Umineko Mafia - Night 4

by Furien

Back to The Real World.

Casilu2011-02-02 21:33:20
QUOTE (rika @ Feb 2 2011, 01:23 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Do you believe in magic? tongue.gif


http://goo.gl/s37xm
Sylandra2011-02-02 21:37:09
So to be clear: this Mason group thing doesn't get activated by lynching one of the members, but by the members finding each other? I'm a bit fuzzy on this. dazed.gif

Also: vote count plz? smile.gif
Ileein2011-02-02 21:39:05
QUOTE (Sylandra @ Feb 2 2011, 04:37 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So to be clear: this Mason group thing doesn't get activated by lynching one of the members, but by the members finding each other?


Correct. How long until deadline, anyway? :/
Unknown2011-02-02 22:03:23
I think it's like 3. :\\
Sylandra2011-02-02 22:06:02
Sweet, I'll just be getting out of class then. smile.gif
Unknown2011-02-02 22:17:49
Just popping in to say I'm sticking with my vote and where it is. I hate not saying anything when the deadline is winding down, but I believe I've made my position on things pretty clear for today so unless we find ourselves with some earth-shattering revelations, I'm set.
Unknown2011-02-02 22:18:03
QUOTE (Phoebus @ Feb 2 2011, 05:17 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Just popping in to say I'm sticking with my vote and where it is. I hate not saying anything when the deadline is winding down, but I believe I've made my position on things pretty clear for today so unless we find ourselves with some earth-shattering revelations, I'm set.

P.S. Can we get a votecount?
Unknown2011-02-02 22:30:02
Yes, votecount like at least half an hour before the day ends please. smile.gif
Unknown2011-02-02 23:01:29
Unofficially I get this:


Ileein (2) - Shou, Diamondias
Kiradawea (4) - Rika, Sylandra, Phoebus, Ileein
Silferras (3) - Ssaliss, Casilu, Kiradawea
Gleip2011-02-02 23:33:25
Okay. With all this information running about, I think we'll need a list of what has been clearly claimed.

Kiradawea: Human Eva. One-shot dayvig (used to kill Tekora). Knows that Shulamit/Silferras left her room.
Rika: Kyrie. Bus-driver and Census taker. Took census during day 1 (when?). Claims there are four scum remaining.
Shiri: Was investigator.
Shou: Erika. Investigator. Claims Ileein was culprit.
Ileein: Can't reveal name or die. Part of the Mariage society. Shou says s/he is a culprit.
Shulamit/Silferras: Part of the Mariage society. Targetted Shiri the night Shiri died. Not Beatrice (then who? I'm not familiar with the flavour)

Minor other things claimed by Kira:
Hideyoshi and George are around and town.
Battler is a coroner.
Scum could've identified Shiri as investigator on day one.
Casilu is town.

Anything I missed?
Gleip2011-02-02 23:35:06
QUOTE (AllergictoSabres @ Feb 3 2011, 12:01 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Unofficially I get this:


Ileein (2) - Shou, Diamondias
Kiradawea (4) - Rika, Sylandra, Phoebus, Ileein
Silferras (3) - Ssaliss, Casilu, Kiradawea

Somehow, that doesn't surprise me. evil.gif
Diamondais2011-02-02 23:39:48
For Rika taking census, look for the post where she said flip the chessboard or something, will take a look for it, but poiting you in the direction for now.

I'm fairly certain that Silf is Maria, though she is welcome to correct me. I know which character Ileein is claiming to be, though will respectfully decline from mentioning the name in case of Bad Things.
Unknown2011-02-02 23:40:11
QUOTE (Gleip @ Feb 3 2011, 12:33 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Shulamit/Silferras: Part of the Mariage society. Targetted Shiri the night Shiri died. Not Beatrice (then who? I'm not familiar with the flavour)

If the Mariage follows the lore AND Silf isn't Beatrice, then he has to be Lady Maria as far as my reading tells me.
Gleip2011-02-02 23:41:48
Also, something struck me. If the society is pro town AND get useful townie powers if they find each other, why did neither put forward that information during the previous day?
Rika2011-02-02 23:42:06
Gleip2011-02-02 23:45:17
Okay. So you flipped it after Bernkastel was killed. That's what I need to know.

And I looked over day one again. I might've missed it as it was more of a cursory glance, but I don't recall seeing anyone even mention the society during day one. Can someone confirm/deny that?
Diamondais2011-02-02 23:46:13
QUOTE (Gleip @ Feb 2 2011, 11:41 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Also, something struck me. If the society is pro town AND get useful townie powers if they find each other, why did neither put forward that information during the previous day?

Would you have believed them? Also, if that's the case, why don't we all just roleclaim then? tongue.gif

Easy pickings for scum if that's the case, sure they could've made hints to each other, but it could've just as easily been taken up as suspicious by the rest of us.
Rika2011-02-02 23:46:28
And if they did mention the Mariage Society on day one when there was no pressure on them to claim anything at all, I'm pretty sure you/Kiradawea would have been on their case anyway.
Unknown2011-02-02 23:49:36
Alright, I have to go to class in twenty minutes, and I'll likely still be in class when the deadline hits, so I'm going to go ahead and

## VOTE SILFERRAS

I still think there's something fishy about the mason group. I think that if killing one confirms they're scum, we really win. If killing one confirms they're town, they still have two members and can still obtain their townie powers AND the rest of us have some piece of mind. There's certainly merit in targeting Kiradawea based off of some of her behavior, but I personally feel that the group, if scum, has a greater potential to do harm very soon since it sounds like the assumption is each member gains powers when they find one another.
Gleip2011-02-02 23:51:19
QUOTE (Shiri @ Jan 27 2011, 01:17 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Actually, I'm gonna unvote vote: Casilu for now. If anyone other than Kira/Casilu has any knowledge about how any non-town faction works, let's hear it. (I assume there's only the two factions because of the role PM wording but I don't want to jump to conclusions there until night 1 has passed.)

They could've revealed it as a response to this. Even a very cursory mention of the society

"You mean like a society cult or something"

akin to that would've served as a primer for them to discover who they were to one another.