Mortal Design Review

by Estarra

Back to Common Grounds.

Everiine2010-03-15 10:37:27
QUOTE (Doman @ Mar 15 2010, 05:50 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
It's not much different than putting up creds...

Except that credits are an actual transaction, while designs are not.
Eventru2010-03-15 18:13:36
You're likely to be stomped on for using market like that, so let's not.
Shaddus2010-03-16 01:17:43
QUOTE (Fain @ Mar 15 2010, 04:38 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
You don't think that might be a little OOC?

Not sure why it would be. Designs are IC. Not that it matters, but Aetolia lets their designers do the same thing over the market. Just saying.
Everiine2010-03-16 01:25:34
I think the point remains though that if mortal reviewers aren't supposed to know who made the designs, having someone announce that their new designs are up kinda defeats that idea.
Esano2010-03-16 01:46:09
If it's that big an issue (reviewers not knowing to check your design the instant it goes up) then a message to logged-in reviewers when a design opens would be best, I think. Just a line - "Design # has been submitted and is awaiting review" or some such.
Gleip2010-03-16 02:22:23
Learn some patience. Reviewers will review when they have the time and energy to review. They shouldn't be constantly harrassed to check reviews, when all they really want is to read up on newsposts and chat with some friends.
Xenthos2010-03-16 02:27:23
QUOTE (Gleip @ Mar 15 2010, 10:22 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Learn some patience. Reviewers will review when they have the time and energy to review. They shouldn't be constantly harrassed to check reviews, when all they really want is to read up on newsposts and chat with some friends.

Note to self: Next time I submit something, send Gleip a few messages.









Disclaimer: I do not actually own or run a cartel.
Shaddus2010-03-16 02:35:18
QUOTE (Esano @ Mar 15 2010, 08:46 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
If it's that big an issue (reviewers not knowing to check your design the instant it goes up) then a message to logged-in reviewers when a design opens would be best, I think. Just a line - "Design # has been submitted and is awaiting review" or some such.

This.
Maylea2010-03-16 03:12:39
QUOTE (Esano @ Mar 15 2010, 08:46 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
If it's that big an issue (reviewers not knowing to check your design the instant it goes up) then a message to logged-in reviewers when a design opens would be best, I think. Just a line - "Design # has been submitted and is awaiting review" or some such.


I've been keeping half an eye on the process, at least, and it seems to me that designs are going through much, much faster anyway! I don't see any reason to spam the reviewers with a line every time a design is submitted. They go through things when they decide they want to, and it's working. The fact that in two months, the Charites have raised the available design slots from 1 public and 1 private per year to 3 each is evidence enough that the queue is running smoothly!

Eventru2010-03-16 03:19:05
QUOTE (Shaddus Mes'ard @ Mar 15 2010, 09:17 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Not sure why it would be. Designs are IC. Not that it matters, but Aetolia lets their designers do the same thing over the market. Just saying.


Then go to Aetolia and let them know your designs are up. cool.gif

I do not, however, really see a problem with a message to the reviewers about new designs being submitted. Though at the same time, I've seen days where 30+ designs can be submitted in a few hours and... That's probably terrifying for them.
Diamondais2010-03-16 03:26:54
QUOTE (Eventru @ Mar 15 2010, 11:19 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Then go to Aetolia and let them know your designs are up. cool.gif

I do not, however, really see a problem with a message to the reviewers about new designs being submitted. Though at the same time, I've seen days where 30+ designs can be submitted in a few hours and... That's probably terrifying for them.

It's like those days during advertising schemes and you see newbie, after newbie, after newbie come through and you know there's only one guide available. Scaaaaary!
Shaddus2010-03-16 03:32:47
QUOTE (Eventru @ Mar 15 2010, 10:19 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Then go to Aetolia and let them know your designs are up. cool.gif

Only if you come with me so I can pick on you.
Aoife2010-03-16 11:42:57
QUOTE (Eventru @ Mar 15 2010, 11:19 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Then go to Aetolia and let them know your designs are up. cool.gif

I do not, however, really see a problem with a message to the reviewers about new designs being submitted. Though at the same time, I've seen days where 30+ designs can be submitted in a few hours and... That's probably terrifying for them.


Any day when it's Shanthin or Roarkian in-game is probably a bad one for reviewers.
Eventru2010-03-16 13:20:09
QUOTE (Aoife @ Mar 16 2010, 07:42 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Any day when it's Shanthin or Roarkian in-game is probably a bad one for reviewers.


Estar is actually the worst!
Gleip2010-03-16 14:48:15
QUOTE (Xenthos @ Mar 16 2010, 03:27 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Note to self: Next time I submit something, send Gleip a few messages.









Disclaimer: I do not actually own or run a cartel.

I'm not a mortal design reviewer. I just got something called empathy.



A pity ain't it? sad.gif
Xenthos2010-03-16 15:13:52
QUOTE (Gleip @ Mar 16 2010, 10:48 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I'm not a mortal design reviewer. I just got something called empathy.



A pity ain't it? sad.gif

I just want you to feel the pain. comfort.gif
Zalandrus2010-03-16 15:38:17
New game: whenever a trademaster submits a design, he/she must randomly message 10 people saying they have done thus. First to provoke a rage wins!
Kharaen2010-03-16 15:47:34
QUOTE (Maylea @ Mar 15 2010, 11:12 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
I've been keeping half an eye on the process, at least, and it seems to me that designs are going through much, much faster anyway! I don't see any reason to spam the reviewers with a line every time a design is submitted. They go through things when they decide they want to, and it's working. The fact that in two months, the Charites have raised the available design slots from 1 public and 1 private per year to 3 each is evidence enough that the queue is running smoothly!


Maybe this could be toggle-able in config settings?