Unknown2009-10-14 03:43:53
She wasn't confirmed town.
(Plus you said killing off the leader was really silly, not killing Celina with no prior warning was silly)
(Plus you said killing off the leader was really silly, not killing Celina with no prior warning was silly)
Unknown2009-10-14 03:51:09
Ok now you are just being picky on how I worded it. I was obviously talking about him killing Celina. Secondly I believe 99% of us thought she was town. You are just arguing for the sake of arguing. It was silly to use the daykill on Celina no matter how you look at it.
Unknown2009-10-14 04:06:51
Really? I thought she was town, but I wasn't -sure- that she was town.
I don't think it was silly to use the daykill on Celina, because, who knows if we have another kill ability at the town's disposal? Vig's dead.
I don't think it was silly to use the daykill on Celina, because, who knows if we have another kill ability at the town's disposal? Vig's dead.
Unknown2009-10-14 04:08:06
So instead of taking the time to try to daykill and lynch a scum. We just go ahead and use it on someone that everyone thinks is town? I guess if you were that scared of her being scum that would make sense but I didn't get that impression from the rest of the group.
Daganev2009-10-14 04:27:14
The odds of a daykill resist scum are low. The odds of a daykill resist scum acting the way Celina acted was 0.
Anyone who thought she was scum is/was an idiot.
Anyone who thought she was scum is/was an idiot.
Rika2009-10-14 06:49:36
Well, it shouldn't even really matter. I don't believe Lorick is scum, given the powers he has used.
Lorick2009-10-14 17:26:34
I had no information if she was scum or if she wasn't. I wasn't sure I would live through the night. I waited until Day 3 hoping someone could turn something up on her, but no one came forward after I made multiple calls for infomration. Her claim also fit the role I had for Fenix, and the only kill resistance we knew for sure was that she was kill resistance. No one here knew for certain if it was daykill immunity, flat resistance, or even her claim. I acted because I was worried that I wouldn't be able to tomorrow, and it was between Dag to allow for another lynch or Celina. I had reasons to not suspect Dag, I had none for Celina.
Lorick2009-10-14 17:29:00
Also Zetsu, you voted to kill Othero and place Celina in office, I'm hardly surprised by your vote but I'm confused by your arguement. How is my actions any different than you murdering Othero?
Unknown2009-10-14 18:42:21
I went ahead and voted since Othero even voted for himself. If you want to go back and look at when I placed my vote, it was after he voted. Now I am saying your actions are different because I don't think that the leader of the mafia would come forward and be willing to basically screw themselves on day one on a coin flip. She wasn't even acting remotely scummy. And like Daganev said, you basically went along with Requiems plan that you argued against so much by putting someone in as leader then killing them so we have no unlynchable people.
Lorick2009-10-15 00:43:45
Hardly, I was against his plan from the start. Trying the marry the two is just bad logic. My actions against Celina were based on what I knew about the mafia and her, the urgency in which I had to act was because you elected her leader with no information as to her alignment, but not simply because of it. I like you jumped down my throat the moment you had the chance though for killing one townie when you've been part of two, and even then you didn't do so for your own reasons but someone else's.
Arix2009-10-15 00:59:27
Did anyone understand that?
Casilu2009-10-15 04:20:40
QUOTE (Arix @ Oct 14 2009, 05:59 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Did anyone understand that?
Does nobody listen to my suggestion to ignore Lorick and continue with the game?
Daganev2009-10-15 04:26:07
Where is Shiri btw?
Lorick2009-10-15 04:58:40
Zetsu voted for both Jack and Othero, but made the arguemeent I had to die because of Celina.
Shiri2009-10-15 05:08:57
They claim my internet will be fixed in 18 hours (this time) but if I'm not back and posting after that feel free to replace me.
Lorick2009-10-15 05:32:50
Look, I still have one power. Around half the town isn't behind this line of thought. Why not hold off the lynch and judge me after, otherwise you are wasting a resource. Dag's vote I understand, he is twitching and quick to judge, Arix's is for personal reasons he just doesn't like me in a game, Zetsu's surprised me though since he normally stays along the sidelines in an arguement.
Unknown2009-10-15 06:04:19
Generally I do, I am just lazy when it comes to typing. I just think that it was a waste of a daykill. Would've been better off just saving it but whatever. What's done is done and now we have a another dead townie. Like I said before which I suppose you just chose to ignore, I didn't vote for Othero until he voted for himself. If someone votes to kill themselves to move us along why would I not vote with it. Also I held my vote off for a long time before voting for Jack. Also for the third time Celina claimed a one :censor: kill resistance, not a 50/50 dodge. As i have been saying I don't think that the scum leader would've put themselves out there to be killed on a coin flips chance on day one.
Lorick2009-10-15 06:32:28
So do you believe I'm scum or are you just going after me because of Celina? Yea or Nay please.
Arix2009-10-15 08:05:03
My vote is not because I don't like you, but comments like that are a major contribution to my not liking you in any case
Arix2009-10-15 08:10:34
Although I'm sure lynching you to shut you up is NOWHERE near anyone's mind...