Okay, I've re-read through the thread, with the magical power of hindsight. Razenth and Ayisdra were the most blatantly scummy (to my perception at least), but lynching them totes didn't pan out at all. By my estimation the next scummiest is Ssaliss, since he was arguing semantics and focusing on pointless nomenclature rather than cutting the crap and just talking straight to Bali. I'm fairly sure Bali's on the down-low (but damn boy, lay off the caffeine). Everyone else seems to be flying below the radar atm. So a FoS @ Ssaliss for the time being. Do we got anything else to go on?

I got nothin' else to add, but would rather say that I have nothing than say nothing and have the thread be like...ghost town.

Can't say I agree with your argument, Jack, since Bali was the one who started talking about Ayisdra being scummy because of his fishing for information, while Bali did the exact same thing.

Oh, and I might be slightly absent over the next 24 hours or so. Just so you know.

Jack's reconstruction for what happened (not so much the reasoning) seems to fit, although I don't see enough in the flavour to determine what kind of group, if any, the scum are in. Frell, this is Casilu running the show. I'm not going to guess the set-up.

But why in Hazmana does it only take four to lynch when there's nine alive?

Huh. I didn't notice that. Wonder if it was a typo or if it actually means something?

Personally, I will assume it's just a typo and that five votes will be required to lynch.

Upon reading through the thread closer, I'm getting more and more suspicious of Bali, to be frank. He started off by posting claims and making a survey. When Ayisdra asked about his claims, he immediately jumped on him and accused him of fishing, despite his own post asking everyone for information. This became even more aggressive towards the end, with that piece of behavior being the focal point of his entire argument: Ayisdra asked for information, so he must be scum. When I pointed it out, he started arguing more and more and tried to make it sound as if his own questions and those of Ayisdras were completely different, and even started throwing personal insults around as if that would make his arguments stronger. It was, apparently, a potent strategy since Vendetta likely killed Ayisdra on his own during the night, but as has been made apparent, Ayisdra was in no way guilty. As such, I will be casting my first vote on Bali for his behavior during the last day.

Vote: Bali

Okay, I didn't like that bandwagon there at all. Vote: Phoebus being the last one to vote.

I think what Ssaliss said makes sense. Totally jumping on that bandwagon.

VOTE: BALI




Also, Phoebus sucks.

Because.

posting restrictions out of the way.

jack's looking pretty scummy(for reasons I will state in a post or two), ayisdra was a terrible player, ssaliss is a moron. im playing two games on mafiascum right now so this one isn't really on my radar - sorry if im flippant. My survey, few points:

I asked what people THINK about their restriction. Not if they had one or not.
I asked what people thought about something JACK SAID.
Last question is somewhat fluff but useful for a few reasons

I even said 'hey you dont have to answer it if you dont want to - though its blatantly pro-town to do so) If you break those down, its hard to say I was role fishing in the sense that Ssaliss thinks I was.

The caliber of players here is so low I wouldn't doubt that we have at least 2-3 scummers on the razenth wagon.

@casilu

how much is flavor apart of the setup? specifically, are your death messages meaningful in their relation to roles?

Yotz. Not to raise dren over nothing, but I'd like a confirmation on the voting threshold before putting down my vote.

I've had some other thoughts about Bali, so for now I'll just

Unvote: Bali

The reasons will be posted later, but right now I've got no time to.

Yeah, I was even going to use different death messages based on the scum who did the kill.

yes they are meaningful

or

no they aren't meaningful

i didnt ask for lip pleb

or were you not being sarcastic?

woops, forgot my posting restriction.

oh well.

I actually started writing my post before I would have been the last one. By the time I submitted it, Llesvelt had voted too, and mine ended up pushing it over the limit.

Also Bali can you sit the down and stop being such a about everything? I dealt with people more tolerable than you during my stint as a dedicated moderator on /b/.