Umineko Mafia - Night 4

by Furien

Back to The Real World.

Kiradawea2011-01-27 12:23:43
Town don't need to know. tongue.gif

But seriously, why do you think I'm the one who killed Tekora?
Shiri2011-01-27 12:27:12
I didn't say that. It was a hypothetical, and in that hypothetical anyone on your side could have done it (or it even could have been some random town dayvig that you lucksacked on.)

I kind of want to suggest that with Bernkastel down, IF we have a Dr. Nanjo or other protector role somewhere in the cast, that we keep Casilu safe just for tonight so we have time to figure out what's going on. Particularly check out Kira and Gleip.
Gleip2011-01-27 12:28:31
Your post against Tekora. It wasn't enough to convince me, and I doubt it'd convince many others to vote for him, and certainly not to vig him. Either that person was you, or someone on your team trying to silence Tekora for you.
Kiradawea2011-01-27 12:35:38
It was in response to Gleip's direct question of if I killed Tekora.

So... yes. Yes I did. I'm Eva. Wife of Hideyoshi, mother of George. Both are in this game and town. I had a one-shot hidden dayvig and realized that Tekora was scum by several factors, such as the fact that he wasn't tearing into Shulamit with raaaaaaage like he usually does. So I killed him.

With that said.

Unvote
Vote: Shiri


I earlier all but quoted the town win condition line. I wouldn't know that if I wasn't town. You'll note that on me using the same wording as the win condition line. You of all people should notice that.
Shiri2011-01-27 12:39:00
Ok, Eva with dayvig checks out. Unvote. There's no reason to assert you wouldn't have known the town win line though. Scum are often told it directly to prevent people using it as a gimmick (which is why I didn't try at any point.)
Gleip2011-01-27 12:42:01
They do? I haven't seen that happen in any game on the forum thus far.
Kiradawea2011-01-27 12:42:28
Actually

Unvote

I've another trick up my sleeve which I can use to confirm or deconfirm Shiri later.
Diamondais2011-01-27 12:47:49
What the hell has happened since my internet zonked out?
Kiradawea2011-01-27 12:49:59
Day-kill, roleclaim, and a lot of other mess. And I'm having a GREAT time! This is so much more fun than the usual safe play.
Shiri2011-01-27 12:54:05
QUOTE (Gleip @ Jan 27 2011, 12:42 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
They do? I haven't seen that happen in any game on the forum thus far.

There was a couple some time ago, and then for a while we just started posting them right in the thread.

I wouldn't waste that gimmick on me if I were you, but at any rate we need to settle on a new lynch target, and I don't know how much time we have left. I really don't want to get Casilu because Kira has no actual reason to know if Tekora was scum or not even if her roleclaim checks out fine and I want to link up Casilu with Tekora, at least for the time being.

Vote: Phoebus for now since I haven't seen much content out of her.
Ssaliss2011-01-27 13:07:48
So... I go to bed, wake up, and Tekora is dead and Kira has roleclaimed and named two people in the game that could either confirm or deny that? I'm officially confused sad.gif The only thing I'm (somewhat) sure about right now is Kira is town, and most likely in a masonic group with the other two. There hasn't been enough time since the roleclaim though, so saying that Phoebus or Rika are suspicious for not unvoting yet is a bit hasty, but yeah, Phoebus is a bit quieter now than she normally is (I think).
Diamondais2011-01-27 13:14:08
QUOTE (Kiradawea @ Jan 27 2011, 12:17 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
It'd be strange to not have the witches on the witch faction. If I understood the lore correct, there are four (five?) witches? Bernkastel, Lambdadelta, EVA-Beatrice, Virgilia and Beatrice. With a 16 person mafia, 4 scum sounds about right, and we know that both Bernkastel and EVA-Beatrice are around.

Sorry, I need to comment on this. There are more witches, Ange and Maria are also witches, various characters gain or discover powers through the series. This wouldn't be so black and white.
Shiri2011-01-27 13:14:44
Oh, I forgot Maria. But I already said that!
Diamondais2011-01-27 13:18:42
QUOTE (Shiri @ Jan 27 2011, 01:14 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Oh, I forgot Maria. But I already said that!

Oh did you? Well, either way, my point stands, the roles aren't black and white, lets not guess the mod (or the story I suppose since each game plays out rather differently).
Shiri2011-01-27 13:21:56
Anyway, think we need to get votes off Kira and onto Phoebus or another relatively hidey person for now, Kira's claim checks out for now and we'll have time to investigate it later.
Ssaliss2011-01-27 13:27:10
If it came down to it, Phoebus is currently at 1 vote and Kira at 2 votes. It'd be easy for someone to just put another vote on Phoebus to at least make Kira not lynched. There are about 12 hours before the deadline ends though, I think, so it's not super-urgent enough for me to put my vote on her right now.
Kiradawea2011-01-27 13:51:05
QUOTE (diamondais @ Jan 27 2011, 02:14 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Sorry, I need to comment on this. There are more witches, Ange and Maria are also witches, various characters gain or discover powers through the series. This wouldn't be so black and white.

Oh. I don't know the series very well, and those were the only witches I saw constantly referenced to as major players working against the rest.

Also, Gleip has a vote on Rika due to her antics.
Ssaliss2011-01-27 13:55:29
QUOTE (Kiradawea @ Jan 27 2011, 02:51 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Oh. I don't know the series very well, and those were the only witches I saw constantly referenced to as major players working against the rest.

Also, Gleip has a vote on Rika due to her antics.

Ah, right. So plenty of options to make sure you're not lynched then.
Diamondais2011-01-27 14:12:48
What were the reasons to go after Phoebus again? I remember it was because of her not starting right away with the rest of us and waiting for Sylandra, but was there anything else? I find the first reasoning rather silly.

I don't like how Kira has been acting, but for now seems to be part of the town.
Shiri2011-01-27 14:16:31
I have no reasoning other than she hasn't contributed much and I don't want Kira lynched today. If you have a better suggestion I'm open to it.