Super Mario RPG -- The Mafia Game!

by Unknown

Back to The Real World.

Diamondais2008-12-12 16:11:59
Interesting turn of events, I'll hold off from voting on Daganev because I'm unsure of the change in teams. If Celina is yoshi, she doesn't warrent a vote for the moment until we're sure and I'd really like to know why Arix was so opposed to ninja-lynches and then participated in one against Celina.

Not liking the Mario team, they're threatening yes but I'm unsure of whether to just to keep an eye out or whether there's actually any real reason to attempt to go after them.
Noola2008-12-12 16:16:37
How are Rogues regular townie? They have a win condition of themselves, don't they? That's what makes them Rogue. Maybe it's the terminology that confuses me?
Morhgor2008-12-12 17:00:52
QUOTE (daganev @ Dec 12 2008, 10:56 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Seriously, its making me sad how easily everyone seems to be fooled to think that Mario's team isn't just a third cult (maybe one of 4 cults?)

I say we get rid of all of the cults, before any of them find everybody and win.


See? Even Daganev agrees with my previous train of thought.

Morhgor2008-12-12 17:01:36
QUOTE (Noola @ Dec 12 2008, 11:16 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
How are Rogues regular townie? They have a win condition of themselves, don't they? That's what makes them Rogue. Maybe it's the terminology that confuses me?


Rogues win by survivng. Everyone else has a 'special' win condition. Being the only team left, etc.
Daganev2008-12-12 18:52:02
Which of the mario members have kill abilities?
which of the axem rangers have kill abilities?
which of smithy's gang have kill abilities?
Noola2008-12-12 19:04:00
QUOTE (Morhgor @ Dec 12 2008, 11:01 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Rogues win by survivng. Everyone else has a 'special' win condition. Being the only team left, etc.



So, that means that Rogues aren't Town because Town wins with Town. Right?
Daganev2008-12-12 19:10:52
QUOTE (Noola @ Dec 12 2008, 11:04 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
So, that means that Rogues aren't Town because Town wins with Town. Right?


Town wins by lynching everybody who has a special win condition.

If all the mafia/cutls are dead, the town wins.

Hence, in this game, Rogues are town. I'm not sure why people fell for Bali's crap.

Vote Bali
Celina2008-12-12 19:22:51
If that were true, then rogues would have a win condition with all the other rogues.

So no, rogues aren't town. They are every man for themselves survivors.
Noola2008-12-12 19:25:11
Something about that seems fishy. But I don't know if it's just that I've only played four games so I don't have the rules down pat yet or not. unsure.gif

But in any case, while Bali is being awfully bossy and so on, I think my vote will stay where it is. I think you'd better hope that a whole boat load of Rogues come along and lynch Bali or whoever quick too cause I have a feeling anyone on a team is gonna be going for you, Daganev, just cause your Arrows ability prevents them from talking to their teammates, from what I've seen so far of what the A abilities are.
Morhgor2008-12-12 19:28:25
QUOTE (Noola @ Dec 12 2008, 02:25 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Something about that seems fishy. But I don't know if it's just that I've only played four games so I don't have the rules down pat yet or not. unsure.gif


Survival seems fishy? twitch.gif
Noola2008-12-12 19:30:11
QUOTE (Morhgor @ Dec 12 2008, 01:28 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Survival seems fishy? twitch.gif



Huh? No, the way he explained how the Rogues are Town seems fishy. laugh.gif
Silvanus2008-12-12 19:34:50
As being somebody with a revive skill, I didn't revive Daganev. So someone else has it.

Also, it says absolutely nothing about the person you revive comes back as a rogue. Daganev still wins with Smithy's Gang, and is now trying to get the rogues together on his side.
Morhgor2008-12-12 19:38:07
QUOTE (Silvanus @ Dec 12 2008, 02:34 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
As being somebody with a revive skill, I didn't revive Daganev. So someone else has it.

Also, it says absolutely nothing about the person you revive comes back as a rogue. Daganev still wins with Smithy's Gang, and is now trying to get the rogues together on his side.


And how do we know we can believe you that it doesn't?

It's your word against Daganev's.
Celina2008-12-12 19:41:24
QUOTE (Morhgor @ Dec 12 2008, 02:38 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
And how do we know we can believe you that it doesn't?

It's your word against Daganev's.


It would be, if it wasn't for Daganev having been part of Smithy's gang in the first place. It's Silvanus's word vs Daganev's word+evidence.
Celina2008-12-12 19:42:01
Oops, Silvanus has the evidence, not Daganev.
Llandros2008-12-12 19:44:46
QUOTE (Silvanus @ Dec 12 2008, 02:34 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
As being somebody with a revive skill, I didn't revive Daganev. So someone else has it.

Also, it says absolutely nothing about the person you revive comes back as a rogue. Daganev still wins with Smithy's Gang, and is now trying to get the rogues together on his side.

Why didn't you revive bowser then? He's on Mario's team, the same as you, and can recruit 3 - 4 rogues to your side. Seems like he would have been pretty handy on your side.
Morhgor2008-12-12 19:45:27
QUOTE (Celina @ Dec 12 2008, 02:41 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
It would be, if it wasn't for Daganev having been part of Smithy's gang in the first place. It's Silvanus's word vs Daganev's word+evidence.


Yeah, Daganev -was- Smithy's gang.

But accord to Dag, he's rogue now. And Silv says that his rez doesn't change alignment.

So it's word vs. word. All previous bets are off.
Morhgor2008-12-12 19:45:55
And Llandros brings up another good point.

>.>
Silvanus2008-12-12 19:49:52
QUOTE (Llandros @ Dec 12 2008, 01:44 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Why didn't you revive bowser then? He's on Mario's team, the same as you, and can recruit 3 - 4 rogues to your side. Seems like he would have been pretty handy on your side.

I choose to not die.
Celina2008-12-12 19:51:29
QUOTE (Morhgor @ Dec 12 2008, 02:45 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Yeah, Daganev -was- Smithy's gang.

But accord to Dag, he's rogue now. And Silv says that his rez doesn't change alignment.

So it's word vs. word. All previous bets are off.


Nah, I don't think it really works like that. You don't get to just say "oh uh..I'm not on a team anymore!" and skip away merrily. The fact that 1) he was on the train to lynchville and 2) he was with a team that was being heavily targeted means he will be saying whatever he has to so he can survive. Considering his role has been posted, he can't plausibly deny who he is, so he made up this "my alignment changed" defense.

It's a little odd that you are falling for his unsubstantiated claim so easily especially considering the previous evidence.

I remember in the X-men game when Jean died and switched alignments and became the pheonix. That was in her role.