Gleip2010-11-18 12:00:12
Okay.
Unvote
Unvote
Ssaliss2010-11-18 12:00:45
QUOTE (diamondais @ Nov 18 2010, 12:48 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Othero isn't scum, nor is Vendetta.
How do you know?
Diamondais2010-11-18 12:01:55
QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Nov 18 2010, 12:00 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How do you know?
Because on the first night I played with their hats, and both of them were town.
Ssaliss2010-11-18 12:22:58
Ah. Fair enough.
Personally I can't shake the feeling about Arix. He never posts anything of value, nor does he ever vote...
Personally I can't shake the feeling about Arix. He never posts anything of value, nor does he ever vote...
Diamondais2010-11-18 12:28:26
Arix is town as well, considering the hats I played with last night were his and Rika's.
Gleip2010-11-18 12:29:28
Let's just spell it right out then shall we not?
Okay, so Othero and Vendetta are not scum.
Arath, Kiradawea and me are likely not scum (we've been the most vocal against scum in general).
Dia claims cop. A gutsy claim so I'm going to believe her.
So those to focus on would be
Caerulo
Arix
Ssaliss
Aysidra
If I should go with one of those, it would have to be Arix. Caerulo helped point out some connections between scum that we have already killed. Ssaliss did vote for Rika... but Rika was the more obvious scum so it could be an attempt at protecting scum, since Ileein is immune to Die's power, meaning that Ileein would have survived a nightkill attempt by Die. Aysidra... doesn't do much. He's as useful as my Swedish fish. And doesn't taste good either.
So I'll go for
Vote: Arix
since Rika's attempt at getting us to lynch him was so poor, it seems more likely a plan to give him plausible protection for when Rika dies.
Okay, so Othero and Vendetta are not scum.
Arath, Kiradawea and me are likely not scum (we've been the most vocal against scum in general).
Dia claims cop. A gutsy claim so I'm going to believe her.
So those to focus on would be
Caerulo
Arix
Ssaliss
Aysidra
If I should go with one of those, it would have to be Arix. Caerulo helped point out some connections between scum that we have already killed. Ssaliss did vote for Rika... but Rika was the more obvious scum so it could be an attempt at protecting scum, since Ileein is immune to Die's power, meaning that Ileein would have survived a nightkill attempt by Die. Aysidra... doesn't do much. He's as useful as my Swedish fish. And doesn't taste good either.
So I'll go for
Vote: Arix
since Rika's attempt at getting us to lynch him was so poor, it seems more likely a plan to give him plausible protection for when Rika dies.
Gleip2010-11-18 12:30:39
Fine then!!
Unvote
Vote: Ayisdra
Any other investigations you did that you want to share?
Unvote
Vote: Ayisdra
Any other investigations you did that you want to share?
Diamondais2010-11-18 12:35:35
I'm not claiming cop at all. I have no idea what this role is, it doesn't seem cop like to me.
Those are the only three I know, aside from Rika, who died before day start.
Those are the only three I know, aside from Rika, who died before day start.
Gleip2010-11-18 12:39:14
But you say that you identified three guys as town. So how can you not be cop?
Diamondais2010-11-18 12:43:25
QUOTE (Gleip @ Nov 18 2010, 12:39 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
But you say that you identified three guys as town. So how can you not be cop?
Switching hats around just doesn't seem that investigative to me, but I guess considering it's Casilu the possibility is there.
Ssaliss2010-11-18 12:48:57
QUOTE (diamondais @ Nov 18 2010, 01:43 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Switching hats around just doesn't seem that investigative to me, but I guess considering it's Casilu the possibility is there.
What does that hat-switching do, precisely?
Gleip2010-11-18 12:50:04
*sigh* Nevermind. More details won't help now. We need to focus on potential scum.
Diamondais2010-11-18 12:51:54
QUOTE (Ssaliss @ Nov 18 2010, 12:48 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
What does that hat-switching do, precisely?
As far as I can tell, I send Casilu two names. When Casilu PMsme back, I see what two names there were. Not who had which name.
Othero and Vendetta both came back as town members. <- first night
Rika and Arix came back as one scum, one town. Rika ended up being scum, which leaves Arix as the town member.
Gleip2010-11-18 13:10:42
Well, either way we need to work on the assumption that Dia's investigation is honest. At least for now. Which means that Ayisdra is the one I want to focus on.
Ayisdra2010-11-18 13:18:49
I'm going to Vote: Gleip....even though we have (or maybe we haven't). Each member of the mafia so far as been one of each suit. (pheobus was spades, ileein was diamonds, rika hearts) which would leave clubs and seeing as Lorick is dead (and was town....)...
(I suppose in a way this is a OMGUS vote but not really directly made that way.)
(I suppose in a way this is a OMGUS vote but not really directly made that way.)
Gleip2010-11-18 13:30:41
An OMGUS vote is a vote made against someone because they voted for you. So yes, that's an OMGUS, an OMGUS with perhaps the worst attempt at making it reasonable I have seen. Rika picked the Queen of Hearts as her card. She ended up Clubs Deuce. Hearts, clubs... I don't see the connection. Of course there's a pretty clear connection between my card and Clubs Deuce. In the name, you could almost say. Just too bad I can't be Clubs Deuce huh?
Vote stays. I think we've found our fourth scum.
Vote stays. I think we've found our fourth scum.
Ayisdra2010-11-18 13:33:16
I was saying so far the mafia had a suit each (wither or not it directly goes with their role I didn't say) I was just saying there has only left clubs suit as I have said.
And you haven't found your fourth scum in me.
And you haven't found your fourth scum in me.
Gleip2010-11-18 13:35:52
Ileein was spades. Rika was Clubs. Phoebus was Hearts. Bad OMGUS is good scum sign.
Unknown2010-11-18 13:40:14
Alright, that last post convinced me. It is a thinly disguised OMGUS vote. We've way past the stage of discussing about whether the cards may or may not mean anything, and basing your vote on card selection at this point of the game is just grasping at straws.
Vote: Ayisdra
Vote: Ayisdra
Unknown2010-11-18 13:41:56
Erm, due to ninja, my 'last post' referred to Ayisdra's post where he voted for Gleip.