Umineko Mafia - Night 4

by Furien

Back to The Real World.

Kiradawea2011-01-26 15:07:09
Usually boring yes, but I think I've already figured out one role. This shapes up to be a very fun game.
Shiri2011-01-26 15:46:20
Well, have you figured out anything you think you can tell us that will make day 1 go any better than usual?
Kiradawea2011-01-26 16:25:29
Not make it faster no. I've still no good idea on who might be scum, but if I'm correct, Casilu is town.
Shulamit2011-01-26 16:28:09
Just caught up, I was sleeping. Given this is only my second game (and my first ended...shortly...) I'm unsure what I'm suppose to be saying. Hi! I'm not evil? Don't kill me? I love everyone? happy.gif

Tekora2011-01-26 16:28:49
QUOTE (Kiradawea @ Jan 26 2011, 11:25 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Not make it faster no. I've still no good idea on who might be scum, but if I'm correct, Casilu is town.


That's... random. What makes you say that?
Ssaliss2011-01-26 16:30:21
QUOTE (Kiradawea @ Jan 26 2011, 05:25 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Not make it faster no. I've still no good idea on who might be scum, but if I'm correct, Casilu is town.

I'm guessing you based that on the "magic isn't real" part? To me, that was a bit too obvious, so I can't decide if it was a hint towards her actual role or just a red herring...

And if you based it on something else, I've got no clue what.
Kiradawea2011-01-26 16:39:06
I won't say what made me think so yet. Town don't need to know.
Diamondais2011-01-26 16:40:59
There were a couple of people who refused to believe in magic, so wouldn't take at face value.

Sigh, my internet is still on the fritz, so hopefully I can still be around for day one.
Shiri2011-01-26 16:42:13
That could actually be a big honking villain sign.
Kiradawea2011-01-26 17:00:16
QUOTE (Shiri @ Jan 26 2011, 05:42 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
That could actually be a big honking villain sign.

Not believing in magic? Might be. But that's not it.
Kiradawea2011-01-26 17:04:59
As in, no, it was not the "I don't believe in magic" quote that is making me think Casi is town. Could be Butler or however you spell his name, could not. But there is something else too.
Ileein2011-01-26 17:05:27
As far as I can tell, 'not believing in magic' is the key aspect of the protagonist of the source material That said, obviously it's rather silly to trust these things at this point. tongue.gif It seems to me that Phoebus had a legitimate reason not to start the game just yet, though normally that's meant to be a scum tell. But since Kira says Casilu's probably town, I won't put my vote there.
Kiradawea2011-01-26 17:11:03
Are you saying you originally planned to vote for Casilu? Why? What was your reasoning?
Ileein2011-01-26 17:14:36
I wasn't seriously, given that this is Day One. However, someone earlier (Gleip?) suggested that she was one of those he viewed with suspicion, and I was agreeing with that-- with the stipulation that your information makes me wary of doing anything more than suspicion at least until further information can be attained.
Kiradawea2011-01-26 17:23:53
Gleip did make some good points yes. Can't really fault you for that. tongue.gif
Casilu2011-01-26 17:37:00
QUOTE (Gleip @ Jan 26 2011, 05:40 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Casilu, I wonder about because she puts a vote on Phoebus because Phoebus was waiting for Sylandra. The forum presence of the Halli-crew suggests that they really are BFF. It makes more sense that she'd choose to wait for her friend, than to play a clever waiting game, trying to draw out a few more minutes of doing... what exactly? Long day benefits town more, and unless scum can talk to each other during the day, a longer day would only make it drag on longer before scum could talk with one another.


It wasn't day yet which means they could most likely talk. Also look at the rules post, scum communication might work differently; I remember that Xavius once had it so the scum could talk during the day.

And as part-member of the Halli-crew, I know how it is. I will, however, be more direct with Phoebus.


Phoebus, did you really stall confirming because of Sylandra?
Tekora2011-01-26 17:46:21
Kira, I don't know why you're trying to get heat on you, but you're coming off as so dodgy that I'm tempted to consider you a Jester until proven otherwise.
Shiri2011-01-26 17:56:38
QUOTE (Ileein @ Jan 26 2011, 05:05 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
As far as I can tell, 'not believing in magic' is the key aspect of the protagonist of the source material That said, obviously it's rather silly to trust these things at this point. tongue.gif It seems to me that Phoebus had a legitimate reason not to start the game just yet, though normally that's meant to be a scum tell. But since Kira says Casilu's probably town, I won't put my vote there.

It's complicated. There are several anti-magic characters who are decidedly not heroic. I don't want to conclude that Casilu is scum or town, because I read that first as some random comment unrelated to Umineko, like "father christmas isn't real, you weirdos."

Maybe wrong though.

But Kira's dubious breadcrumbing is making me skeptical of the whole affair. Unvote, Vote: Kiradawea.
Llandros2011-01-26 18:47:18
FOS Shulamit

She has made two unpromted posts about not being evil
Tekora2011-01-26 18:48:24
QUOTE (Llandros @ Jan 26 2011, 01:47 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
FOS Shulamit

She has made two unpromted posts about not being evil


That's just Shulamit being too nice for her own good, like usual.