14:42
No one gets my name right...
In light of new evidence, mostly Shiri's, I'm going to believe Solanis for now. I think doctor/boost is a rather odd combination to have, but I suppose there have been odder.
so Unvote:Solanis, and Vote: Konton because I forgot he was playing. Again.
In light of new evidence, mostly Shiri's, I'm going to believe Solanis for now. I think doctor/boost is a rather odd combination to have, but I suppose there have been odder.
so Unvote:Solanis, and Vote: Konton because I forgot he was playing. Again.
Unknown2009-06-27 14:18:39
Claimed doctor d1 is useless anyway lynch him
Furien2009-06-27 14:24:36
Bali has a point. Maybe. Scum might hesitate and think it's a trap? I'm not sure how the psychology behind this part works, it's a bit loopish for me.
Shiri2009-06-27 14:34:47
QUOTE (B_a_L_i @ Jun 27 2009, 03:18 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Claimed doctor d1 is useless anyway lynch him
Not with a 25% chance to live through any night attempts he's not.