Don't worry. I'm playing a Harry Potter themed Mafia game on the forums for a MUD too. We're all one big happy nerd family.

So... Could we get a bit more activity here? What do the rest of you think about Peeves? About my (currently rather loose) theory that the DE and Mystery Organisation can nightkill on alternating nights? What makes you believe what you believe? Any other comments?

As far as I can tell, the alternating-nights theory seems sound. Which complicates things, but that is the blessing/curse of a good Mafia setup.

Hi there Yeah, people should start talking! And this thingy called a 'deadline' seems to have worked pretty well to get folks talking, so...

DEADLINE: 24 hours from the time of this post.

'bout time!

Oh, great. Well, time for me to point a serious finger then.

Since I'm not the only one who sees the possibilities for an alternate-night NK between the DE and the unknown group, I'm extremely suspicious of Lilia. She is the only one who mentioned a similar thing (she said she asked someone, although who is unclear, about whether day 0 was odd or even). She then said she had no power that worked on alternating nights. In that case, why would she even ask? To me, the more I think about it, the more suspicious of her I become.

As such,
Unvote
Vote: Lilia

And as a pre-emptive strike, since people are likely to ask me to roleclaim anyway:

I'm Dobby. I can't do anything... yet. As for that "yet", that's as much as I know, really. It's starting to look like "never", as far as I'm concerned.

We do know those exist, so it's an easy claim I guess.

Okay... 12 more hours until the deadline, and so far three out of nine have voted. Any reasons why the rest of you haven't voted?

Sorry, I'm being pretty lurky this day. I'm still trying to make my decision, and should have something in a few hours based on the things that have been discussed up to this point.

I'm feeling at a loss really, Feyrll seems the iffiest to me but I can't exactly pin down why and voting without a reason is not very good.

Question for someone who has time since I'm too busy to do much but skim through things myself right now: is there anyone still alive who hasn't been posting at all since we came back from our little break? And diamondias, I'm pretty much in the same boat as you. :/

diamondais*

I noticed my typo after I already clicked add reply.

The only one who hasn't posted at all after the break is Casilu. And I don't think we should be trying to vote for her.

Well, so much for that helping my decision in any way, I guess. Back to the drawing board!

I am in something of a conundrum. Nobody seems suspicious enough to be worthy of a vote (duh, anyone suspicious enough to be worthy of a vote is gone by now), but it's almost always more advantageous to vote than not to vote. The every-other-night theory is odd, but isn't enough to change that general rule. Unless I'm wrong here?

Well, it's not like there aren't people to vote for already... If you believe Feyrll's claims, vote for me. If you found her posts and responses fishy, vote for her. If you feel Lilias responses some days ago was strange (for the reasons I outlined), then vote for her.

If you want to vote for someone who hasn't done much... I dunno. Gleip hasn't done much this day (other than voting for me), nor has Dynami, as far as I can remember. There should be plenty of suspects without having to vote for lurkers though.

Roughly 6 hours to go...