I don't remember Othero saying all that. Where was it?

Hmm, okay. And Phoebus' power is supposed to be only used during the daytime? I thought that's how it functioned.

You know, to be perfectly honest, I'm not sure why we're assuming that someone going to the store automatically means they couldn't possibly have killed someone else that night.

I guess it's the mindset of "one action per Night"? But clearly a person can be doing more than one thing. For instance, I both went out to get my hair cut (I think that's your power? Giving haircuts?) and was home to answer the phone when Othero called. Unless I'm misinterpreting those results? That means someone can be caught at home or out on the same night. So couldn't one then assume that someone who went out at night could have stopped by the store and gone a-murdering?

Possibly, though that then throws my power out the window as any sort of check on who we want to lynch.

I think it throws everyone's power out the window. Except for mine, which has been sitting uselessly on the grass beneath the windowsill the whole time anyway. I began to slowly suspect over the course of the game that the sole purpose of our powers is to make us suspicious of one another.

If that's so, and would kind of suck as a set-up for a game, can we sort of end it? If you're going to run on that theory, that powers are all useless, then what info at all do you have to go on?

Then you end up, more or less, in the same position as me and my examination of Romertien.

I don't really have anything else at this point, though. Do you still feel Caerulo is our best bet, Phoebus?

Why are you asking me? D: I voted completely on gut feelings.

If we're all sitting here voting for, more or less, different people, then we're going to stay deadlocked. I guess at this point I'm willing to vote for Caerulo on the basis that he just happened to visit Rika on the night Rika disappeared. It's a long shot, but feels more substantial than this awkward flavour juggle we're grappling with right now.

At the same time, I don't feel like moving my vote right away and putting him into insta-gib territory.

Thoughts from Romertien and Othero?

I'll go with my original post in this day, Caerulo has posted like good scum, very helpful, summing up info, and looking harmless. So yeah, seems like a good vote to me.

A Unvote Vote: Caerulo would also be helpful.

Can we get a votecount? I don't want to accidentally lynch somebody.

Looks like we're all considering it, at the least, and this will probably be about as close to consensus as we'll get.

Unvote
Vote: Caerulo

Unofficial vote count:

Caerulo (2): Phoebus, Othero
Othero (1): Romertien
Vendetta (1): Caerulo
Romertien (1): Vendetta

With five alive, it would take 3 to lynch.


Look at it this way. There's probably two scum in the game. If so, any town lynch we do today would lose us the game instantly.
As I've mentioned before, Romertien and I have been confirmed to have targeted Tekora on Night 0.
Unlike Othero's ability, Tekora's ability has been confirmed at his death.
Therefore, at least one scum is among Othero, Phoebus or Vendetta.
Out of the three, Vendetta is the most suspicious.

Also, Othero, isn't being very helpful, summing up info, and looking harmless what a good townie should be doing as well?

Oh well, looks like you guys lynched me.

I was just coming to the thread to unvote too.

I think I know who's the scum, but in the (unlikely) event that the game hasn't ended, I'm gonna keep mum.

Crazy murderous folks jump on Caerulo to throttle him.

"So. What now?"

"I dunno? Something good on TV?"

"Eh. Underworld Revolution. It's just a bunch of werewolves. As if they're real."

Then Vendetta lunges on everyone and eats them.

Werewolf Wins!

Whew, close game.

Caerulo's pretty good at this, and has been a consistent good sport about things. I hope he keeps playing with us!